Tolerance of Reinforcement Learning Controllers against Deviations in Cyber Physical Systems
2406.17066
0
0
Abstract
Cyber-physical systems (CPS) with reinforcement learning (RL)-based controllers are increasingly being deployed in complex physical environments such as autonomous vehicles, the Internet-of-Things(IoT), and smart cities. An important property of a CPS is tolerance; i.e., its ability to function safely under possible disturbances and uncertainties in the actual operation. In this paper, we introduce a new, expressive notion of tolerance that describes how well a controller is capable of satisfying a desired system requirement, specified using Signal Temporal Logic (STL), under possible deviations in the system. Based on this definition, we propose a novel analysis problem, called the tolerance falsification problem, which involves finding small deviations that result in a violation of the given requirement. We present a novel, two-layer simulation-based analysis framework and a novel search heuristic for finding small tolerance violations. To evaluate our approach, we construct a set of benchmark problems where system parameters can be configured to represent different types of uncertainties and disturbancesin the system. Our evaluation shows that our falsification approach and heuristic can effectively find small tolerance violations.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper examines the tolerance of reinforcement learning (RL) controllers against deviations in cyber-physical systems (CPS).
- The researchers investigate how RL controllers can maintain stable and reliable performance even when faced with changes or disturbances in the system.
- They propose a framework for analyzing the robustness of RL controllers and conduct experiments to assess their tolerance to various types of deviations.
Plain English Explanation
Cyber-physical systems (CPS) are systems that combine physical components, like sensors and actuators, with computational elements, like computers and software. These systems are used in many industries, from manufacturing to transportation. Reinforcement learning (RL) is a type of machine learning that can be used to control CPS, helping them adapt to changing conditions.
In this paper, the researchers explore how well RL controllers can handle deviations or changes in the CPS they are controlling. For example, if a sensor in the system starts providing inaccurate data, or if the physical environment changes in an unexpected way, how well can the RL controller continue to maintain stable and reliable performance?
The researchers develop a framework to analyze the robustness of RL controllers, and they conduct experiments to see how the controllers respond to different types of deviations. This helps them understand the strengths and limitations of RL controllers in CPS applications, which is important for ensuring the safety and reliability of these systems.
Overall, this research aims to improve our understanding of how RL controllers can be made more resilient and adaptable, which is crucial as these technologies become more widely adopted in real-world, safety-critical systems.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a framework for analyzing the tolerance of reinforcement learning (RL) controllers against deviations in cyber-physical systems (CPS). The researchers develop a methodology to quantify the robustness of RL controllers by introducing various types of deviations, such as sensor noise, parameter changes, and external disturbances, and measuring the controller's ability to maintain stable and reliable performance.
The proposed framework consists of three main components: (1) a CPS model that captures the dynamics of the physical system and the control loop, (2) an RL controller that learns an optimal policy for controlling the CPS, and (3) a deviation model that introduces disturbances and changes to the CPS.
The researchers conduct experiments using this framework to assess the tolerance of RL controllers against different types of deviations. They consider a range of scenarios, including sensor noise, parameter changes, and external disturbances, and evaluate the controllers' performance in terms of stability, tracking accuracy, and energy efficiency.
The experimental results demonstrate that RL controllers can exhibit varying levels of tolerance to different types of deviations, depending on the specific characteristics of the CPS and the nature of the disturbances. The researchers identify key factors that influence the robustness of RL controllers, such as the complexity of the control task, the training data used, and the design of the RL algorithm.
The findings of this research contribute to the ongoing efforts to improve the reliability and safety of RL-based control systems in cyber-physical applications. The proposed framework and insights can inform the development of more robust and adaptive RL controllers that can better withstand the challenges posed by real-world deviations in CPS.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive framework for analyzing the tolerance of reinforcement learning (RL) controllers against deviations in cyber-physical systems (CPS). The researchers have carefully designed their experiments to cover a wide range of potential deviations, including sensor noise, parameter changes, and external disturbances, which is a strength of the study.
However, the paper does not extensively discuss the limitations of the proposed framework or the potential challenges in applying it to real-world CPS. For example, the paper does not address how the framework might scale to larger, more complex systems or how it could handle more diverse types of deviations that may arise in practice.
Additionally, the paper could benefit from a more in-depth discussion of the trade-offs and design choices involved in the RL controller development, such as the selection of the RL algorithm, the hyperparameter tuning, and the handling of exploration-exploitation dynamics. These factors can significantly impact the robustness of the RL controller and should be considered in the analysis.
Furthermore, the paper could explore the potential for synergies between the RL controller and other control techniques, such as Distributionally Robust Policy with Lyapunov Certificate Learning or ISAACS: Iterative Soft Adversarial Actor-Critic for Safety, to further enhance the tolerance and reliability of the overall control system.
Despite these minor limitations, the paper presents a valuable contribution to the field of RL-based control in CPS, and the proposed framework and insights can serve as a foundation for future research in this area.
Conclusion
This paper investigates the tolerance of reinforcement learning (RL) controllers against deviations in cyber-physical systems (CPS). The researchers develop a comprehensive framework for analyzing the robustness of RL controllers by introducing various types of disturbances and changes to the CPS and measuring the controller's ability to maintain stable and reliable performance.
The experimental results demonstrate that RL controllers can exhibit varying levels of tolerance to different types of deviations, depending on the characteristics of the CPS and the nature of the disturbances. The findings of this research contribute to the ongoing efforts to improve the reliability and safety of RL-based control systems in CPS applications, which is crucial as these technologies become more widely adopted in real-world, safety-critical systems.
The insights from this paper can inform the design and development of more robust and adaptive RL controllers that can better withstand the challenges posed by deviations in cyber-physical systems. Further research in this area, exploring synergies with other control techniques and addressing the limitations identified in the paper, can help advance the state-of-the-art in RL-based control for safety-critical applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
👨🏫
Intrusion Tolerance for Networked Systems through Two-Level Feedback Control
Kim Hammar, Rolf Stadler
0
0
We formulate intrusion tolerance for a system with service replicas as a two-level optimal control problem. On the local level node controllers perform intrusion recovery, and on the global level a system controller manages the replication factor. The local and global control problems can be formulated as classical problems in operations research, namely, the machine replacement problem and the inventory replenishment problem. Based on this formulation, we design TOLERANCE, a novel control architecture for intrusion-tolerant systems. We prove that the optimal control strategies on both levels have threshold structure and design efficient algorithms for computing them. We implement and evaluate TOLERANCE in an emulation environment where we run 10 types of network intrusions. The results show that TOLERANCE can improve service availability and reduce operational cost compared with state-of-the-art intrusion-tolerant systems.
6/6/2024
🧪
Testing learning-enabled cyber-physical systems with Large-Language Models: A Formal Approach
Xi Zheng, Aloysius K. Mok, Ruzica Piskac, Yong Jae Lee, Bhaskar Krishnamachari, Dakai Zhu, Oleg Sokolsky, Insup Lee
0
0
The integration of machine learning (ML) into cyber-physical systems (CPS) offers significant benefits, including enhanced efficiency, predictive capabilities, real-time responsiveness, and the enabling of autonomous operations. This convergence has accelerated the development and deployment of a range of real-world applications, such as autonomous vehicles, delivery drones, service robots, and telemedicine procedures. However, the software development life cycle (SDLC) for AI-infused CPS diverges significantly from traditional approaches, featuring data and learning as two critical components. Existing verification and validation techniques are often inadequate for these new paradigms. In this study, we pinpoint the main challenges in ensuring formal safety for learningenabled CPS.We begin by examining testing as the most pragmatic method for verification and validation, summarizing the current state-of-the-art methodologies. Recognizing the limitations in current testing approaches to provide formal safety guarantees, we propose a roadmap to transition from foundational probabilistic testing to a more rigorous approach capable of delivering formal assurance.
5/17/2024
Distributionally Robust Policy and Lyapunov-Certificate Learning
Kehan Long, Jorge Cortes, Nikolay Atanasov
0
0
This article presents novel methods for synthesizing distributionally robust stabilizing neural controllers and certificates for control systems under model uncertainty. A key challenge in designing controllers with stability guarantees for uncertain systems is the accurate determination of and adaptation to shifts in model parametric uncertainty during online deployment. We tackle this with a novel distributionally robust formulation of the Lyapunov derivative chance constraint ensuring a monotonic decrease of the Lyapunov certificate. To avoid the computational complexity involved in dealing with the space of probability measures, we identify a sufficient condition in the form of deterministic convex constraints that ensures the Lyapunov derivative constraint is satisfied. We integrate this condition into a loss function for training a neural network-based controller and show that, for the resulting closed-loop system, the global asymptotic stability of its equilibrium can be certified with high confidence, even with Out-of-Distribution (OoD) model uncertainties. To demonstrate the efficacy and efficiency of the proposed methodology, we compare it with an uncertainty-agnostic baseline approach and several reinforcement learning approaches in two control problems in simulation.
4/8/2024
🚀
ISAACS: Iterative Soft Adversarial Actor-Critic for Safety
Kai-Chieh Hsu, Duy Phuong Nguyen, Jaime Fern'andez Fisac
0
0
The deployment of robots in uncontrolled environments requires them to operate robustly under previously unseen scenarios, like irregular terrain and wind conditions. Unfortunately, while rigorous safety frameworks from robust optimal control theory scale poorly to high-dimensional nonlinear dynamics, control policies computed by more tractable deep methods lack guarantees and tend to exhibit little robustness to uncertain operating conditions. This work introduces a novel approach enabling scalable synthesis of robust safety-preserving controllers for robotic systems with general nonlinear dynamics subject to bounded modeling error by combining game-theoretic safety analysis with adversarial reinforcement learning in simulation. Following a soft actor-critic scheme, a safety-seeking fallback policy is co-trained with an adversarial disturbance agent that aims to invoke the worst-case realization of model error and training-to-deployment discrepancy allowed by the designer's uncertainty. While the learned control policy does not intrinsically guarantee safety, it is used to construct a real-time safety filter (or shield) with robust safety guarantees based on forward reachability rollouts. This shield can be used in conjunction with a safety-agnostic control policy, precluding any task-driven actions that could result in loss of safety. We evaluate our learning-based safety approach in a 5D race car simulator, compare the learned safety policy to the numerically obtained optimal solution, and empirically validate the robust safety guarantee of our proposed safety shield against worst-case model discrepancy.
6/11/2024