Towards Robust Knowledge Unlearning: An Adversarial Framework for Assessing and Improving Unlearning Robustness in Large Language Models
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Introduces an adversarial framework for assessing and improving the robustness of knowledge unlearning in large language models
- Focuses on developing techniques to reliably remove specific knowledge from pre-trained models without compromising their overall performance
- Highlights the challenges of achieving robust knowledge unlearning and proposes solutions to address them
Plain English Explanation
The paper presents an adversarial framework to test and enhance the ability of large language models to unlearn specific knowledge that was previously learned. This is an important capability, as it allows these models to remove sensitive or outdated information without degrading their overall performance.
The researchers recognize that achieving robust knowledge unlearning is not straightforward, as language models can be resistant to forgetting information they have acquired. Their framework aims to identify weaknesses in unlearning approaches and develop techniques to make the process more reliable.
By using adversarial attacks, the researchers can stress-test the unlearning capabilities of language models and assess their robustness. This helps them understand the limitations of current unlearning methods and devise strategies to improve the models' ability to selectively remove targeted knowledge.
The ultimate goal is to enable large language models to safely and effectively unlearn specific information, while preserving their overall capabilities. This could have important implications for the responsible deployment of these powerful AI systems in real-world applications.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces an adversarial framework for evaluating and enhancing the robustness of knowledge unlearning in large language models. The framework involves two key components:
-
Unlearning Evaluation: The researchers design targeted adversarial attacks to assess the unlearning robustness of language models. These attacks attempt to recover the knowledge that the model is supposed to have unlearned, revealing vulnerabilities in the unlearning process.
-
Unlearning Improvement: Based on the insights gained from the evaluation, the researchers propose techniques to improve the robustness of knowledge unlearning. This includes developing novel unlearning methods and incorporating them into the training process to make the models more resistant to adversarial attacks.
The paper presents several experiments that validate the effectiveness of the proposed framework. The researchers demonstrate that their approach can identify weaknesses in existing unlearning methods and lead to the development of more robust unlearning techniques.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of machine unlearning, which is an important aspect of responsible AI development. The authors acknowledge that achieving robust knowledge unlearning is a challenging task, as language models can be resistant to forgetting information they have acquired.
While the proposed adversarial framework is a promising approach, the authors note that it has certain limitations. For example, the framework may not capture all possible ways in which an adversary could attempt to recover unlearned knowledge. Additionally, the unlearning techniques developed within this framework may have trade-offs, such as potential performance degradation or increased computational overhead.
The paper also highlights the need for further research to address the fundamental challenges of iterative unlearning in large language models, which could lead to more reliable and efficient unlearning methods.
Overall, this paper represents a significant step towards robust and cost-efficient knowledge unlearning in large language models, which is crucial for the responsible deployment of these powerful AI systems.
Conclusion
The paper presents an adversarial framework for assessing and improving the robustness of knowledge unlearning in large language models. The framework aims to identify vulnerabilities in existing unlearning methods and develop techniques to make the unlearning process more reliable and effective.
The research highlights the challenges of achieving robust knowledge unlearning and demonstrates the potential of using adversarial attacks to stress-test and enhance the unlearning capabilities of language models. The proposed solutions have important implications for the responsible deployment of large language models, as they enable these powerful AI systems to selectively remove sensitive or outdated information without compromising their overall performance.
Overall, this work represents a significant contribution to the field of machine unlearning and paves the way for further advancements in the development of reliable and cost-efficient unlearning techniques for large language models.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Towards Robust Knowledge Unlearning: An Adversarial Framework for Assessing and Improving Unlearning Robustness in Large Language Models
Hongbang Yuan, Zhuoran Jin, Pengfei Cao, Yubo Chen, Kang Liu, Jun Zhao
LLM have achieved success in many fields but still troubled by problematic content in the training corpora. LLM unlearning aims at reducing their influence and avoid undesirable behaviours. However, existing unlearning methods remain vulnerable to adversarial queries and the unlearned knowledge resurfaces after the manually designed attack queries. As part of a red-team effort to proactively assess the vulnerabilities of unlearned models, we design Dynamic Unlearning Attack (DUA), a dynamic and automated framework to attack these models and evaluate their robustness. It optimizes adversarial suffixes to reintroduce the unlearned knowledge in various scenarios. We find that unlearned knowledge can be recovered in $55.2%$ of the questions, even without revealing the unlearned model's parameters. In response to this vulnerability, we propose Latent Adversarial Unlearning (LAU), a universal framework that effectively enhances the robustness of the unlearned process. It formulates the unlearning process as a min-max optimization problem and resolves it through two stages: an attack stage, where perturbation vectors are trained and added to the latent space of LLMs to recover the unlearned knowledge, and a defense stage, where previously trained perturbation vectors are used to enhance unlearned model's robustness. With our LAU framework, we obtain two robust unlearning methods, AdvGA and AdvNPO. We conduct extensive experiments across multiple unlearning benchmarks and various models, and demonstrate that they improve the unlearning effectiveness by over $53.5%$, cause only less than a $11.6%$ reduction in neighboring knowledge, and have almost no impact on the model's general capabilities.
Read more8/21/2024
0
Towards Robust and Cost-Efficient Knowledge Unlearning for Large Language Models
Sungmin Cha, Sungjun Cho, Dasol Hwang, Moontae Lee
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated strong reasoning and memorization capabilities via pretraining on massive textual corpora. However, training LLMs on human-written text entails significant risk of privacy and copyright violations, which demands an efficient machine unlearning framework to remove knowledge of sensitive data without retraining the model from scratch. While Gradient Ascent (GA) is widely used for unlearning by reducing the likelihood of generating unwanted information, the unboundedness of increasing the cross-entropy loss causes not only unstable optimization, but also catastrophic forgetting of knowledge that needs to be retained. We also discover its joint application under low-rank adaptation results in significantly suboptimal computational cost vs. generative performance trade-offs. In light of this limitation, we propose two novel techniques for robust and cost-efficient unlearning on LLMs. We first design an Inverted Hinge loss that suppresses unwanted tokens by increasing the probability of the next most likely token, thereby retaining fluency and structure in language generation. We also propose to initialize low-rank adapter weights based on Fisher-weighted low-rank approximation, which induces faster unlearning and better knowledge retention by allowing model updates to be focused on parameters that are important in generating textual data we wish to remove.
Read more8/14/2024
0
Adversarial Machine Unlearning
Zonglin Di, Sixie Yu, Yevgeniy Vorobeychik, Yang Liu
This paper focuses on the challenge of machine unlearning, aiming to remove the influence of specific training data on machine learning models. Traditionally, the development of unlearning algorithms runs parallel with that of membership inference attacks (MIA), a type of privacy threat to determine whether a data instance was used for training. However, the two strands are intimately connected: one can view machine unlearning through the lens of MIA success with respect to removed data. Recognizing this connection, we propose a game-theoretic framework that integrates MIAs into the design of unlearning algorithms. Specifically, we model the unlearning problem as a Stackelberg game in which an unlearner strives to unlearn specific training data from a model, while an auditor employs MIAs to detect the traces of the ostensibly removed data. Adopting this adversarial perspective allows the utilization of new attack advancements, facilitating the design of unlearning algorithms. Our framework stands out in two ways. First, it takes an adversarial approach and proactively incorporates the attacks into the design of unlearning algorithms. Secondly, it uses implicit differentiation to obtain the gradients that limit the attacker's success, thus benefiting the process of unlearning. We present empirical results to demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach for machine unlearning.
Read more6/13/2024
0
Practical Unlearning for Large Language Models
Chongyang Gao, Lixu Wang, Chenkai Weng, Xiao Wang, Qi Zhu
While LLMs have demonstrated impressive performance across various domains and tasks, their security issues have become increasingly severe. Machine unlearning (MU) has emerged as a promising solution to address these issues by removing the influence of undesired data on the target model without compromising its utility in other aspects. MU typically assumes full access to the original training data to preserve utility, which is difficult to achieve in LLM unlearning. Existing LLM unlearning methods often assume access to data most affected by undesired data unlearning. However, this assumption underestimates the entanglement among various LLM capabilities and ignores data access limitations due to various issues. Moreover, these LLM unlearning methods do not sufficiently consider that unlearning requests in real-world scenarios are continuously emerging. To overcome these challenges and achieve practical LLM unlearning, we propose the O3 framework. The O3 framework includes an Out-Of-Distribution (OOD) detector to measure the similarity between input and unlearning data, and an Orthogonal low-rank adapter (LoRA) for continuously unlearning requested data. The OOD detector is trained with a novel contrastive entropy loss and utilizes a local-global layer-aggregated scoring mechanism. The orthogonal LoRA achieves parameter disentanglement among continual unlearning requests. During inference, our O3 framework can smartly decide whether and to what extent to load the unlearning LoRA based on the OOD detector's predictions. Notably, O3's effectiveness does not rely on any retained data. We conducted extensive experiments on O3 and state-of-the-art LLM unlearning methods across three tasks and seven datasets. The results indicate that O3 consistently achieves the best trade-off between unlearning effectiveness and utility preservation, especially when facing continuous unlearning requests.
Read more7/16/2024