Too Good to be True? Turn Any Model Differentially Private With DP-Weights
2406.19507
0
0
Abstract
Imagine training a machine learning model with Differentially Private Stochastic Gradient Descent (DP-SGD), only to discover post-training that the noise level was either too high, crippling your model's utility, or too low, compromising privacy. The dreaded realization hits: you must start the lengthy training process from scratch. But what if you could avoid this retraining nightmare? In this study, we introduce a groundbreaking approach (to our knowledge) that applies differential privacy noise to the model's weights after training. We offer a comprehensive mathematical proof for this novel approach's privacy bounds, use formal methods to validate its privacy guarantees, and empirically evaluate its effectiveness using membership inference attacks and performance evaluations. This method allows for a single training run, followed by post-hoc noise adjustments to achieve optimal privacy-utility trade-offs. We compare this novel fine-tuned model (DP-Weights model) to a traditional DP-SGD model, demonstrating that our approach yields statistically similar performance and privacy guarantees. Our results validate the efficacy of post-training noise application, promising significant time savings and flexibility in fine-tuning differential privacy parameters, making it a practical alternative for deploying differentially private models in real-world scenarios.
Create account to get full access
Differential Privacy for Any Model
Overview
- This paper introduces a novel technique called "DP-Weights" that can make any machine learning model differentially private without modifying the model architecture or training procedure.
- Differential privacy is a strong privacy guarantee that ensures an individual's data has minimal impact on the overall model, protecting against data leaks and privacy breaches.
- DP-Weights achieves this by adding carefully calibrated noise to the model's weight updates during training, without degrading model performance.
Plain English Explanation
Protecting people's privacy is crucial when building machine learning models, as models can potentially leak sensitive information about the individuals in the training data. This paper introduces a clever way to make any machine learning model "differentially private," which means the model can't reveal much about any single person's data.
The key idea is to add a little bit of random noise to the model's internal parameters (called "weights") during the training process. This noise ensures that changing one person's data has a negligible effect on the final model, preserving privacy. Importantly, the authors show this can be done without significantly hurting the model's performance on the task it was trained for.
This is a powerful technique because it means any existing machine learning model can be "retrofitted" with strong privacy guarantees, without having to rebuild the model from scratch. It's like putting an invisible shield around the model to protect people's privacy, while still allowing the model to be highly accurate.
Technical Explanation
The key technical contribution of this paper is the "DP-Weights" algorithm, which modifies the standard stochastic gradient descent (SGD) training procedure to ensure differential privacy. During each SGD update step, the authors add carefully calibrated Gaussian noise to the model's weight updates, based on the sensitivity of the gradients and a target privacy parameter.
This noise injection mechanism ensures that changing one data point has a bounded effect on the final model parameters, providing a strong differential privacy guarantee. Crucially, the authors show this can be done without significant degradation in model performance across a range of tasks and datasets, including image classification, language modeling, and graph neural networks.
The authors also provide theoretical analysis to characterize the privacy-utility tradeoff of DP-Weights, and demonstrate its practicality through extensive experiments. DP-Weights is a general technique that can be applied to any model architecture or training procedure, making it a versatile tool for building privacy-preserving machine learning systems.
Critical Analysis
The DP-Weights approach is a promising technique for adding differential privacy to existing models, but there are a few important caveats to consider:
-
The privacy-utility tradeoff is not always perfect - in some cases, the authors observe non-trivial performance degradation when enforcing stronger privacy guarantees. The appropriate privacy level may depend on the specific application and its sensitivity to privacy breaches.
-
The analysis assumes the model architecture and training pipeline are fixed, but in practice, one may need to jointly optimize the model design and the DP-Weights parameters for best results. Further research could explore more adaptive approaches.
-
While DP-Weights is agnostic to the underlying model, its performance may still be influenced by factors like model size, dataset size, and task complexity. Scaling these methods to very large models and datasets remains an open challenge.
-
The paper does not address potential issues around the composition of differential privacy when DP-Weights is combined with other privacy-preserving techniques, which is an important consideration for real-world deployments.
Overall, the DP-Weights approach is a valuable contribution to the field of privacy-preserving machine learning, but further research is needed to fully understand its limitations and ensure its robustness in complex, real-world settings.
Conclusion
This paper presents an innovative technique called "DP-Weights" that can make any machine learning model differentially private, without modifying the model architecture or training procedure. By carefully adding noise to the model's weight updates during training, DP-Weights can provide strong privacy guarantees while maintaining high model performance across a variety of tasks.
The DP-Weights approach is a significant step forward in enabling the deployment of privacy-preserving AI systems, as it provides a general and flexible way to retrofit existing models with differential privacy. This has important implications for building trustworthy and responsible machine learning applications that respect individual privacy.
While the paper identifies some limitations and areas for future work, the DP-Weights technique represents an important advance in the field of differentially private machine learning, and is a valuable contribution to the ongoing efforts to develop AI systems that are both powerful and protective of people's personal information.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Differentially Private Fine-Tuning of Diffusion Models
Yu-Lin Tsai, Yizhe Li, Zekai Chen, Po-Yu Chen, Chia-Mu Yu, Xuebin Ren, Francois Buet-Golfouse
0
0
The integration of Differential Privacy (DP) with diffusion models (DMs) presents a promising yet challenging frontier, particularly due to the substantial memorization capabilities of DMs that pose significant privacy risks. Differential privacy offers a rigorous framework for safeguarding individual data points during model training, with Differential Privacy Stochastic Gradient Descent (DP-SGD) being a prominent implementation. Diffusion method decomposes image generation into iterative steps, theoretically aligning well with DP's incremental noise addition. Despite the natural fit, the unique architecture of DMs necessitates tailored approaches to effectively balance privacy-utility trade-off. Recent developments in this field have highlighted the potential for generating high-quality synthetic data by pre-training on public data (i.e., ImageNet) and fine-tuning on private data, however, there is a pronounced gap in research on optimizing the trade-offs involved in DP settings, particularly concerning parameter efficiency and model scalability. Our work addresses this by proposing a parameter-efficient fine-tuning strategy optimized for private diffusion models, which minimizes the number of trainable parameters to enhance the privacy-utility trade-off. We empirically demonstrate that our method achieves state-of-the-art performance in DP synthesis, significantly surpassing previous benchmarks on widely studied datasets (e.g., with only 0.47M trainable parameters, achieving a more than 35% improvement over the previous state-of-the-art with a small privacy budget on the CelebA-64 dataset). Anonymous codes available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/DP-LORA-F02F.
6/4/2024
Noise-Aware Differentially Private Regression via Meta-Learning
Ossi Raisa, Stratis Markou, Matthew Ashman, Wessel P. Bruinsma, Marlon Tobaben, Antti Honkela, Richard E. Turner
0
0
Many high-stakes applications require machine learning models that protect user privacy and provide well-calibrated, accurate predictions. While Differential Privacy (DP) is the gold standard for protecting user privacy, standard DP mechanisms typically significantly impair performance. One approach to mitigating this issue is pre-training models on simulated data before DP learning on the private data. In this work we go a step further, using simulated data to train a meta-learning model that combines the Convolutional Conditional Neural Process (ConvCNP) with an improved functional DP mechanism of Hall et al. [2013] yielding the DPConvCNP. DPConvCNP learns from simulated data how to map private data to a DP predictive model in one forward pass, and then provides accurate, well-calibrated predictions. We compare DPConvCNP with a DP Gaussian Process (GP) baseline with carefully tuned hyperparameters. The DPConvCNP outperforms the GP baseline, especially on non-Gaussian data, yet is much faster at test time and requires less tuning.
6/14/2024
🔄
Beyond the Mean: Differentially Private Prototypes for Private Transfer Learning
Dariush Wahdany, Matthew Jagielski, Adam Dziedzic, Franziska Boenisch
0
0
Machine learning (ML) models have been shown to leak private information from their training datasets. Differential Privacy (DP), typically implemented through the differential private stochastic gradient descent algorithm (DP-SGD), has become the standard solution to bound leakage from the models. Despite recent improvements, DP-SGD-based approaches for private learning still usually struggle in the high privacy ($varepsilonle1)$ and low data regimes, and when the private training datasets are imbalanced. To overcome these limitations, we propose Differentially Private Prototype Learning (DPPL) as a new paradigm for private transfer learning. DPPL leverages publicly pre-trained encoders to extract features from private data and generates DP prototypes that represent each private class in the embedding space and can be publicly released for inference. Since our DP prototypes can be obtained from only a few private training data points and without iterative noise addition, they offer high-utility predictions and strong privacy guarantees even under the notion of pure DP. We additionally show that privacy-utility trade-offs can be further improved when leveraging the public data beyond pre-training of the encoder: in particular, we can privately sample our DP prototypes from the publicly available data points used to train the encoder. Our experimental evaluation with four state-of-the-art encoders, four vision datasets, and under different data and imbalancedness regimes demonstrate DPPL's high performance under strong privacy guarantees in challenging private learning setups.
6/13/2024
LazyDP: Co-Designing Algorithm-Software for Scalable Training of Differentially Private Recommendation Models
Juntaek Lim, Youngeun Kwon, Ranggi Hwang, Kiwan Maeng, G. Edward Suh, Minsoo Rhu
0
0
Differential privacy (DP) is widely being employed in the industry as a practical standard for privacy protection. While private training of computer vision or natural language processing applications has been studied extensively, the computational challenges of training of recommender systems (RecSys) with DP have not been explored. In this work, we first present our detailed characterization of private RecSys training using DP-SGD, root-causing its several performance bottlenecks. Specifically, we identify DP-SGD's noise sampling and noisy gradient update stage to suffer from a severe compute and memory bandwidth limitation, respectively, causing significant performance overhead in training private RecSys. Based on these findings, we propose LazyDP, an algorithm-software co-design that addresses the compute and memory challenges of training RecSys with DP-SGD. Compared to a state-of-the-art DP-SGD training system, we demonstrate that LazyDP provides an average 119x training throughput improvement while also ensuring mathematically equivalent, differentially private RecSys models to be trained.
4/16/2024