Towards a methodology to consider the environmental impacts of digital agriculture
0
🔄
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Agriculture contributes to global warming, but its yields are also threatened by climate change
- Information and communication technology (ICT) is often seen as a way to help mitigate this tension, through monitoring and process optimization
- However, the environmental impact of agricultural ICT systems is often overlooked
- Rebound effects could undermine the expected benefits and hinder agricultural sustainability
Plain English Explanation
Farming has an impact on climate change, but climate change also affects farming. Information technology is sometimes thought to be a solution, as it can help monitor and optimize agricultural processes. But the environmental footprint of these digital farming technologies is often ignored. There's a risk that the benefits could be cancelled out by unintended consequences, making agriculture less sustainable.
This research aims to develop a way to assess the environmental impact of digital agriculture systems and their supporting infrastructure. The goal is to create models that can predict how different technological paths might affect the sustainability, self-sufficiency, and resilience of agriculture. The findings could help inform public debates and policy decisions.
Technical Explanation
The research adapts environmental footprint assessment methods to the context of digital agriculture. The goal is to define a methodology that accounts for the environmental impact of agricultural ICT systems and their required infrastructure.
The expected contribution is to propose present and prospective models based on possible digitalization scenarios. These models would be used to assess the effects and consequences of different technological paths on the sustainability, sufficiency, and resilience of agriculture.
Critical Analysis
The paper recognizes that while agricultural ICT is actively promoted, its environmental impact appears to be overlooked. This is an important point, as unintended consequences and rebound effects could undermine the expected benefits of these technologies.
The proposed methodology for assessing the environmental footprint of digital agriculture systems seems like a valuable approach. By modeling different digitalization scenarios, the research could provide crucial insights to guide decisions and ensure agricultural sustainability.
However, the paper does not delve into the specific challenges or limitations of this assessment approach. More discussion of potential data gaps, modeling uncertainties, or other complexities would strengthen the critical analysis.
Conclusion
This research aims to develop a framework for evaluating the environmental impacts of information technologies in agriculture. By modeling different digitalization pathways, it seeks to understand how these technologies could affect the sustainability, self-sufficiency, and resilience of the agricultural sector.
The findings could inform important societal debates and policy decisions around the role of digital tools in addressing the complex, interrelated challenges of agriculture and climate change. A comprehensive assessment of both the benefits and potential drawbacks of agricultural ICT is crucial to ensuring these technologies support, rather than undermine, long-term agricultural sustainability.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔄
0
Towards a methodology to consider the environmental impacts of digital agriculture
Pierre La Rocca (UB, LaBRI, MANAO)
Agriculture affects global warming, while its yields are threatened by it. Information and communication technology (ICT) is often considered as a potential lever to mitigate this tension, through monitoring and process optimization. However, while agricultural ICT is actively promoted, its environmental impact appears to be overlooked. Possible rebound effects could put at stake its net expected benefits and hamper agriculture sustainability. By adapting environmental footprint assessment methods to digital agriculture context, this research aims at defining a methodology taking into account the environmental footprint of agricultural ICT systems and their required infrastructures. The expected contribution is to propose present and prospective models based on possible digitalization scenarios, in order to assess effects and consequences of different technological paths on agriculture sustainability, sufficiency and resilience. The final results could be useful to enlighten societal debates and political decisions.
Read more9/12/2024
🎲
0
Rethinking Digitalization and Climate: Don't Predict, Mitigate
Daria Gritsenko, Jon Aaen, Bent Flyvbjerg
Digitalization is a core component of the green transition. Today's focus is on quantifying and pre-dicting the climate effects of digitalization through various life-cycle assessments and baseline sce-nario methodologies. Here we argue that this is a mistake. Most attempts at prediction are based on three implicit assumptions: (a) the digital carbon footprint can be quantified, (b) business-as-usual with episodic change leading to a new era of stability, and (c) investments in digitalization will be delivered within the cost, timeframe, and benefits described in their business cases. We problema-tize each assumption within the context of digitalization and argue that the digital carbon footprint is inherently unpredictable. We build on uncertainty literature to show that even if you cannot predict, you can still mitigate. On that basis, we propose to rethink practice on the digital carbon footprint from prediction to mitigation.
Read more7/23/2024
📊
0
Reducing the climate impact of data portals: a case study
Noah Gie{ss}ing, Madhurima Deb, Ankit Satpute, Moritz Schubotz, Olaf Teschke
The carbon footprint share of the information and communication technology (ICT) sector has steadily increased in the past decade and is predicted to make up as much as 23 % of global emissions in 2030. This shows a pressing need for developers, including the information retrieval community, to make their code more energy-efficient. In this project proposal, we discuss techniques to reduce the energy footprint of the MaRDI (Mathematical Research Data Initiative) Portal, a MediaWiki-based knowledge base. In future work, we plan to implement these changes and provide concrete measurements on the gain in energy efficiency. Researchers developing similar knowledge bases can adapt our measures to reduce their environmental footprint. In this way, we are working on mitigating the climate impact of Information Retrieval research.
Read more6/7/2024
🚀
0
Towards A Comprehensive Assessment of AI's Environmental Impact
Srija Chakraborty
Artificial Intelligence, machine learning (AI/ML) has allowed exploring solutions for a variety of environmental and climate questions ranging from natural disasters, greenhouse gas emission, monitoring biodiversity, agriculture, to weather and climate modeling, enabling progress towards climate change mitigation. However, the intersection of AI/ML and environment is not always positive. The recent surge of interest in ML, made possible by processing very large volumes of data, fueled by access to massive compute power, has sparked a trend towards large-scale adoption of AI/ML. This interest places tremendous pressure on natural resources, that are often overlooked and under-reported. There is a need for a framework that monitors the environmental impact and degradation from AI/ML throughout its lifecycle for informing policymakers, stakeholders to adequately implement standards and policies and track the policy outcome over time. For these policies to be effective, AI's environmental impact needs to be monitored in a spatially-disaggregated, timely manner across the globe at the key activity sites. This study proposes a methodology to track environmental variables relating to the multifaceted impact of AI around datacenters using openly available energy data and globally acquired satellite observations. We present a case study around Northern Virginia, United States that hosts a growing number of datacenters and observe changes in multiple satellite-based environmental metrics. We then discuss the steps to expand this methodology for comprehensive assessment of AI's environmental impact across the planet. We also identify data gaps and formulate recommendations for improving the understanding and monitoring AI-induced changes to the environment and climate.
Read more5/24/2024