Train Till You Drop: Towards Stable and Robust Source-free Unsupervised 3D Domain Adaptation
0
🤷
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Tackles the challenging problem of source-free unsupervised domain adaptation (SFUDA) for 3D semantic segmentation
- SFUDA involves adapting a model trained on a source domain to perform well on an unlabeled target domain, without access to the source data
- Existing SFUDA approaches can exhibit performance degradation over time, due to the under-constrained and ill-posed nature of the problem
- Proposes two strategies to address this issue:
- Regularizing the learning problem in a sensible way
- Introducing a novel criterion based on agreement with a reference model
Plain English Explanation
In this research, the authors address the problem of source-free unsupervised domain adaptation (SFUDA) for 3D semantic segmentation. This means they want to take a machine learning model that was trained on one set of 3D data (the "source" domain) and adapt it to perform well on a new set of 3D data (the "target" domain), without having access to the original training data.
A common issue with existing SFUDA approaches is that the model's performance can degrade over time during the adaptation process. The authors explain that this is because the problem is "under-constrained and ill-posed," meaning there are many possible solutions and it's challenging to determine the best one.
To address this, the authors propose two main strategies:
-
Regularizing the learning problem in a sensible way. This involves adding additional constraints or guidelines to the adaptation process to make it more stable and reliable.
-
Introducing a novel criterion based on agreement with a reference model. This criterion serves two purposes: (1) to know when to stop the adaptation training, and (2) to select the best hyperparameters (settings) for the adaptation process, without needing any information about the target domain.
The authors claim these contributions are easy to implement and can be applied to improve the performance of various SFUDA methods. They validate their approach on different 3D lidar (light detection and ranging) settings and achieve state-of-the-art results.
Technical Explanation
The key elements of the paper are as follows:
Experiment Design: The authors evaluate their proposed SFUDA strategies on various 3D lidar datasets, including Semantic KITTI, nuScenes, and a custom dataset. They compare their approach to several existing SFUDA baselines.
Architecture: The authors do not propose a new neural network architecture. Instead, they introduce two novel techniques that can be applied to improve the performance of any SFUDA method:
-
Regularization: The authors introduce a sensible way to regularize the learning problem, which helps stabilize the adaptation process and prevent performance degradation.
-
Reference Model Agreement: The authors propose a new criterion based on the agreement between the adapted model and a reference model. This is used to (1) determine when to stop the adaptation training and (2) select the best hyperparameters without any knowledge of the target domain.
Insights: The authors show that their proposed strategies can be easily integrated into existing SFUDA methods and lead to consistent performance improvements across various 3D lidar settings.
Critical Analysis
The authors acknowledge the limitations of their approach, noting that the SFUDA problem is inherently under-constrained and ill-posed, which makes it challenging to find a stable and optimal solution. They also suggest that further research is needed to better understand the factors that lead to performance degradation in SFUDA.
One potential area for improvement could be exploring more sophisticated regularization techniques or alternative criteria for determining the stopping point and hyperparameter selection. Additionally, the authors could investigate the performance of their approach on a wider range of 3D semantic segmentation tasks and datasets.
Overall, the authors have made a valuable contribution to the field of SFUDA for 3D semantic segmentation by proposing two practical strategies to address the stability issues in existing methods. Their work highlights the importance of further research in this challenging area.
Conclusion
This paper tackles the problem of source-free unsupervised domain adaptation (SFUDA) for 3D semantic segmentation, which involves adapting a machine learning model trained on one 3D dataset to perform well on a new, unlabeled 3D dataset, without access to the original training data.
The authors propose two key strategies to address the common issue of performance degradation in existing SFUDA approaches: (1) a sensible way to regularize the learning problem, and (2) a novel criterion based on agreement with a reference model, which is used to determine the stopping point and select hyperparameters.
These contributions are easy to implement and can be readily applied to improve the performance of various SFUDA methods for 3D semantic segmentation. The authors validate their approach on multiple 3D lidar datasets and achieve state-of-the-art results, demonstrating the effectiveness of their proposed solutions.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤷
0
Train Till You Drop: Towards Stable and Robust Source-free Unsupervised 3D Domain Adaptation
Bjorn Michele, Alexandre Boulch, Tuan-Hung Vu, Gilles Puy, Renaud Marlet, Nicolas Courty
We tackle the challenging problem of source-free unsupervised domain adaptation (SFUDA) for 3D semantic segmentation. It amounts to performing domain adaptation on an unlabeled target domain without any access to source data; the available information is a model trained to achieve good performance on the source domain. A common issue with existing SFUDA approaches is that performance degrades after some training time, which is a by product of an under-constrained and ill-posed problem. We discuss two strategies to alleviate this issue. First, we propose a sensible way to regularize the learning problem. Second, we introduce a novel criterion based on agreement with a reference model. It is used (1) to stop the training when appropriate and (2) as validator to select hyperparameters without any knowledge on the target domain. Our contributions are easy to implement and readily amenable for all SFUDA methods, ensuring stable improvements over all baselines. We validate our findings on various 3D lidar settings, achieving state-of-the-art performance. The project repository (with code) is: github.com/valeoai/TTYD.
Read more9/9/2024
0
An Uncertainty-guided Tiered Self-training Framework for Active Source-free Domain Adaptation in Prostate Segmentation
Zihao Luo, Xiangde Luo, Zijun Gao, Guotai Wang
Deep learning models have exhibited remarkable efficacy in accurately delineating the prostate for diagnosis and treatment of prostate diseases, but challenges persist in achieving robust generalization across different medical centers. Source-free Domain Adaptation (SFDA) is a promising technique to adapt deep segmentation models to address privacy and security concerns while reducing domain shifts between source and target domains. However, recent literature indicates that the performance of SFDA remains far from satisfactory due to unpredictable domain gaps. Annotating a few target domain samples is acceptable, as it can lead to significant performance improvement with a low annotation cost. Nevertheless, due to extremely limited annotation budgets, careful consideration is needed in selecting samples for annotation. Inspired by this, our goal is to develop Active Source-free Domain Adaptation (ASFDA) for medical image segmentation. Specifically, we propose a novel Uncertainty-guided Tiered Self-training (UGTST) framework, consisting of efficient active sample selection via entropy-based primary local peak filtering to aggregate global uncertainty and diversity-aware redundancy filter, coupled with a tiered self-learning strategy, achieves stable domain adaptation. Experimental results on cross-center prostate MRI segmentation datasets revealed that our method yielded marked advancements, with a mere 5% annotation, exhibiting an average Dice score enhancement of 9.78% and 7.58% in two target domains compared with state-of-the-art methods, on par with fully supervised learning. Code is available at:https://github.com/HiLab-git/UGTST
Read more7/8/2024
0
Style Adaptation for Domain-adaptive Semantic Segmentation
Ting Li, Jianshu Chao, Deyu An
Unsupervised Domain Adaptation (UDA) refers to the method that utilizes annotated source domain data and unlabeled target domain data to train a model capable of generalizing to the target domain data. Domain discrepancy leads to a significant decrease in the performance of general network models trained on the source domain data when applied to the target domain. We introduce a straightforward approach to mitigate the domain discrepancy, which necessitates no additional parameter calculations and seamlessly integrates with self-training-based UDA methods. Through the transfer of the target domain style to the source domain in the latent feature space, the model is trained to prioritize the target domain style during the decision-making process. We tackle the problem at both the image-level and shallow feature map level by transferring the style information from the target domain to the source domain data. As a result, we obtain a model that exhibits superior performance on the target domain. Our method yields remarkable enhancements in the state-of-the-art performance for synthetic-to-real UDA tasks. For example, our proposed method attains a noteworthy UDA performance of 76.93 mIoU on the GTA->Cityscapes dataset, representing a notable improvement of +1.03 percentage points over the previous state-of-the-art results.
Read more4/26/2024
👀
0
Source-Free Domain Adaptation Guided by Vision and Vision-Language Pre-Training
Wenyu Zhang, Li Shen, Chuan-Sheng Foo
Source-free domain adaptation (SFDA) aims to adapt a source model trained on a fully-labeled source domain to a related but unlabeled target domain. While the source model is a key avenue for acquiring target pseudolabels, the generated pseudolabels may exhibit source bias. In the conventional SFDA pipeline, a large data (e.g. ImageNet) pre-trained feature extractor is used to initialize the source model at the start of source training, and subsequently discarded. Despite having diverse features important for generalization, the pre-trained feature extractor can overfit to the source data distribution during source training and forget relevant target domain knowledge. Rather than discarding this valuable knowledge, we introduce an integrated framework to incorporate pre-trained networks into the target adaptation process. The proposed framework is flexible and allows us to plug modern pre-trained networks into the adaptation process to leverage their stronger representation learning capabilities. For adaptation, we propose the Co-learn algorithm to improve target pseudolabel quality collaboratively through the source model and a pre-trained feature extractor. Building on the recent success of the vision-language model CLIP in zero-shot image recognition, we present an extension Co-learn++ to further incorporate CLIP's zero-shot classification decisions. We evaluate on 4 benchmark datasets and include more challenging scenarios such as open-set, partial-set and open-partial SFDA. Experimental results demonstrate that our proposed strategy improves adaptation performance and can be successfully integrated with existing SFDA methods.
Read more8/22/2024