Topology-preserving Adversarial Training for Alleviating Natural Accuracy Degradation
0
🏋️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Adversarial training is an effective way to improve the robustness of neural networks.
- However, it often leads to a significant reduction in the accuracy on natural (non-adversarial) samples.
- This natural accuracy degradation problem is the focus of this study.
Plain English Explanation
Adversarial training is a technique used to make neural networks more robust - in other words, less vulnerable to adversarial attacks. This involves exposing the network to carefully crafted "adversarial examples" during training, which can help the model learn to better recognize and defend against such attacks.
While adversarial training is effective at improving robustness, it often comes at a cost - the model's accuracy on regular, "natural" samples (not designed to fool the model) can decrease significantly. This is known as the "natural accuracy degradation problem."
The researchers in this study investigate the root cause of this problem. Through experiments, they find that adversarial training disrupts the natural "topology" (the geometric structure) of how the model represents natural samples in its internal feature space. This distortion of the natural sample topology is what leads to the drop in natural accuracy.
To address this, the researchers propose a new training method called "Topology-preserving Adversarial Training" (TRAIN). TRAIN aims to preserve the original topology of natural samples during the adversarial training process, allowing the model to maintain high accuracy on both adversarial and natural inputs.
Technical Explanation
The key idea behind the researchers' observation is that adversarial training disrupts the natural sample topology in the model's feature space - the high-dimensional representation that the model learns to extract from the input data. This disruption is what leads to the degradation in natural accuracy.
To demonstrate this, the researchers conduct both quantitative and qualitative experiments. The quantitative experiments measure various topological properties of the feature space before and after adversarial training, showing significant changes. The qualitative experiments visualize the feature space, revealing how adversarial training distorts the natural sample clusters.
Based on these findings, the researchers propose their Topology-preserving Adversarial Training (TRAIN) method. TRAIN aims to preserve the original topology of natural samples during the adversarial training process, allowing the model to maintain high accuracy on both adversarial and natural inputs.
TRAIN can be combined with various popular adversarial training algorithms as an additional regularization technique, taking advantage of the strengths of both approaches. The researchers evaluate TRAIN on CIFAR-10, CIFAR-100, and Tiny ImageNet datasets, and show that it consistently outperforms strong baseline methods in terms of both natural and robust accuracy.
Critical Analysis
The researchers provide a compelling explanation for the natural accuracy degradation problem in adversarial training, rooted in the disruption of natural sample topology. This is an important insight that can inform the development of more effective adversarial training techniques.
However, the paper does not explore the potential limitations or drawbacks of the proposed TRAIN method. For example, it's unclear how TRAIN's performance might scale to larger, more complex datasets or architectures. Additionally, the computational overhead of TRAIN compared to other methods is not discussed.
Further research could also investigate the generalizability of the topology-preservation concept to other domains or tasks beyond image classification, as well as its potential connections to human perception and cognitive science.
Conclusion
This study provides a novel understanding of the natural accuracy degradation problem in adversarial training, attributing it to the disruption of natural sample topology in the model's feature space. The proposed TRAIN method offers a promising solution by preserving this topology, leading to significant improvements in both natural and robust accuracy across multiple benchmark datasets.
This work highlights the importance of considering the underlying geometric structure of the feature space when developing robust machine learning models, opening up new avenues for research in this area.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏋️
0
Topology-preserving Adversarial Training for Alleviating Natural Accuracy Degradation
Xiaoyue Mi, Fan Tang, Yepeng Weng, Danding Wang, Juan Cao, Sheng Tang, Peng Li, Yang Liu
Despite the effectiveness in improving the robustness of neural networks, adversarial training has suffered from the natural accuracy degradation problem, i.e., accuracy on natural samples has reduced significantly. In this study, we reveal that natural accuracy degradation is highly related to the disruption of the natural sample topology in the representation space by quantitative and qualitative experiments. Based on this observation, we propose Topology-pReserving Adversarial traINing (TRAIN) to alleviate the problem by preserving the topology structure of natural samples from a standard model trained only on natural samples during adversarial training. As an additional regularization, our method can be combined with various popular adversarial training algorithms, taking advantage of both sides. Extensive experiments on CIFAR-10, CIFAR-100, and Tiny ImageNet show that our proposed method achieves consistent and significant improvements over various strong baselines in most cases. Specifically, without additional data, TRAIN achieves up to 8.86% improvement in natural accuracy and 6.33% improvement in robust accuracy.
Read more8/20/2024
🏋️
0
Adversarial Training on Purification (AToP): Advancing Both Robustness and Generalization
Guang Lin, Chao Li, Jianhai Zhang, Toshihisa Tanaka, Qibin Zhao
The deep neural networks are known to be vulnerable to well-designed adversarial attacks. The most successful defense technique based on adversarial training (AT) can achieve optimal robustness against particular attacks but cannot generalize well to unseen attacks. Another effective defense technique based on adversarial purification (AP) can enhance generalization but cannot achieve optimal robustness. Meanwhile, both methods share one common limitation on the degraded standard accuracy. To mitigate these issues, we propose a novel pipeline to acquire the robust purifier model, named Adversarial Training on Purification (AToP), which comprises two components: perturbation destruction by random transforms (RT) and purifier model fine-tuned (FT) by adversarial loss. RT is essential to avoid overlearning to known attacks, resulting in the robustness generalization to unseen attacks, and FT is essential for the improvement of robustness. To evaluate our method in an efficient and scalable way, we conduct extensive experiments on CIFAR-10, CIFAR-100, and ImageNette to demonstrate that our method achieves optimal robustness and exhibits generalization ability against unseen attacks.
Read more8/26/2024
0
Rethinking Invariance Regularization in Adversarial Training to Improve Robustness-Accuracy Trade-off
Futa Waseda, Ching-Chun Chang, Isao Echizen
Although adversarial training has been the state-of-the-art approach to defend against adversarial examples (AEs), it suffers from a robustness-accuracy trade-off, where high robustness is achieved at the cost of clean accuracy. In this work, we leverage invariance regularization on latent representations to learn discriminative yet adversarially invariant representations, aiming to mitigate this trade-off. We analyze two key issues in representation learning with invariance regularization: (1) a gradient conflict between invariance loss and classification objectives, leading to suboptimal convergence, and (2) the mixture distribution problem arising from diverged distributions of clean and adversarial inputs. To address these issues, we propose Asymmetrically Representation-regularized Adversarial Training (AR-AT), which incorporates asymmetric invariance loss with stop-gradient operation and a predictor to improve the convergence, and a split-BatchNorm (BN) structure to resolve the mixture distribution problem. Our method significantly improves the robustness-accuracy trade-off by learning adversarially invariant representations without sacrificing discriminative ability. Furthermore, we discuss the relevance of our findings to knowledge-distillation-based defense methods, contributing to a deeper understanding of their relative successes.
Read more5/30/2024
0
Boosting Model Resilience via Implicit Adversarial Data Augmentation
Xiaoling Zhou, Wei Ye, Zhemg Lee, Rui Xie, Shikun Zhang
Data augmentation plays a pivotal role in enhancing and diversifying training data. Nonetheless, consistently improving model performance in varied learning scenarios, especially those with inherent data biases, remains challenging. To address this, we propose to augment the deep features of samples by incorporating their adversarial and anti-adversarial perturbation distributions, enabling adaptive adjustment in the learning difficulty tailored to each sample's specific characteristics. We then theoretically reveal that our augmentation process approximates the optimization of a surrogate loss function as the number of augmented copies increases indefinitely. This insight leads us to develop a meta-learning-based framework for optimizing classifiers with this novel loss, introducing the effects of augmentation while bypassing the explicit augmentation process. We conduct extensive experiments across four common biased learning scenarios: long-tail learning, generalized long-tail learning, noisy label learning, and subpopulation shift learning. The empirical results demonstrate that our method consistently achieves state-of-the-art performance, highlighting its broad adaptability.
Read more6/4/2024