Uncertainty Voting Ensemble for Imbalanced Deep Regression

Read original: arXiv:2305.15178 - Published 9/6/2024 by Yuchang Jiang, Vivien Sainte Fare Garnot, Konrad Schindler, Jan Dirk Wegner

🤿

Overview

Data imbalance is a common problem in real-world machine learning applications, especially for regression problems.
Existing approaches like oversampling or reweighting can help, but recent work has explored two main strategies: leveraging the continuity of the target distribution for regression, and using ensemble methods for classification.
The authors propose a new method called UVOTE that combines advances in probabilistic deep learning with an ensemble approach for imbalanced regression.

Plain English Explanation

In the real world, the data we use to train machine learning models is often [object Object]. This means some parts of the data are much more common than others. For example, if you're trying to predict house prices, you might have lots of data on moderately priced homes but very little data on luxury mansions.

When the training data is imbalanced, the model tends to focus on the more common regions and perform poorly in the sparser regions. Researchers have explored a few ways to address this:

For [object Object] problems (where the goal is to predict a continuous value), some have used the fact that the target variable changes gradually, not just in discrete jumps.
For [object Object] problems (where the goal is to predict a category), the trend has been to use [object Object] - combining the predictions of multiple models, with some specializing in the sparser regions.

The authors of this paper propose a new method called UVOTE that combines these ideas. UVOTE uses probabilistic deep learning to not only make predictions, but also estimate the [object Object] in those predictions. It then uses that uncertainty information to combine the predictions of an ensemble of models, focusing more on the models that are more confident in the sparser regions.

Technical Explanation

The key elements of the UVOTE method are:

Probabilistic Deep Learning: Instead of using traditional regression loss functions, UVOTE uses a [object Object] loss. This not only predicts the target value, but also estimates the [object Object] (the inherent unpredictability) in the prediction.
Ensemble Approach: UVOTE trains multiple "expert" models in an ensemble. Each model specializes in different regions of the input space, helping to handle the imbalance.
Uncertainty-Weighted Fusion: UVOTE uses the predicted aleatoric uncertainty values to [object Object] the predictions of the different expert models, without needing a separate aggregation module. Models that are more certain in a given region are weighted more heavily.

The authors evaluate UVOTE on multiple public benchmark datasets and show that it outperforms previous methods, while also producing better-calibrated uncertainty estimates.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough evaluation of UVOTE and compares it to several existing approaches. However, a few potential limitations or areas for further research are worth noting:

The paper focuses on regression tasks, but it would be interesting to see how UVOTE performs on classification problems with imbalanced data as well.
The authors mention that UVOTE can handle multi-modal target distributions, but they don't provide any specific experiments or analysis on such cases.
While the ensemble approach helps handle imbalance, the authors don't explore the trade-offs between the number of expert models and the overall performance and computational cost.
The paper doesn't delve into the interpretability or explainability of the UVOTE predictions and uncertainty estimates, which could be an important consideration in some real-world applications.

Overall, the UVOTE method represents an innovative approach to tackling imbalanced regression problems, and the authors have done a commendable job of validating its effectiveness. Further research exploring the method's broader applicability and investigating some of the potential limitations could help strengthen the contribution.

Conclusion

The UVOTE method proposed in this paper offers a promising solution for addressing data imbalance in real-world regression problems. By integrating advances in probabilistic deep learning with an uncertainty-weighted ensemble approach, UVOTE is able to outperform previous techniques while also providing better-calibrated uncertainty estimates.

This work highlights the importance of considering the unique challenges posed by imbalanced data and the value of exploring novel architectures and loss functions to handle such scenarios. As machine learning continues to be applied to an ever-widening range of real-world applications, methods like UVOTE will become increasingly crucial for ensuring the reliability and robustness of these systems.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🤿

Uncertainty Voting Ensemble for Imbalanced Deep Regression

Yuchang Jiang, Vivien Sainte Fare Garnot, Konrad Schindler, Jan Dirk Wegner

Data imbalance is ubiquitous when applying machine learning to real-world problems, particularly regression problems. If training data are imbalanced, the learning is dominated by the densely covered regions of the target distribution and the learned regressor tends to exhibit poor performance in sparsely covered regions. Beyond standard measures like oversampling or reweighting, there are two main approaches to handling learning from imbalanced data. For regression, recent work leverages the continuity of the distribution, while for classification, the trend has been to use ensemble methods, allowing some members to specialize in predictions for sparser regions. In our method, named UVOTE, we integrate recent advances in probabilistic deep learning with an ensemble approach for imbalanced regression. We replace traditional regression losses with negative log-likelihood, which also predicts sample-wise aleatoric uncertainty. Our experiments show that this loss function handles imbalance better. Additionally, we use the predicted aleatoric uncertainty values to fuse the predictions of different expert models in the ensemble, eliminating the need for a separate aggregation module. We compare our method with existing alternatives on multiple public benchmarks and show that UVOTE consistently outperforms the prior art, while at the same time producing better-calibrated uncertainty estimates. Our code is available at link-upon-publication.

9/6/2024

Uncertainty-Based Ensemble Learning For Speech Classification

Bagus Tris Atmaja, Felix Burkhardt

Speech classification has attracted increasing attention due to its wide applications, particularly in classifying physical and mental states. However, these tasks are challenging due to the high variability in speech signals. Ensemble learning has shown promising results when multiple classifiers are combined to improve performance. With recent advancements in hardware development, combining several models is not a limitation in deep learning research and applications. In this paper, we propose an uncertainty-based ensemble learning approach for speech classification. Specifically, we train a set of base features on the same classifier and quantify the uncertainty of their predictions. The predictions are combined using variants of uncertainty calculation to produce the final prediction. The visualization of the effect of uncertainty and its ensemble learning results show potential improvements in speech classification tasks. The proposed method outperforms single models and conventional ensemble learning methods in terms of unweighted accuracy or weighted accuracy.

7/25/2024

Awareness of uncertainty in classification using a multivariate model and multi-views

Alexey Kornaev, Elena Kornaeva, Oleg Ivanov, Ilya Pershin, Danis Alukaev

One of the ways to make artificial intelligence more natural is to give it some room for doubt. Two main questions should be resolved in that way. First, how to train a model to estimate uncertainties of its own predictions? And then, what to do with the uncertain predictions if they appear? First, we proposed an uncertainty-aware negative log-likelihood loss for the case of N-dimensional multivariate normal distribution with spherical variance matrix to the solution of N-classes classification tasks. The loss is similar to the heteroscedastic regression loss. The proposed model regularizes uncertain predictions, and trains to calculate both the predictions and their uncertainty estimations. The model fits well with the label smoothing technique. Second, we expanded the limits of data augmentation at the training and test stages, and made the trained model to give multiple predictions for a given number of augmented versions of each test sample. Given the multi-view predictions together with their uncertainties and confidences, we proposed several methods to calculate final predictions, including mode values and bin counts with soft and hard weights. For the latter method, we formalized the model tuning task in the form of multimodal optimization with non-differentiable criteria of maximum accuracy, and applied particle swarm optimization to solve the tuning task. The proposed methodology was tested using CIFAR-10 dataset with clean and noisy labels and demonstrated good results in comparison with other uncertainty estimation methods related to sample selection, co-teaching, and label smoothing.

4/17/2024

👨‍🏫

Zero-Shot Uncertainty Quantification using Diffusion Probabilistic Models

Dule Shu, Amir Barati Farimani

The success of diffusion probabilistic models in generative tasks, such as text-to-image generation, has motivated the exploration of their application to regression problems commonly encountered in scientific computing and various other domains. In this context, the use of diffusion regression models for ensemble prediction is becoming a practice with increasing popularity. Under such background, we conducted a study to quantitatively evaluate the effectiveness of ensemble methods on solving different regression problems using diffusion models. We consider the ensemble prediction of a diffusion model as a means for zero-shot uncertainty quantification, since the diffusion models in our study are not trained with a loss function containing any uncertainty estimation. Through extensive experiments on 1D and 2D data, we demonstrate that ensemble methods consistently improve model prediction accuracy across various regression tasks. Notably, we observed a larger accuracy gain in auto-regressive prediction compared with point-wise prediction, and that enhancements take place in both the mean-square error and the physics-informed loss. Additionally, we reveal a statistical correlation between ensemble prediction error and ensemble variance, offering insights into balancing computational complexity with prediction accuracy and monitoring prediction confidence in practical applications where the ground truth is unknown. Our study provides a comprehensive view of the utility of diffusion ensembles, serving as a useful reference for practitioners employing diffusion models in regression problem-solving.

8/12/2024