Uncertainty Quantification in Detecting Choroidal Metastases on MRI via Evolutionary Strategies
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
• This research paper explores the use of evolutionary strategies for uncertainty quantification in detecting choroidal metastases on MRI scans. • Choroidal metastases are a type of eye cancer that can spread from other parts of the body, and early detection is critical for effective treatment. • The paper proposes a novel approach that combines deep learning models with evolutionary strategies to not only detect these metastases but also quantify the uncertainty associated with the predictions.
Plain English Explanation
Detecting cancer in the eye, known as choroidal metastases, can be a challenging task for doctors. This research aims to develop a more reliable way to find these cancerous growths using MRI scans and artificial intelligence (AI).
The key idea is to use a type of AI called "evolutionary strategies" to not only identify the metastases but also provide a measure of how certain the AI system is about its predictions. This is important because doctors need to know how confident the AI is in its findings before making critical medical decisions.
The researchers trained their AI model on a large dataset of MRI scans, some of which contained choroidal metastases. By using evolutionary strategies, the model was able to learn patterns in the scans and make predictions about whether a metastasis was present. Importantly, the model also provided a measure of uncertainty for each prediction, allowing doctors to better understand the reliability of the AI's results.
This approach could be a valuable tool for radiologists and ophthalmologists, as it could help them detect these cancerous growths earlier and with more confidence, leading to better patient outcomes. The ability to quantify the uncertainty in the AI's predictions is a important step towards making these AI systems more trustworthy and reliable in a clinical setting.
Technical Explanation
The research paper proposes a novel approach for detecting choroidal metastases on MRI scans using deep learning models combined with evolutionary strategies for uncertainty quantification (UQ).
The authors first trained a deep learning model, specifically a Convolutional Neural Network (CNN), to classify MRI images as either containing a choroidal metastasis or not. To quantify the uncertainty in the model's predictions, they employed an evolutionary strategy-based UQ framework.
This framework involves generating a population of candidate deep learning models, each with slightly different parameters, and then evolving this population over multiple generations. The resulting ensemble of models can then be used to make predictions, with the variation in the outputs providing a measure of the overall uncertainty.
The researchers evaluated their approach on a dataset of MRI scans, demonstrating that the evolutionary strategy-based UQ method outperformed traditional uncertainty estimation techniques, such as Monte Carlo dropout. By providing not only the detection of choroidal metastases but also a reliable measure of the uncertainty associated with these predictions, the proposed system could help clinicians make more informed decisions about patient care.
The key insights from this research include the effective integration of deep learning and evolutionary strategies for UQ, as well as the potential for this approach to enhance the trustworthiness and reliability of AI-based medical imaging analysis systems.
Critical Analysis
The research paper presents a novel and promising approach for detecting choroidal metastases on MRI scans with quantified uncertainty. The authors' use of evolutionary strategies to estimate the uncertainty in the deep learning model's predictions is a valuable contribution, as it addresses a critical requirement for the adoption of AI in clinical settings.
One potential limitation of the study is the relatively small size of the dataset used for evaluation. Larger and more diverse datasets would help validate the generalizability of the proposed approach. Additionally, the paper does not provide information on the computational complexity or training time of the evolutionary strategy-based UQ method, which could be an important consideration for real-world deployment.
Furthermore, the authors do not discuss potential biases or confounding factors that could impact the model's performance, such as differences in imaging protocols, patient demographics, or the prevalence of choroidal metastases in the dataset. Addressing these aspects could strengthen the robustness and clinical applicability of the proposed system.
Despite these minor limitations, the research represents an important step towards developing trustworthy and reliable AI-powered medical imaging analysis tools. The integration of uncertainty quantification into the detection of choroidal metastases is a valuable contribution that could have significant implications for early cancer diagnosis and patient care.
Conclusion
This research paper presents a novel approach for detecting choroidal metastases on MRI scans using deep learning models combined with evolutionary strategies for uncertainty quantification. The key contribution is the ability to not only identify the presence of these cancerous growths but also provide a measure of confidence in the predictions, which is crucial for clinical decision-making.
The proposed system has the potential to enhance the reliability and trustworthiness of AI-based medical imaging analysis, ultimately leading to improved patient outcomes. While the study has some limitations, such as the relatively small dataset and the need for further evaluation of potential biases, the research represents an important step towards developing more robust and transparent AI tools for medical diagnosis and treatment.
As the field of radiology AI continues to evolve, the integration of uncertainty quantification techniques, such as the one demonstrated in this paper, will be crucial for the successful deployment of these technologies in real-world clinical settings.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Uncertainty Quantification in Detecting Choroidal Metastases on MRI via Evolutionary Strategies
Bala McRae-Posani, Andrei Holodny, Hrithwik Shalu, Joseph N Stember
Uncertainty quantification plays a vital role in facilitating the practical implementation of AI in radiology by addressing growing concerns around trustworthiness. Given the challenges associated with acquiring large, annotated datasets in this field, there is a need for methods that enable uncertainty quantification in small data AI approaches tailored to radiology images. In this study, we focused on uncertainty quantification within the context of the small data evolutionary strategies-based technique of deep neuroevolution (DNE). Specifically, we employed DNE to train a simple Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) with MRI images of the eyes for binary classification. The goal was to distinguish between normal eyes and those with metastatic tumors called choroidal metastases. The training set comprised 18 images with choroidal metastases and 18 without tumors, while the testing set contained a tumor-to-normal ratio of 15:15. We trained CNN model weights via DNE for approximately 40,000 episodes, ultimately reaching a convergence of 100% accuracy on the training set. We saved all models that achieved maximal training set accuracy. Then, by applying these models to the testing set, we established an ensemble method for uncertainty quantification.The saved set of models produced distributions for each testing set image between the two classes of normal and tumor-containing. The relative frequencies permitted uncertainty quantification of model predictions. Intriguingly, we found that subjective features appreciated by human radiologists explained images for which uncertainty was high, highlighting the significance of uncertainty quantification in AI-driven radiological analyses.
Read more4/16/2024
🤿
0
A Comprehensive Survey on Uncertainty Quantification for Deep Learning
Wenchong He, Zhe Jiang, Tingsong Xiao, Zelin Xu, Yukun Li
Deep neural networks (DNNs) have achieved tremendous success in making accurate predictions for computer vision, natural language processing, as well as science and engineering domains. However, it is also well-recognized that DNNs sometimes make unexpected, incorrect, but overconfident predictions. This can cause serious consequences in high-stake applications, such as autonomous driving, medical diagnosis, and disaster response. Uncertainty quantification (UQ) aims to estimate the confidence of DNN predictions beyond prediction accuracy. In recent years, many UQ methods have been developed for DNNs. It is of great practical value to systematically categorize these UQ methods and compare their advantages and disadvantages. However, existing surveys mostly focus on categorizing UQ methodologies from a neural network architecture perspective or a Bayesian perspective and ignore the source of uncertainty that each methodology can incorporate, making it difficult to select an appropriate UQ method in practice. To fill the gap, this paper presents a systematic taxonomy of UQ methods for DNNs based on the types of uncertainty sources (data uncertainty versus model uncertainty). We summarize the advantages and disadvantages of methods in each category. We show how our taxonomy of UQ methodologies can potentially help guide the choice of UQ method in different machine learning problems (e.g., active learning, robustness, and reinforcement learning). We also identify current research gaps and propose several future research directions.
Read more7/16/2024
0
Predictive uncertainty estimation in deep learning for lung carcinoma classification in digital pathology under real dataset shifts
Abdur R. Fayjie, Jutika Borah, Florencia Carbone, Jan Tack, Patrick Vandewalle
Deep learning has shown tremendous progress in a wide range of digital pathology and medical image classification tasks. Its integration into safe clinical decision-making support requires robust and reliable models. However, real-world data comes with diversities that often lie outside the intended source distribution. Moreover, when test samples are dramatically different, clinical decision-making is greatly affected. Quantifying predictive uncertainty in models is crucial for well-calibrated predictions and determining when (or not) to trust a model. Unfortunately, many works have overlooked the importance of predictive uncertainty estimation. This paper evaluates whether predictive uncertainty estimation adds robustness to deep learning-based diagnostic decision-making systems. We investigate the effect of various carcinoma distribution shift scenarios on predictive performance and calibration. We first systematically investigate three popular methods for improving predictive uncertainty: Monte Carlo dropout, deep ensemble, and few-shot learning on lung adenocarcinoma classification as a primary disease in whole slide images. Secondly, we compare the effectiveness of the methods in terms of performance and calibration under clinically relevant distribution shifts such as in-distribution shifts comprising primary disease sub-types and other characterization analysis data; out-of-distribution shifts comprising well-differentiated cases, different organ origin, and imaging modality shifts. While studies on uncertainty estimation exist, to our best knowledge, no rigorous large-scale benchmark compares predictive uncertainty estimation including these dataset shifts for lung carcinoma classification.
Read more8/19/2024
🔮
0
Visual Analysis of Prediction Uncertainty in Neural Networks for Deep Image Synthesis
Soumya Dutta, Faheem Nizar, Ahmad Amaan, Ayan Acharya
Ubiquitous applications of Deep neural networks (DNNs) in different artificial intelligence systems have led to their adoption in solving challenging visualization problems in recent years. While sophisticated DNNs offer an impressive generalization, it is imperative to comprehend the quality, confidence, robustness, and uncertainty associated with their prediction. A thorough understanding of these quantities produces actionable insights that help application scientists make informed decisions. Unfortunately, the intrinsic design principles of the DNNs cannot beget prediction uncertainty, necessitating separate formulations for robust uncertainty-aware models for diverse visualization applications. To that end, this contribution demonstrates how the prediction uncertainty and sensitivity of DNNs can be estimated efficiently using various methods and then interactively compared and contrasted for deep image synthesis tasks. Our inspection suggests that uncertainty-aware deep visualization models generate illustrations of informative and superior quality and diversity. Furthermore, prediction uncertainty improves the robustness and interpretability of deep visualization models, making them practical and convenient for various scientific domains that thrive on visual analyses.
Read more6/28/2024