A User Interface Study on Sustainable City Trip Recommendations
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a user interface study on sustainable city trip recommendations, exploring how to encourage eco-friendly transportation choices.
- The researchers developed a prototype trip planning system and evaluated it with users to understand their preferences and decision-making around sustainable transportation options.
- The findings provide insights into design considerations for future sustainable mobility systems and recommender interfaces.
Plain English Explanation
The paper looks at how to design trip planning tools that encourage people to choose more environmentally-friendly transportation options when visiting cities. The researchers created a prototype system that suggested sustainable transportation choices, like walking, biking, or taking public transit, alongside traditional driving routes.
They then had people test out this system and provide feedback. This helped the researchers understand what features and information are most important to users when deciding how to get around a city in a sustainable way. For example, users wanted to see the estimated carbon emissions or environmental impact of each transportation option, not just the travel time.
The insights from this study can inform the design of future trip planning applications that aim to nudge people towards greener mobility choices, which is an important step in creating more sustainable cities. By making it easier for people to choose eco-friendly transportation, these kinds of systems could have a meaningful impact on reducing urban carbon emissions and environmental harm.
Technical Explanation
The researchers developed a prototype trip planning interface that integrated sustainability information for transportation options, building on prior work on augmented reality for sustainable dining and balancing sustainability trade-offs. The interface displayed estimated CO2 emissions, travel time, and cost for walking, biking, public transit, and driving routes between a starting point and destination in a city.
They evaluated this prototype with 20 participants through a user study, tracking their decision-making process and collecting feedback on the system's design and information presentation. The study found that users valued having sustainability metrics alongside traditional travel time and cost data when selecting transportation options. However, some participants also desired more granular environmental impact information, such as energy usage or air pollution levels.
The paper provides design recommendations for future sustainable mobility recommender systems, including the need to guide users through social media information to support informed transportation choices. The authors also discuss the trade-offs between providing comprehensive sustainability data and maintaining a simple, intuitive interface.
Critical Analysis
The user study provides valuable insights, but the sample size is relatively small and may not capture the full diversity of user preferences and decision-making factors around sustainable transportation. Additionally, the study was conducted in a lab setting rather than with users making real-world trip planning decisions, which could affect the ecological validity of the findings.
The paper also does not explore how the prototype system might be integrated with existing trip planning platforms or transportation services, which would be an important consideration for real-world deployment and adoption. Further research is needed to understand how such sustainable mobility recommender systems could be seamlessly incorporated into people's existing travel planning workflows.
Finally, the study focuses on individual user behavior and preferences, but the broader societal and infrastructural changes needed to enable widespread sustainable urban mobility are not discussed. The authors acknowledge this limitation and suggest future work should examine the systemic challenges and policy implications of promoting eco-friendly transportation choices.
Conclusion
This user interface study provides valuable insights for designing sustainable city trip planning systems that can encourage more environmentally-friendly transportation choices. By integrating sustainability metrics and information alongside traditional travel data, these kinds of recommender interfaces have the potential to positively influence urban mobility patterns and reduce the environmental impact of city travel.
However, realizing this potential will require addressing broader systemic challenges, such as gaps in transportation infrastructure and the social and cultural factors that shape travel behavior. Continued research and collaboration between designers, urban planners, and policymakers will be essential for developing holistic solutions to support sustainable urban mobility.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
A User Interface Study on Sustainable City Trip Recommendations
Ashmi Banerjee, Tunar Mahmudov, Wolfgang Worndl
The importance of promoting sustainable and environmentally responsible practices is becoming increasingly recognized in all domains, including tourism. The impact of tourism extends beyond its immediate stakeholders and affects passive participants such as the environment, local businesses, and residents. City trips, in particular, offer significant opportunities to encourage sustainable tourism practices by directing travelers towards destinations that minimize environmental impact while providing enriching experiences. Tourism Recommender Systems (TRS) can play a critical role in this. By integrating sustainability features in TRS, travelers can be guided towards destinations that meet their preferences and align with sustainability objectives. This paper investigates how different user interface design elements affect the promotion of sustainable city trip choices. We explore the impact of various features on user decisions, including sustainability labels for transportation modes and their emissions, popularity indicators for destinations, seasonality labels reflecting crowd levels for specific months, and an overall sustainability composite score. Through a user study involving mockups, participants evaluated the helpfulness of these features in guiding them toward more sustainable travel options. Our findings indicate that sustainability labels significantly influence users towards lower-carbon footprint options, while popularity and seasonality indicators guide users to less crowded and more seasonally appropriate destinations. This study emphasizes the importance of providing users with clear and informative sustainability information, which can help them make more sustainable travel choices. It lays the groundwork for future applications that can recommend sustainable destinations in real-time.
Read more5/21/2024
0
Modeling Sustainable City Trips: Integrating CO2e Emissions, Popularity, and Seasonality into Tourism Recommender Systems
Ashmi Banerjee, Tunar Mahmudov, Emil Adler, Fitri Nur Aisyah, Wolfgang Worndl
Tourism affects not only the tourism industry but also society and stakeholders such as the environment, local businesses, and residents. Tourism Recommender Systems (TRS) can be pivotal in promoting sustainable tourism by guiding travelers toward destinations with minimal negative impact. Our paper introduces a composite sustainability indicator for a city trip TRS based on the users' starting point and month of travel. This indicator integrates CO2e emissions for different transportation modes and analyses destination popularity and seasonal demand. We quantify city popularity based on user reviews, points of interest, and search trends from Tripadvisor and Google Trends data. To calculate a seasonal demand index, we leverage data from TourMIS and Airbnb. We conducted a user study to explore the fundamental trade-offs in travel decision-making and determine the weights for our proposed indicator. Finally, we demonstrate the integration of this indicator into a TRS, illustrating its ability to deliver sustainable city trip recommendations. This work lays the foundation for future research by integrating sustainability measures and contributing to responsible recommendations by TRS.
Read more5/7/2024
📊
0
Address-Specific Sustainable Accommodation Choice Through Real-World Data Integration
Peter J. Bentley, Rajat Mathur, Soo Ling Lim, Sid Narang
Consumers wish to choose sustainable accommodation for their travels, and in the case of corporations, may be required to do so. Yet accommodation marketplaces provide no meaningful capability for sustainable choice: typically CO2 estimates are provided that are identical for all accommodation of the same type across an entire country. We propose a decision support system that enables real choice of sustainable accommodation. We develop a data-driven address-specific metric called EcoGrade, which integrates government approved datasets and uses interpolation where data is sparse. We validate the metric on 10,000 UK addresses in 10 cities, showing the match of our interpolations to reality is statistically significant. We show how the metric has been embedded into a decision support system for a global accommodation marketplace and tested by real users over several months with positive user feedback. In the EU, forty percent of final energy consumption is from buildings. We need to encourage all building owners to make their accommodation more efficient. The rental sector is one area where change can occur rapidly, as rented accommodation is renovated frequently. We anticipate our decision support system using EcoGrade will encourage this positive change.
Read more8/19/2024
0
Modeling Urban Transport Choices: Incorporating Sociocultural Aspects
Kathleen Salazar-Serna, Lorena Cadavid, Carlos J. Franco
This paper introduces an agent-based simulation model aimed at understanding urban commuters mode choices and evaluating the impacts of transport policies to promote sustainable mobility. Crafted for developing countries, where utilitarian travel heavily relies on motorcycles, the model integrates sociocultural factors that influence transport behavior. Multinomial models and inferential statistics applied to survey data from Cali, Colombia, inform the model, revealing significant influences of sociodemographic factors and travel attributes on mode choice. Findings highlight the importance of cost, time, safety, comfort, and personal security, with disparities across socioeconomic groups. Policy simulations demonstrate positive responses to interventions like free public transportation, increased bus frequency, and enhanced security, yet with modest shifts in mode choice. Multifaceted policy approaches are deemed more effective, addressing diverse user preferences. Outputs can be extended to cities with similar sociocultural characteristics and transport dynamics. The methodology applied in this work can be replicated for other territories.
Read more8/1/2024