Towards Improving Unit Commitment Economics: An Add-On Tailor for Renewable Energy and Reserve Predictions
0
🌐
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper presents a method for improving the day-ahead unit commitment (UC) process by tailoring renewable energy source (RES) and system reserve requirement predictions to better assist the UC optimization.
- The proposed "RES-and-reserve tailor" is trained using a bi-level optimization model, where the upper level trains the tailor to minimize the induced operating cost, while the lower level mimics the actual system operation process.
- The trained tailor can be embedded into the existing predict-then-optimize UC process as an add-on, improving the overall UC economics.
- The method is compared to traditional, binary-relaxation, neural network-based, stochastic, and robust approaches.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a way to improve the day-ahead unit commitment (UC) process, which is used to plan the most cost-effective way to operate the electricity grid. Typically, the UC process involves first predicting the availability of renewable energy sources (RES) and the system's reserve requirements, and then optimizing the operation plan based on those predictions.
However, these initial predictions can be quite rough. The key idea presented in the paper is to "tailor" these predictions to better support the UC optimization, with the goal of reducing the overall operating costs. The tailoring is done by training a model, using a bi-level optimization approach, to customize the raw predictions in a way that minimizes the expected operating costs.
The trained tailor model can then be incorporated into the existing UC process as an add-on, helping to improve the final operation plan and reduce costs. The paper compares this approach to several other methods, such as traditional, binary-relaxation, neural network-based, stochastic, and robust approaches.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a cost-oriented tailor of RES-and-reserve predictions for UC, deployed as an add-on to the predict-then-optimize UC process. The tailor is trained by solving a bi-level mixed-integer programming model:
- The upper level trains the tailor based on its induced operating cost.
- The lower level, given tailored predictions, mimics the system operation process and feeds the induced operating cost back to the upper level.
- The upper level then evaluates the training quality according to the fed-back cost.
Through this training, the tailor learns to customize the raw predictions into cost-oriented predictions. The trained tailor can be embedded into the existing predict-then-optimize process as an add-on, improving the UC economics.
The paper compares the presented method to traditional, binary-relaxation, neural network-based, stochastic, and robust methods.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel approach to improving the day-ahead UC process by tailoring the input predictions. The bi-level optimization-based training process is an interesting and potentially effective way to customize the predictions to minimize operating costs.
However, the paper does not discuss the computational complexity and scalability of the proposed method, which could be a concern for real-world application. Additionally, the paper does not address the potential sensitivity of the tailor to errors or biases in the initial predictions, and how this could impact the overall UC optimization.
Further research could explore ways to make the tailor more robust to prediction errors, as well as investigate the trade-offs between the increased computational complexity and the potential cost savings from the improved UC process.
Conclusion
The paper presents a cost-oriented tailor for RES-and-reserve predictions in the day-ahead unit commitment (UC) process. By training a tailor model using a bi-level optimization approach to customize the raw predictions, the method can improve the UC economics when incorporated as an add-on to the existing predict-then-optimize UC process.
The proposed approach shows promise in reducing operating costs compared to traditional, binary-relaxation, neural network-based, stochastic, and robust methods. However, further research is needed to address potential scalability and robustness concerns. Overall, the paper contributes a novel and interesting solution to the challenge of improving day-ahead UC optimization.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🌐
0
Towards Improving Unit Commitment Economics: An Add-On Tailor for Renewable Energy and Reserve Predictions
Xianbang Chen, Yikui Liu, Lei Wu
Generally, day-ahead unit commitment (UC) is conducted in a predict-then-optimize process: it starts by predicting the renewable energy source (RES) availability and system reserve requirements; given the predictions, the UC model is then optimized to determine the economic operation plans. In fact, predictions within the process are raw. In other words, if the predictions are further tailored to assist UC in making the economic operation plans against realizations of the RES and reserve requirements, UC economics will benefit significantly. To this end, this paper presents a cost-oriented tailor of RES-and-reserve predictions for UC, deployed as an add-on to the predict-then-optimize process. The RES-and-reserve tailor is trained by solving a bi-level mixed-integer programming model: the upper level trains the tailor based on its induced operating cost; the lower level, given tailored predictions, mimics the system operation process and feeds the induced operating cost back to the upper level; finally, the upper level evaluates the training quality according to the fed-back cost. Through this training, the tailor learns to customize the raw predictions into cost-oriented predictions. Moreover, the tailor can be embedded into the existing predict-then-optimize process as an add-on, improving the UC economics. Lastly, the presented method is compared to traditional, binary-relaxation, neural network-based, stochastic, and robust methods.
Read more7/9/2024
0
Costs Estimation in Unit Commitment Problems using Simulation-Based Inference
Matthias Pirlet, Adrien Bolland, Gilles Louppe, Damien Ernst
The Unit Commitment (UC) problem is a key optimization task in power systems to forecast the generation schedules of power units over a finite time period by minimizing costs while meeting demand and technical constraints. However, many parameters required by the UC problem are unknown, such as the costs. In this work, we estimate these unknown costs using simulation-based inference on an illustrative UC problem, which provides an approximated posterior distribution of the parameters given observed generation schedules and demands. Our results highlight that the learned posterior distribution effectively captures the underlying distribution of the data, providing a range of possible values for the unknown parameters given a past observation. This posterior allows for the estimation of past costs using observed past generation schedules, enabling operators to better forecast future costs and make more robust generation scheduling forecasts. We present avenues for future research to address overconfidence in posterior estimation, enhance the scalability of the methodology and apply it to more complex UC problems modeling the network constraints and renewable energy sources.
Read more9/6/2024
0
Improving Sequential Market Clearing via Value-oriented Renewable Energy Forecasting
Yufan Zhang, Honglin Wen, Yuexin Bian, Yuanyuan Shi
Large penetration of renewable energy sources (RESs) brings huge uncertainty into the electricity markets. While existing deterministic market clearing fails to accommodate the uncertainty, the recently proposed stochastic market clearing struggles to achieve desirable market properties. In this work, we propose a value-oriented forecasting approach, which tactically determines the RESs generation that enters the day-ahead market. With such a forecast, the existing deterministic market clearing framework can be maintained, and the day-ahead and real-time overall operation cost is reduced. At the training phase, the forecast model parameters are estimated to minimize expected day-ahead and real-time overall operation costs, instead of minimizing forecast errors in a statistical sense. Theoretically, we derive the exact form of the loss function for training the forecast model that aligns with such a goal. For market clearing modeled by linear programs, this loss function is a piecewise linear function. Additionally, we derive the analytical gradient of the loss function with respect to the forecast, which inspires an efficient training strategy. A numerical study shows our forecasts can bring significant benefits of the overall cost reduction to deterministic market clearing, compared to quality-oriented forecasting approach.
Read more5/16/2024
0
Integrating the Expected Future: Schedule Based Energy Forecasting
Raffael Theiler, Olga Fink
Power grid operators depend on accurate and reliable energy forecasts, aiming to minimize cases of extreme errors, as these outliers are particularly challenging to manage during operation. Incorporating planning information -- such as known data about users' future behavior or scheduled events -- has the potential to significantly enhance the accuracy and specificity of forecasts. Although there have been attempts to integrate such expected future behavior, these efforts consistently rely on conventional regression models to process this information. These models often lack the flexibility and capability to effectively incorporate both dynamic, forward-looking contextual inputs and historical data. To address this challenge, we conceptualize this combined forecasting and regression challenge as a sequence-to-sequence modeling problem and demonstrate, with three distinct models, that our contextually enhanced transformer models excel in this task. By leveraging schedule-based contextual information from the Swiss railway traction network, our proposed method significantly improved the average forecasting accuracy of nationwide railway energy consumption. Specifically, enhancing the transformer models with contextual information resulted in an average reduction of mean absolute error by 40.6% , whereas other state-of-the-art methods did not demonstrate any significant improvement.
Read more9/11/2024