On the Theory of Risk-Aware Agents: Bridging Actor-Critic and Economics
2310.19527
0
0
ā
Abstract
Risk-aware Reinforcement Learning (RL) algorithms like SAC and TD3 were shown empirically to outperform their risk-neutral counterparts in a variety of continuous-action tasks. However, the theoretical basis for the pessimistic objectives these algorithms employ remains unestablished, raising questions about the specific class of policies they are implementing. In this work, we apply the expected utility hypothesis, a fundamental concept in economics, to illustrate that both risk-neutral and risk-aware RL goals can be interpreted through expected utility maximization using an exponential utility function. This approach reveals that risk-aware policies effectively maximize value certainty equivalent, aligning them with conventional decision theory principles. Furthermore, we propose Dual Actor-Critic (DAC). DAC is a risk-aware, model-free algorithm that features two distinct actor networks: a pessimistic actor for temporal-difference learning and an optimistic actor for exploration. Our evaluations of DAC across various locomotion and manipulation tasks demonstrate improvements in sample efficiency and final performance. Remarkably, DAC, while requiring significantly less computational resources, matches the performance of leading model-based methods in the complex dog and humanoid domains.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the theoretical and practical aspects of risk-aware reinforcement learning (RL) algorithms.
- It shows that both risk-neutral and risk-aware RL goals can be interpreted through expected utility maximization using an exponential utility function.
- The authors propose a new algorithm called Dual Actor-Critic (DAC) that features two distinct actor networks: a pessimistic actor for temporal-difference learning and an optimistic actor for exploration.
- Evaluations of DAC across various tasks demonstrate improvements in sample efficiency and final performance, even matching the performance of leading model-based methods in complex domains.
Plain English Explanation
Reinforcement learning (RL) is a type of machine learning where an agent learns to make decisions by interacting with an environment and receiving rewards or penalties. Traditional RL algorithms aim to maximize the total expected reward, which can be considered a "risk-neutral" approach.
However, Risk-aware Reinforcement Learning (RL) algorithms like SAC and TD3 were found to outperform their risk-neutral counterparts in certain tasks. These risk-aware algorithms use "pessimistic" objectives, meaning they focus on minimizing the potential for negative outcomes.
This paper shows that both risk-neutral and risk-aware RL goals can be interpreted using a fundamental economic concept called the "expected utility hypothesis." This approach reveals that risk-aware policies effectively maximize the "value certainty equivalent," which aligns with conventional decision theory principles.
The authors then propose a new algorithm called Dual Actor-Critic (DAC) that has two distinct actor networks: a pessimistic actor for learning and an optimistic actor for exploration. Evaluations of DAC across various tasks, including complex locomotion and manipulation tasks, demonstrate improvements in sample efficiency and performance, even matching the capabilities of leading model-based methods while requiring significantly less computational resources.
Technical Explanation
The paper first establishes the theoretical foundation for risk-aware RL by applying the expected utility hypothesis, a fundamental concept in economics. This approach reveals that both risk-neutral and risk-aware RL objectives can be interpreted as expected utility maximization using an exponential utility function.
The authors then introduce the Dual Actor-Critic (DAC) algorithm, which features two distinct actor networks: a pessimistic actor network for temporal-difference learning and an optimistic actor network for exploration. This dual-actor architecture allows DAC to effectively balance exploration and exploitation, leading to improved sample efficiency and final performance.
Experiments across various continuous-action tasks, including complex locomotion and manipulation domains, demonstrate the effectiveness of DAC. Remarkably, DAC is able to match the performance of leading model-based methods, such as Diffusion Actor-Critic with Entropy Regulator and RACER, while requiring significantly less computational resources.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a strong theoretical foundation for risk-aware RL by linking it to the expected utility hypothesis, a well-established concept in economics. This connection helps to solidify the principles underlying risk-aware algorithms and aligns them with conventional decision theory.
However, the paper does not delve into the specific limitations or trade-offs of the proposed Dual Actor-Critic (DAC) algorithm. For example, it would be valuable to understand how DAC's performance compares to other state-of-the-art risk-aware RL algorithms, such as Taming Equilibrium Bias in Risk-Sensitive Multi-Agent Systems, in terms of stability, convergence, and computational efficiency.
Additionally, the paper could benefit from a more in-depth discussion of the potential challenges or drawbacks of the dual-actor architecture, as well as the specific scenarios where this approach may be most advantageous compared to other risk-aware RL methods.
Conclusion
This paper makes significant contributions to the understanding and development of risk-aware reinforcement learning. By grounding risk-aware RL objectives in the expected utility hypothesis, the authors provide a theoretical framework that helps to solidify the principles behind these algorithms.
The introduction of the Dual Actor-Critic (DAC) algorithm, which combines a pessimistic actor for learning and an optimistic actor for exploration, represents a practical application of these insights. The empirical results demonstrating DAC's improvements in sample efficiency and performance, even matching the capabilities of leading model-based methods, suggest that this approach holds promise for advancing the field of risk-aware RL.
As the research in this area continues to evolve, further exploration of the limitations, trade-offs, and potential applications of risk-aware RL algorithms like DAC will be important for fully realizing their benefits and guiding the development of even more robust and efficient reinforcement learning systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
š¤·
PAC-Bayesian Soft Actor-Critic Learning
Bahareh Tasdighi, Abdullah Akgul, Manuel Haussmann, Kenny Kazimirzak Brink, Melih Kandemir
0
0
Actor-critic algorithms address the dual goals of reinforcement learning (RL), policy evaluation and improvement via two separate function approximators. The practicality of this approach comes at the expense of training instability, caused mainly by the destructive effect of the approximation errors of the critic on the actor. We tackle this bottleneck by employing an existing Probably Approximately Correct (PAC) Bayesian bound for the first time as the critic training objective of the Soft Actor-Critic (SAC) algorithm. We further demonstrate that online learning performance improves significantly when a stochastic actor explores multiple futures by critic-guided random search. We observe our resulting algorithm to compare favorably against the state-of-the-art SAC implementation on multiple classical control and locomotion tasks in terms of both sample efficiency and regret.
6/11/2024
Exploring Pessimism and Optimism Dynamics in Deep Reinforcement Learning
Bahareh Tasdighi, Nicklas Werge, Yi-Shan Wu, Melih Kandemir
0
0
Off-policy actor-critic algorithms have shown promise in deep reinforcement learning for continuous control tasks. Their success largely stems from leveraging pessimistic state-action value function updates, which effectively address function approximation errors and improve performance. However, such pessimism can lead to under-exploration, constraining the agent's ability to explore/refine its policies. Conversely, optimism can counteract under-exploration, but it also carries the risk of excessive risk-taking and poor convergence if not properly balanced. Based on these insights, we introduce Utility Soft Actor-Critic (USAC), a novel framework within the actor-critic paradigm that enables independent control over the degree of pessimism/optimism for both the actor and the critic via interpretable parameters. USAC adapts its exploration strategy based on the uncertainty of critics through a utility function that allows us to balance between pessimism and optimism separately. By going beyond binary choices of optimism and pessimism, USAC represents a significant step towards achieving balance within off-policy actor-critic algorithms. Our experiments across various continuous control problems show that the degree of pessimism or optimism depends on the nature of the task. Furthermore, we demonstrate that USAC can outperform state-of-the-art algorithms for appropriately configured pessimism/optimism parameters.
6/7/2024
Actor-Critic Reinforcement Learning with Phased Actor
Ruofan Wu, Junmin Zhong, Jennie Si
0
0
Policy gradient methods in actor-critic reinforcement learning (RL) have become perhaps the most promising approaches to solving continuous optimal control problems. However, the trial-and-error nature of RL and the inherent randomness associated with solution approximations cause variations in the learned optimal values and policies. This has significantly hindered their successful deployment in real life applications where control responses need to meet dynamic performance criteria deterministically. Here we propose a novel phased actor in actor-critic (PAAC) method, aiming at improving policy gradient estimation and thus the quality of the control policy. Specifically, PAAC accounts for both $Q$ value and TD error in its actor update. We prove qualitative properties of PAAC for learning convergence of the value and policy, solution optimality, and stability of system dynamics. Additionally, we show variance reduction in policy gradient estimation. PAAC performance is systematically and quantitatively evaluated in this study using DeepMind Control Suite (DMC). Results show that PAAC leads to significant performance improvement measured by total cost, learning variance, robustness, learning speed and success rate. As PAAC can be piggybacked onto general policy gradient learning frameworks, we select well-known methods such as direct heuristic dynamic programming (dHDP), deep deterministic policy gradient (DDPG) and their variants to demonstrate the effectiveness of PAAC. Consequently we provide a unified view on these related policy gradient algorithms.
4/19/2024
Diffusion Actor-Critic with Entropy Regulator
Yinuo Wang, Likun Wang, Yuxuan Jiang, Wenjun Zou, Tong Liu, Xujie Song, Wenxuan Wang, Liming Xiao, Jiang Wu, Jingliang Duan, Shengbo Eben Li
0
0
Reinforcement learning (RL) has proven highly effective in addressing complex decision-making and control tasks. However, in most traditional RL algorithms, the policy is typically parameterized as a diagonal Gaussian distribution with learned mean and variance, which constrains their capability to acquire complex policies. In response to this problem, we propose an online RL algorithm termed diffusion actor-critic with entropy regulator (DACER). This algorithm conceptualizes the reverse process of the diffusion model as a novel policy function and leverages the capability of the diffusion model to fit multimodal distributions, thereby enhancing the representational capacity of the policy. Since the distribution of the diffusion policy lacks an analytical expression, its entropy cannot be determined analytically. To mitigate this, we propose a method to estimate the entropy of the diffusion policy utilizing Gaussian mixture model. Building on the estimated entropy, we can learn a parameter $alpha$ that modulates the degree of exploration and exploitation. Parameter $alpha$ will be employed to adaptively regulate the variance of the added noise, which is applied to the action output by the diffusion model. Experimental trials on MuJoCo benchmarks and a multimodal task demonstrate that the DACER algorithm achieves state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance in most MuJoCo control tasks while exhibiting a stronger representational capacity of the diffusion policy.
6/18/2024