TRIP-PAL: Travel Planning with Guarantees by Combining Large Language Models and Automated Planners
2406.10196
1
0
💬
Abstract
Travel planning is a complex task that involves generating a sequence of actions related to visiting places subject to constraints and maximizing some user satisfaction criteria. Traditional approaches rely on problem formulation in a given formal language, extracting relevant travel information from web sources, and use an adequate problem solver to generate a valid solution. As an alternative, recent Large Language Model (LLM) based approaches directly output plans from user requests using language. Although LLMs possess extensive travel domain knowledge and provide high-level information like points of interest and potential routes, current state-of-the-art models often generate plans that lack coherence, fail to satisfy constraints fully, and do not guarantee the generation of high-quality solutions. We propose TRIP-PAL, a hybrid method that combines the strengths of LLMs and automated planners, where (i) LLMs get and translate travel information and user information into data structures that can be fed into planners; and (ii) automated planners generate travel plans that guarantee constraint satisfaction and optimize for users' utility. Our experiments across various travel scenarios show that TRIP-PAL outperforms an LLM when generating travel plans.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Outlines a hybrid approach called TRIP-PAL that combines the strengths of large language models (LLMs) and automated planners for generating high-quality travel plans
- LLMs provide travel information and user preferences, which are then translated into a format that can be used by automated planners to generate the final travel plan
- Experiments show that TRIP-PAL outperforms standalone LLMs in generating travel plans that satisfy constraints and optimize for user satisfaction
Plain English Explanation
Traveling can be a complex task, as it involves deciding where to go, how to get there, and what to do along the way. Traditional approaches rely on extracting relevant travel information from the web and using automated problem-solving techniques to generate a travel plan. More recently, large language models (LLMs) have been used to directly generate travel plans from user requests, leveraging their extensive knowledge of travel-related information.
However, current LLM-based approaches often produce plans that lack coherence, fail to fully satisfy all constraints, and may not be of the highest quality. To address these limitations, the researchers propose a hybrid approach called TRIP-PAL, which combines the strengths of LLMs and automated planners.
In this approach, the LLM is used to gather and translate travel information and user preferences into a format that can be understood by an automated planner. The planner then generates the final travel plan, ensuring that it satisfies all constraints and maximizes the user's satisfaction. This combination of LLM-powered information gathering and automated planning allows for the generation of high-quality travel plans that are both coherent and optimized for the user's needs.
The researchers tested TRIP-PAL across various travel scenarios and found that it outperformed standalone LLM-based approaches, demonstrating the benefits of this hybrid approach.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a hybrid method called TRIP-PAL that combines the strengths of large language models (LLMs) and automated planners for generating high-quality travel plans.
In the TRIP-PAL approach, the LLM is first used to gather and translate relevant travel information and user preferences into a structured data format that can be understood by an automated planner. This includes details like points of interest, potential routes, and the user's priorities and constraints.
The automated planner then takes this structured data as input and generates the final travel plan, ensuring that it satisfies all relevant constraints and maximizes the user's satisfaction. This combination of LLM-powered information gathering and automated planning allows TRIP-PAL to generate travel plans that are both coherent and optimized, overcoming the limitations of standalone LLM-based approaches.
The researchers evaluated TRIP-PAL across various travel scenarios and found that it outperformed LLM-only models in generating high-quality travel plans. This demonstrates the benefits of the hybrid approach, which leverages the complementary strengths of LLMs and automated planners.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising hybrid approach, TRIP-PAL, that combines the strengths of LLMs and automated planners to generate high-quality travel plans. However, the research also acknowledges some potential limitations and areas for further exploration.
One key limitation mentioned is that the current implementation of TRIP-PAL relies on the LLM to accurately translate travel information and user preferences into a format that can be understood by the automated planner. Errors or biases in this translation process could potentially lead to suboptimal travel plans being generated. Exploring more robust translation techniques could be an area for further research.
Additionally, the paper notes that the performance of TRIP-PAL is still dependent on the capabilities of the underlying LLM and automated planner. Advancements in these core technologies could further improve the quality and reliability of the travel plans generated by TRIP-PAL.
Finally, the paper does not address the potential privacy and security concerns that may arise when using LLMs to gather and process sensitive user travel information. Ensuring the appropriate safeguards and consent processes are in place would be an important consideration for real-world deployment of such a system.
Overall, the TRIP-PAL approach represents an interesting and potentially valuable contribution to the field of travel planning. By leveraging the complementary strengths of LLMs and automated planners, it offers a promising path towards generating high-quality, user-centric travel plans.
Conclusion
The paper proposes a hybrid approach called TRIP-PAL that combines the strengths of large language models (LLMs) and automated planners to generate high-quality travel plans. This approach leverages the extensive travel domain knowledge of LLMs to gather and translate relevant information, which is then used by an automated planner to generate the final travel plan, ensuring constraint satisfaction and optimization of user satisfaction.
Experiments across various travel scenarios show that TRIP-PAL outperforms standalone LLM-based approaches, demonstrating the benefits of this hybrid approach. While the research acknowledges some limitations and areas for further exploration, such as the robustness of the translation process and the ongoing advancements in the underlying technologies, TRIP-PAL represents a promising step towards more effective and user-centric travel planning solutions.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
Large Language Models Can Plan Your Travels Rigorously with Formal Verification Tools
Yilun Hao, Yongchao Chen, Yang Zhang, Chuchu Fan
0
0
The recent advancements of Large Language Models (LLMs), with their abundant world knowledge and capabilities of tool-using and reasoning, fostered many LLM planning algorithms. However, LLMs have not shown to be able to accurately solve complex combinatorial optimization problems. In Xie et al. (2024), the authors proposed TravelPlanner, a U.S. domestic travel planning benchmark, and showed that LLMs themselves cannot make travel plans that satisfy user requirements with a best success rate of 0.6%. In this work, we propose a framework that enables LLMs to formally formulate and solve the travel planning problem as a satisfiability modulo theory (SMT) problem and use SMT solvers interactively and automatically solve the combinatorial search problem. The SMT solvers guarantee the satisfiable of input constraints and the LLMs can enable a language-based interaction with our framework. When the input constraints cannot be satisfiable, our LLM-based framework will interactively offer suggestions to users to modify their travel requirements via automatic reasoning using the SMT solvers. We evaluate our framework with TravelPlanner and achieve a success rate of 97%. We also create a separate dataset that contain international travel benchmarks and use both dataset to evaluate the effectiveness of our interactive planning framework when the initial user queries cannot be satisfied. Our framework could generate valid plans with an average success rate of 78.6% for our dataset and 85.0% for TravelPlanner according to diverse humans preferences.
4/22/2024
💬
TravelPlanner: A Benchmark for Real-World Planning with Language Agents
Jian Xie, Kai Zhang, Jiangjie Chen, Tinghui Zhu, Renze Lou, Yuandong Tian, Yanghua Xiao, Yu Su
0
0
Planning has been part of the core pursuit for artificial intelligence since its conception, but earlier AI agents mostly focused on constrained settings because many of the cognitive substrates necessary for human-level planning have been lacking. Recently, language agents powered by large language models (LLMs) have shown interesting capabilities such as tool use and reasoning. Are these language agents capable of planning in more complex settings that are out of the reach of prior AI agents? To advance this investigation, we propose TravelPlanner, a new planning benchmark that focuses on travel planning, a common real-world planning scenario. It provides a rich sandbox environment, various tools for accessing nearly four million data records, and 1,225 meticulously curated planning intents and reference plans. Comprehensive evaluations show that the current language agents are not yet capable of handling such complex planning tasks-even GPT-4 only achieves a success rate of 0.6%. Language agents struggle to stay on task, use the right tools to collect information, or keep track of multiple constraints. However, we note that the mere possibility for language agents to tackle such a complex problem is in itself non-trivial progress. TravelPlanner provides a challenging yet meaningful testbed for future language agents.
6/26/2024
Enhancing Travel Choice Modeling with Large Language Models: A Prompt-Learning Approach
Xuehao Zhai, Hanlin Tian, Lintong Li, Tianyu Zhao
0
0
Travel choice analysis is crucial for understanding individual travel behavior to develop appropriate transport policies and recommendation systems in Intelligent Transportation Systems (ITS). Despite extensive research, this domain faces two critical challenges: a) modeling with limited survey data, and b) simultaneously achieving high model explainability and accuracy. In this paper, we introduce a novel prompt-learning-based Large Language Model(LLM) framework that significantly improves prediction accuracy and provides explicit explanations for individual predictions. This framework involves three main steps: transforming input variables into textual form; building of demonstrations similar to the object, and applying these to a well-trained LLM. We tested the framework's efficacy using two widely used choice datasets: London Passenger Mode Choice (LPMC) and Optima-Mode collected in Switzerland. The results indicate that the LLM significantly outperforms state-of-the-art deep learning methods and discrete choice models in predicting people's choices. Additionally, we present a case of explanation illustrating how the LLM framework generates understandable and explicit explanations at the individual level.
6/26/2024
NATURAL PLAN: Benchmarking LLMs on Natural Language Planning
Huaixiu Steven Zheng, Swaroop Mishra, Hugh Zhang, Xinyun Chen, Minmin Chen, Azade Nova, Le Hou, Heng-Tze Cheng, Quoc V. Le, Ed H. Chi, Denny Zhou
0
0
We introduce NATURAL PLAN, a realistic planning benchmark in natural language containing 3 key tasks: Trip Planning, Meeting Planning, and Calendar Scheduling. We focus our evaluation on the planning capabilities of LLMs with full information on the task, by providing outputs from tools such as Google Flights, Google Maps, and Google Calendar as contexts to the models. This eliminates the need for a tool-use environment for evaluating LLMs on Planning. We observe that NATURAL PLAN is a challenging benchmark for state of the art models. For example, in Trip Planning, GPT-4 and Gemini 1.5 Pro could only achieve 31.1% and 34.8% solve rate respectively. We find that model performance drops drastically as the complexity of the problem increases: all models perform below 5% when there are 10 cities, highlighting a significant gap in planning in natural language for SoTA LLMs. We also conduct extensive ablation studies on NATURAL PLAN to further shed light on the (in)effectiveness of approaches such as self-correction, few-shot generalization, and in-context planning with long-contexts on improving LLM planning.
6/10/2024