Test-Time Adaptation for Depth Completion
2402.03312
0
0
🛸
Abstract
It is common to observe performance degradation when transferring models trained on some (source) datasets to target testing data due to a domain gap between them. Existing methods for bridging this gap, such as domain adaptation (DA), may require the source data on which the model was trained (often not available), while others, i.e., source-free DA, require many passes through the testing data. We propose an online test-time adaptation method for depth completion, the task of inferring a dense depth map from a single image and associated sparse depth map, that closes the performance gap in a single pass. We first present a study on how the domain shift in each data modality affects model performance. Based on our observations that the sparse depth modality exhibits a much smaller covariate shift than the image, we design an embedding module trained in the source domain that preserves a mapping from features encoding only sparse depth to those encoding image and sparse depth. During test time, sparse depth features are projected using this map as a proxy for source domain features and are used as guidance to train a set of auxiliary parameters (i.e., adaptation layer) to align image and sparse depth features from the target test domain to that of the source domain. We evaluate our method on indoor and outdoor scenarios and show that it improves over baselines by an average of 21.1%.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes an online test-time adaptation method for depth completion, which is the task of inferring a dense depth map from a single image and associated sparse depth map.
- The method aims to close the performance gap between models trained on a source dataset and tested on a target dataset, which often suffer from domain shift.
- The key insight is that the sparse depth modality exhibits a much smaller covariate shift than the image modality, so an embedding module is trained in the source domain to preserve a mapping from sparse depth features to those encoding both image and sparse depth.
- During test time, the sparse depth features are projected using this map as a proxy for source domain features and are used to train an adaptation layer that aligns the image and sparse depth features from the target domain to the source domain.
Plain English Explanation
Towards Domain-Agnostic Depth Completion explores a common problem in machine learning: when you train a model on one dataset (the source domain), it often doesn't perform as well when applied to a different dataset (the target domain). This is because there can be a "domain gap" between the datasets, meaning they have different characteristics.
The researchers focused on the task of "depth completion" - taking a sparse depth map (where only some pixels have depth values) and using that along with an image to predict a dense depth map (where all pixels have depth values). They found that the sparse depth information tends to transfer better between domains than the image information.
So, they developed a method that uses the sparse depth features as a proxy for the source domain, and then trains an "adaptation layer" that aligns the target domain features to match the source domain. This allows them to adapt the model to the target domain in a single pass through the test data, without needing access to the original source dataset.
The researchers show that this approach can improve performance by an average of 21.1% compared to other methods, across both indoor and outdoor scenarios. This is a significant improvement and demonstrates the value of their test-time adaptation technique for bridging the domain gap.
Technical Explanation
Towards Domain-Agnostic Depth Completion investigates the problem of performance degradation when transferring models trained on one dataset (the source domain) to a different testing dataset (the target domain). This is a common issue due to the domain gap between the datasets.
The authors propose an online test-time adaptation method for the task of depth completion, which aims to infer a dense depth map from a single image and associated sparse depth map. Their key insight is that the sparse depth modality exhibits a much smaller covariate shift (difference in data distributions) than the image modality when transferring between domains.
To leverage this, the authors first train an embedding module in the source domain that preserves a mapping from features encoding only sparse depth to those encoding both image and sparse depth. During test time on the target domain, the sparse depth features are projected using this map as a proxy for source domain features. These proxy features are then used to train an adaptation layer that aligns the image and sparse depth features from the target domain to the source domain.
The authors evaluate their method on both indoor and outdoor depth completion scenarios, and show that it improves over baselines by an average of 21.1%. This demonstrates the effectiveness of their test-time adaptation approach in bridging the performance gap between source and target domains without requiring access to the original source data.
Critical Analysis
The Towards Domain-Agnostic Depth Completion paper presents a novel and promising approach to addressing domain shift in depth completion tasks. The key strength is the insight that the sparse depth modality exhibits a smaller covariate shift than the image modality, which allows the method to adapt effectively using only the sparse depth features as a proxy for the source domain.
However, the paper does not explore the limitations of this approach in depth. For example, it's unclear how well the method would perform if the domain shift in the sparse depth maps was more significant, or if the image and sparse depth modalities were more tightly coupled. Additionally, the evaluation is limited to indoor and outdoor scenarios, and it would be interesting to see how the method generalizes to other types of domain shifts.
Another potential concern is the computational overhead of training the adaptation layer during test time. While the authors claim this can be done in a single pass, the impact on inference time and overall model complexity is not quantified.
Overall, the Towards Domain-Agnostic Depth Completion paper presents a promising approach, but further research is needed to fully understand its capabilities and limitations. Readers are encouraged to think critically about the tradeoffs and consider how the method might be applied or extended in their own work.
Conclusion
Towards Domain-Agnostic Depth Completion proposes an innovative test-time adaptation method for depth completion that can significantly improve performance when transferring models between different datasets. The key insight is to leverage the sparse depth modality, which exhibits a smaller covariate shift, as a proxy for the source domain features during adaptation.
This work demonstrates the value of understanding the underlying data characteristics and modalities when addressing domain shift, and suggests that targeted adaptation strategies can be more effective than generic domain adaptation techniques. The authors' approach of aligning target domain features to the source domain in a single pass is a compelling solution that could have broad applicability beyond depth completion.
As depth sensing and 3D perception continue to advance, techniques like this that can robustly handle domain shifts will become increasingly important. The Towards Domain-Agnostic Depth Completion paper represents an important step forward in this direction, and serves as a valuable reference for researchers and practitioners working on related problems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🧪
Towards Domain-agnostic Depth Completion
Guangkai Xu, Wei Yin, Jianming Zhang, Oliver Wang, Simon Niklaus, Simon Chen, Jia-Wang Bian
0
0
Existing depth completion methods are often targeted at a specific sparse depth type and generalize poorly across task domains. We present a method to complete sparse/semi-dense, noisy, and potentially low-resolution depth maps obtained by various range sensors, including those in modern mobile phones, or by multi-view reconstruction algorithms. Our method leverages a data-driven prior in the form of a single image depth prediction network trained on large-scale datasets, the output of which is used as an input to our model. We propose an effective training scheme where we simulate various sparsity patterns in typical task domains. In addition, we design two new benchmarks to evaluate the generalizability and the robustness of depth completion methods. Our simple method shows superior cross-domain generalization ability against state-of-the-art depth completion methods, introducing a practical solution to high-quality depth capture on a mobile device. The code is available at: https://github.com/YvanYin/FillDepth.
4/9/2024
Domain-Transferred Synthetic Data Generation for Improving Monocular Depth Estimation
Seungyeop Lee, Knut Peterson, Solmaz Arezoomandan, Bill Cai, Peihan Li, Lifeng Zhou, David Han
0
0
A major obstacle to the development of effective monocular depth estimation algorithms is the difficulty in obtaining high-quality depth data that corresponds to collected RGB images. Collecting this data is time-consuming and costly, and even data collected by modern sensors has limited range or resolution, and is subject to inconsistencies and noise. To combat this, we propose a method of data generation in simulation using 3D synthetic environments and CycleGAN domain transfer. We compare this method of data generation to the popular NYUDepth V2 dataset by training a depth estimation model based on the DenseDepth structure using different training sets of real and simulated data. We evaluate the performance of the models on newly collected images and LiDAR depth data from a Husky robot to verify the generalizability of the approach and show that GAN-transformed data can serve as an effective alternative to real-world data, particularly in depth estimation.
5/3/2024
All-day Depth Completion
Vadim Ezhov, Hyoungseob Park, Zhaoyang Zhang, Rishi Upadhyay, Howard Zhang, Chethan Chinder Chandrappa, Achuta Kadambi, Yunhao Ba, Julie Dorsey, Alex Wong
0
0
We propose a method for depth estimation under different illumination conditions, i.e., day and night time. As photometry is uninformative in regions under low-illumination, we tackle the problem through a multi-sensor fusion approach, where we take as input an additional synchronized sparse point cloud (i.e., from a LiDAR) projected onto the image plane as a sparse depth map, along with a camera image. The crux of our method lies in the use of the abundantly available synthetic data to first approximate the 3D scene structure by learning a mapping from sparse to (coarse) dense depth maps along with their predictive uncertainty - we term this, SpaDe. In poorly illuminated regions where photometric intensities do not afford the inference of local shape, the coarse approximation of scene depth serves as a prior; the uncertainty map is then used with the image to guide refinement through an uncertainty-driven residual learning (URL) scheme. The resulting depth completion network leverages complementary strengths from both modalities - depth is sparse but insensitive to illumination and in metric scale, and image is dense but sensitive with scale ambiguity. SpaDe can be used in a plug-and-play fashion, which allows for 25% improvement when augmented onto existing methods to preprocess sparse depth. We demonstrate URL on the nuScenes dataset where we improve over all baselines by an average 11.65% in all-day scenarios, 11.23% when tested specifically for daytime, and 13.12% for nighttime scenes.
5/28/2024
🧠
Do More With What You Have: Transferring Depth-Scale from Labeled to Unlabeled Domains
Alexandra Dana, Nadav Carmel, Amit Shomer, Ofer Manela, Tomer Peleg
0
0
Transferring the absolute depth prediction capabilities of an estimator to a new domain is a task with significant real-world applications. This task is specifically challenging when images from the new domain are collected without ground-truth depth measurements, and possibly with sensors of different intrinsics. To overcome such limitations, a recent zero-shot solution was trained on an extensive training dataset and encoded the various camera intrinsics. Other solutions generated synthetic data with depth labels that matched the intrinsics of the new target data to enable depth-scale transfer between the domains. In this work we present an alternative solution that can utilize any existing synthetic or real dataset, that has a small number of images annotated with ground truth depth labels. Specifically, we show that self-supervised depth estimators result in up-to-scale predictions that are linearly correlated to their absolute depth values across the domain, a property that we model in this work using a single scalar. In addition, aligning the field-of-view of two datasets prior to training, results in a common linear relationship for both domains. We use this observed property to transfer the depth-scale from source datasets that have absolute depth labels to new target datasets that lack these measurements, enabling absolute depth predictions in the target domain. The suggested method was successfully demonstrated on the KITTI, DDAD and nuScenes datasets, while using other existing real or synthetic source datasets, that have a different field-of-view, other image style or structural content, achieving comparable or better accuracy than other existing methods that do not use target ground-truth depths.
4/16/2024