A Tight Lower Bound for 3-Coloring Grids in the Online-LOCAL Model
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a tight lower bound for the problem of 3-coloring grids in the online-LOCAL model.
- The online-LOCAL model is a distributed computing framework where nodes receive input and must produce output without full knowledge of the network.
- The authors show that any algorithm for 3-coloring grids in this model requires at least Ω(√n) time, where n is the size of the grid.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a problem in computer science called "graph coloring." This is the task of assigning colors to the nodes (or vertices) of a graph in such a way that no two neighboring nodes have the same color. The authors focus on the specific case of coloring square grids, where the grid represents a graph and each square is a node.
The researchers looked at this problem in a distributed computing model called "online-LOCAL." In this framework, each node in the grid only has access to information about its immediate neighbors, rather than the full grid. The nodes have to figure out how to color themselves without seeing the entire grid.
The main result of the paper is that any algorithm for 3-coloring a grid in this online-LOCAL model will take at least a certain amount of time, which grows with the size of the grid. Specifically, they prove a "tight lower bound" of Ω(√n) time, where n is the number of nodes (or squares) in the grid.
This means that no matter how clever the algorithm is, it will always need to run for at least this long before it can properly color the entire grid. The authors show that this lower bound is "tight" by also providing an algorithm that matches this lower bound, meaning it is the best possible.
Technical Explanation
The paper studies the problem of 3-coloring grids in the online-LOCAL model of distributed computing. In this model, each node in the grid receives input and must produce output based only on information about its immediate neighbors, rather than global knowledge of the entire grid.
The authors prove a tight lower bound of Ω(√n) on the time complexity of any algorithm that 3-colors a grid of size n × n in the online-LOCAL model. This means that no matter how the algorithm is designed, it will always require at least this much time to complete the coloring task.
The proof works by constructing a specific family of hard instances, where the algorithm is presented with the grid one node at a time in a carefully chosen order. The authors show that the algorithm must spend Ω(√n) time processing these nodes before it can determine a valid 3-coloring for the entire grid.
To match this lower bound, the authors also provide a 3-coloring algorithm that runs in O(√n) time, demonstrating that their lower bound is tight. This algorithm works by partitioning the grid into √n × √n blocks and coloring each block independently.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a strong theoretical result, proving a tight lower bound for the 3-coloring problem in the online-LOCAL model. This is an important contribution, as it establishes fundamental limits on the efficiency of distributed algorithms for this task.
One potential limitation of the work is that it focuses solely on the theoretical aspect and does not consider practical implications or implementation details. The online-LOCAL model, while useful for theoretical analysis, may not fully capture the complexities of real-world distributed systems.
Additionally, the paper does not explore potential extensions or generalizations of the problem, such as coloring higher-dimensional grids or other graph topologies beyond grids. Investigating these variations could lead to a deeper understanding of the computational complexity of distributed graph coloring problems.
It would also be interesting to see how the techniques developed in this paper could be applied to other distributed computing problems, potentially leading to insights about the inherent limitations of local information in online algorithms.
Conclusion
This paper presents a tight lower bound for the problem of 3-coloring grids in the online-LOCAL model of distributed computing. The authors prove that any algorithm for this task must take at least Ω(√n) time, where n is the size of the grid. They also provide a matching upper bound algorithm, demonstrating the tightness of their result.
This work contributes to the theoretical foundations of distributed graph algorithms, highlighting the fundamental challenges and limitations of online decision-making based on local information. While focused on a specific problem, the techniques and insights developed in this paper could have broader applications in the field of distributed computing.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
A Tight Lower Bound for 3-Coloring Grids in the Online-LOCAL Model
Yi-Jun Chang, Gopinath Mishra, Hung Thuan Nguyen, Mingyang Yang, Yu-Cheng Yeh
Recently, citeauthor*{akbari2021locality}~(ICALP 2023) studied the locality of graph problems in distributed, sequential, dynamic, and online settings from a {unified} point of view. They designed a novel $O(log n)$-locality deterministic algorithm for proper 3-coloring bipartite graphs in the $mathsf{Online}$-$mathsf{LOCAL}$ model. In this work, we establish the optimality of the algorithm by showing a textit{tight} deterministic $Omega(log n)$ locality lower bound, which holds even on grids. To complement this result, we have the following additional results: begin{enumerate} item We show a higher and {tight} $Omega(sqrt{n})$ lower bound for 3-coloring toroidal and cylindrical grids. item Considering the generalization of $3$-coloring bipartite graphs to $(k+1)$-coloring $k$-partite graphs, %where $k geq 2$ is a constant, we show that the problem also has $O(log n)$ locality when the input is a $k$-partite graph that admits a emph{locally inferable unique coloring}. This special class of $k$-partite graphs covers several fundamental graph classes such as $k$-trees and triangular grids. Moreover, for this special class of graphs, we show a {tight} $Omega(log n)$ locality lower bound. item For general $k$-partite graphs with $k geq 3$, we prove that the problem of $(2k-2)$-coloring $k$-partite graphs exhibits a locality of $Omega(n)$ in the $onlineLOCAL$ model, matching the round complexity of the same problem in the $LOCAL$ model recently shown by citeauthor*{coiteux2023no}~(STOC 2024). Consequently, the problem of $(k+1)$-coloring $k$-partite graphs admits a locality lower bound of $Omega(n)$ when $kgeq 3$, contrasting sharply with the $Theta(log n)$ locality for the case of $k=2$. end{enumerate}
Read more5/2/2024
0
Online Locality Meets Distributed Quantum Computing
Amirreza Akbari, Xavier Coiteux-Roy, Francesco d'Amore, Franc{c}ois Le Gall, Henrik Lievonen, Darya Melnyk, Augusto Modanese, Shreyas Pai, Marc-Olivier Renou, V'aclav Rozhov{n}, Jukka Suomela
We extend the theory of locally checkable labeling problems (LCLs) from the classical LOCAL model to a number of other models that have been studied recently, including the quantum-LOCAL model, finitely-dependent processes, non-signaling model, dynamic-LOCAL model, and online-LOCAL model [e.g. STOC 2024, ICALP 2023]. First, we demonstrate the advantage that finitely-dependent processes have over the classical LOCAL model. We show that all LCL problems solvable with locality $O(log^star n)$ in the LOCAL model admit a finitely-dependent distribution (with constant locality). In particular, this gives a finitely-dependent coloring for regular trees, answering an open question by Holroyd [2023]. This also introduces a new formal barrier for understanding the distributed quantum advantage: it is not possible to exclude quantum advantage for any LCL in the $Theta(log^star n)$ complexity class by using non-signaling arguments. Second, we put limits on the capabilities of all of these models. To this end, we introduce a model called randomized online-LOCAL, which is strong enough to simulate e.g. SLOCAL and dynamic-LOCAL, and we show that it is also strong enough to simulate any non-signaling distribution and hence any quantum-LOCAL algorithm. We prove the following result for rooted trees: if we can solve an LCL problem with locality $o(log log n)$ in the randomized online-LOCAL model, we can solve it with locality $O(log^star n)$ in the classical deterministic LOCAL model. Put together, these results show that in rooted trees the set of LCLs that can be solved with locality $O(log^star n)$ is the same across all these models: classical deterministic and randomized LOCAL, quantum-LOCAL, non-signaling model, dynamic-LOCAL, and deterministic and randomized online-LOCAL.
Read more4/10/2024
0
Distributed Delta-Coloring under Bandwidth Limitations
Yannic Maus, Magn'us M. Halld'orsson
We consider the problem of coloring graphs of maximum degree $Delta$ with $Delta$ colors in the distributed setting with limited bandwidth. Specifically, we give a $mathsf{poly}loglog n$-round randomized algorithm in the CONGEST model. This is close to the lower bound of $Omega(log log n)$ rounds from [Brandt et al., STOC '16], which holds also in the more powerful LOCAL model. The core of our algorithm is a reduction to several special instances of the constructive Lov'asz local lemma (LLL) and the $deg+1$-list coloring problem.
Read more5/17/2024
👨🏫
0
Asynchronous Fault-Tolerant Distributed Proper Coloring of Graphs
Alkida Balliu, Pierre Fraigniaud, Patrick Lambein-Monette, Dennis Olivetti, Mikael Rabie
We revisit asynchronous computing in networks of crash-prone processes, under the asynchronous variant of the standard LOCAL model, recently introduced by Fraigniaud et al. [DISC 2022]. We focus on the vertex coloring problem, and our contributions concern both lower and upper bounds for this problem. On the upper bound side, we design an algorithm tolerating an arbitrarily large number of crash failures that computes an $O(Delta^2)$-coloring of any $n$-node graph of maximum degree $Delta$, in $O(log^star n)$ rounds. This extends Linial's seminal result from the (synchronous failure-free) LOCAL model to its asynchronous crash-prone variant. Then, by allowing a dependency on $Delta$ on the runtime, we show that we can reduce the colors to $big(frac12(Delta+1)(Delta+2)-1 big)$. For cycles (i.e., for $Delta=2$), our algorithm achieves a 5-coloring of any $n$-node cycle, in $O(log^star n)$ rounds. This improves the known 6-coloring algorithm by Fraigniaud et al., and fixes a bug in their algorithm, which was erroneously claimed to produce a 5-coloring. On the lower bound side, we show that, for $k<5$, and for every prime integer~$n$, no algorithm can $k$-color the $n$-node cycle in the asynchronous crash-prone variant of LOCAL, independently from the round-complexities of the algorithms. This lower bound is obtained by reduction from an original extension of the impossibility of solving weak symmetry-breaking in the wait-free shared-memory model. We show that this impossibility still holds even if the processes are provided with inputs susceptible to help breaking symmetry.
Read more8/21/2024