Towards Context-Aware Emotion Recognition Debiasing from a Causal Demystification Perspective via De-confounded Training
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a method for reducing bias in emotion recognition systems by incorporating contextual information and using a causal approach to training.
- The key ideas are to make emotion recognition models "context-aware" and to use "de-confounded training" to remove unwanted biases.
- The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on several emotion recognition benchmarks.
Plain English Explanation
Emotion recognition systems, which aim to identify a person's emotional state from their facial expressions, speech, or other cues, can often be biased. For example, the system may be more accurate at recognizing emotions in certain demographic groups or in certain contexts, leading to unfair and unreliable results.
The researchers in this paper tackle this problem by taking a "causal" approach. Instead of just trying to improve the overall accuracy of the emotion recognition model, they seek to understand the underlying causes of the biases and then actively work to remove them.
The key insight is that emotion is influenced not just by the person's facial expressions, but also by the context - things like the situation they are in, the people they are with, and so on. By explicitly modeling this contextual information and how it relates to emotion, the researchers can disentangle the true emotional signal from confounding factors that may be causing biases.
They call this a "context-aware" approach to emotion recognition. And by using a special training technique called "de-confounded training," they are able to learn emotion recognition models that are much less biased and more robust to different contexts.
The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their method on several standard emotion recognition benchmarks, showing that it outperforms previous bias-reduction techniques. This work is an important step towards building fairer and more reliable emotion recognition systems, with applications in areas like mental health, human-computer interaction, and link to "Enhancing Emotion Recognition in Conversation through Emotional Cross-Modal Consistency".
Technical Explanation
The key technical contributions of this paper are:
-
Context-Aware Emotion Recognition: The authors propose modeling emotion recognition as a causal process, where the observed emotional expression is influenced by both the person's internal emotional state and the external context they are in. They incorporate contextual information, such as the situation, people present, and environment, into the emotion recognition model.
-
De-Confounded Training: To remove unwanted biases from the emotion recognition model, the authors use a "de-confounded training" approach. This involves explicitly modeling the causal relationships between the context, the person's emotional state, and the observed emotional expression. The model is then trained to disentangle the true emotional signal from confounding factors that may be causing biases.
-
Evaluation on Benchmarks: The authors evaluate their context-aware, de-biased emotion recognition model on several standard benchmarks, including link to "Robust Emotion Recognition in the Wild via Adversarial Training", link to "DINER: Towards Debiased Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis", and link to "Emotion-Anchored Contrastive Learning Framework for Emotion Recognition". They show that their approach outperforms previous bias-reduction techniques and leads to more accurate and equitable emotion recognition.
Critical Analysis
The authors present a well-designed and thoughtful approach to addressing the important problem of bias in emotion recognition systems. By explicitly incorporating contextual information and using a causal modeling framework, they are able to achieve significant improvements in reducing unwanted biases.
However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for future research:
-
Scalability and Generalization: While the authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on several benchmarks, it remains to be seen how well it will scale to more diverse and complex real-world scenarios. Expanding the types of contextual information considered and testing the method on larger, more heterogeneous datasets would be valuable.
-
Interpretability and Explainability: The causal modeling approach used in this work can potentially provide insights into the underlying mechanisms driving biases in emotion recognition. However, the authors do not delve deeply into interpreting the learned causal relationships or explaining how the de-confounded training process works. Improving the interpretability of the method could make it more accessible and trustworthy.
-
Ethical Considerations: While the authors' goal of reducing biases is commendable, there may be additional ethical considerations to keep in mind when deploying emotion recognition systems, even if they are less biased. For example, link to "Two for the Price of One: On the Use of Emotion Recognition for Surveillance and Advertising" discusses some of the privacy and fairness concerns around emotion recognition technology.
Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of emotion recognition and bias mitigation. The authors' causal approach is a promising direction for building more fair and reliable systems, and their work could inspire further research in this important area.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to reducing bias in emotion recognition systems by incorporating contextual information and using a causal modeling framework for training. The key ideas are to make the emotion recognition models "context-aware" and to use "de-confounded training" to disentangle the true emotional signal from confounding factors that may be causing biases.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their method on several standard benchmarks, showing that it outperforms previous bias-reduction techniques. This work is an important step towards building fairer and more reliable emotion recognition systems, with applications in areas like mental health, human-computer interaction, and link to "Enhancing Emotion Recognition in Conversation through Emotional Cross-Modal Consistency".
While the paper has a few limitations, such as the need for further exploration of scalability and interpretability, it represents a significant contribution to the field. The authors' causal approach to bias mitigation is a promising direction that could inspire further research and lead to more trustworthy and equitable emotion recognition technologies.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Towards Context-Aware Emotion Recognition Debiasing from a Causal Demystification Perspective via De-confounded Training
Dingkang Yang, Kun Yang, Haopeng Kuang, Zhaoyu Chen, Yuzheng Wang, Lihua Zhang
Understanding emotions from diverse contexts has received widespread attention in computer vision communities. The core philosophy of Context-Aware Emotion Recognition (CAER) is to provide valuable semantic cues for recognizing the emotions of target persons by leveraging rich contextual information. Current approaches invariably focus on designing sophisticated structures to extract perceptually critical representations from contexts. Nevertheless, a long-neglected dilemma is that a severe context bias in existing datasets results in an unbalanced distribution of emotional states among different contexts, causing biased visual representation learning. From a causal demystification perspective, the harmful bias is identified as a confounder that misleads existing models to learn spurious correlations based on likelihood estimation, limiting the models' performance. To address the issue, we embrace causal inference to disentangle the models from the impact of such bias, and formulate the causalities among variables in the CAER task via a customized causal graph. Subsequently, we present a Contextual Causal Intervention Module (CCIM) to de-confound the confounder, which is built upon backdoor adjustment theory to facilitate seeking approximate causal effects during model training. As a plug-and-play component, CCIM can easily integrate with existing approaches and bring significant improvements. Systematic experiments on three datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our CCIM.
Read more7/9/2024
0
Robust Emotion Recognition in Context Debiasing
Dingkang Yang, Kun Yang, Mingcheng Li, Shunli Wang, Shuaibing Wang, Lihua Zhang
Context-aware emotion recognition (CAER) has recently boosted the practical applications of affective computing techniques in unconstrained environments. Mainstream CAER methods invariably extract ensemble representations from diverse contexts and subject-centred characteristics to perceive the target person's emotional state. Despite advancements, the biggest challenge remains due to context bias interference. The harmful bias forces the models to rely on spurious correlations between background contexts and emotion labels in likelihood estimation, causing severe performance bottlenecks and confounding valuable context priors. In this paper, we propose a counterfactual emotion inference (CLEF) framework to address the above issue. Specifically, we first formulate a generalized causal graph to decouple the causal relationships among the variables in CAER. Following the causal graph, CLEF introduces a non-invasive context branch to capture the adverse direct effect caused by the context bias. During the inference, we eliminate the direct context effect from the total causal effect by comparing factual and counterfactual outcomes, resulting in bias mitigation and robust prediction. As a model-agnostic framework, CLEF can be readily integrated into existing methods, bringing consistent performance gains.
Read more6/4/2024
0
Large Vision-Language Models as Emotion Recognizers in Context Awareness
Yuxuan Lei, Dingkang Yang, Zhaoyu Chen, Jiawei Chen, Peng Zhai, Lihua Zhang
Context-aware emotion recognition (CAER) is a complex and significant task that requires perceiving emotions from various contextual cues. Previous approaches primarily focus on designing sophisticated architectures to extract emotional cues from images. However, their knowledge is confined to specific training datasets and may reflect the subjective emotional biases of the annotators. Furthermore, acquiring large amounts of labeled data is often challenging in real-world applications. In this paper, we systematically explore the potential of leveraging Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) to empower the CAER task from three paradigms: 1) We fine-tune LVLMs on two CAER datasets, which is the most common way to transfer large models to downstream tasks. 2) We design zero-shot and few-shot patterns to evaluate the performance of LVLMs in scenarios with limited data or even completely unseen. In this case, a training-free framework is proposed to fully exploit the In-Context Learning (ICL) capabilities of LVLMs. Specifically, we develop an image similarity-based ranking algorithm to retrieve examples; subsequently, the instructions, retrieved examples, and the test example are combined to feed LVLMs to obtain the corresponding sentiment judgment. 3) To leverage the rich knowledge base of LVLMs, we incorporate Chain-of-Thought (CoT) into our framework to enhance the model's reasoning ability and provide interpretable results. Extensive experiments and analyses demonstrate that LVLMs achieve competitive performance in the CAER task across different paradigms. Notably, the superior performance in few-shot settings indicates the feasibility of LVLMs for accomplishing specific tasks without extensive training.
Read more7/17/2024
0
In-Depth Analysis of Emotion Recognition through Knowledge-Based Large Language Models
Bin Han, Cleo Yau, Su Lei, Jonathan Gratch
Emotion recognition in social situations is a complex task that requires integrating information from both facial expressions and the situational context. While traditional approaches to automatic emotion recognition have focused on decontextualized signals, recent research emphasizes the importance of context in shaping emotion perceptions. This paper contributes to the emerging field of context-based emotion recognition by leveraging psychological theories of human emotion perception to inform the design of automated methods. We propose an approach that combines emotion recognition methods with Bayesian Cue Integration (BCI) to integrate emotion inferences from decontextualized facial expressions and contextual knowledge inferred via Large-language Models. We test this approach in the context of interpreting facial expressions during a social task, the prisoner's dilemma. Our results provide clear support for BCI across a range of automatic emotion recognition methods. The best automated method achieved results comparable to human observers, suggesting the potential for this approach to advance the field of affective computing.
Read more8/6/2024