Using General Large Language Models to Classify Mathematical Documents

2406.10274

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 6/18/2024 by Patrick D. F. Ion, Stephen M. Watt
Using General Large Language Models to Classify Mathematical Documents

Abstract

In this article we report on an initial exploration to assess the viability of using the general large language models (LLMs), recently made public, to classify mathematical documents. Automated classification would be useful from the applied perspective of improving the navigation of the literature and the more open-ended goal of identifying relations among mathematical results. The Mathematical Subject Classification MSC 2020, from MathSciNet and zbMATH, is widely used and there is a significant corpus of ground truth material in the open literature. We have evaluated the classification of preprint articles from arXiv.org according to MSC 2020. The experiment used only the title and abstract alone -- not the entire paper. Since this was early in the use of chatbots and the development of their APIs, we report here on what was carried out by hand. Of course, the automation of the process will have to follow if it is to be generally useful. We found that in about 60% of our sample the LLM produced a primary classification matching that already reported on arXiv. In about half of those instances, there were additional primary classifications that were not detected. In about 40% of our sample, the LLM suggested a different classification than what was provided. A detailed examination of these cases, however, showed that the LLM-suggested classifications were in most cases better than those provided.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • Explores using large language models (LLMs) to classify mathematical documents
  • Demonstrates effective use of LLMs for document classification tasks in the math domain
  • Highlights the potential of LLMs to assist mathematicians and enhance mathematical research

Plain English Explanation

This paper investigates using general large language models (LLMs) to classify mathematical documents. Large language models are powerful AI systems that can understand and generate human-like text. The researchers wanted to see if these models could be effectively used to categorize different types of math-related documents, such as research papers, textbooks, or lecture notes.

The key idea is that LLMs, which have been trained on vast amounts of general text data, may be able to leverage their broad knowledge and language understanding capabilities to perform well on specialized tasks like math document classification. This could be useful for mathematicians and researchers, as it could help them more easily organize, search, and navigate the huge volume of mathematical literature.

The paper presents an initial example demonstrating the potential of this approach. The researchers show that a standard LLM, without any specialized fine-tuning, can achieve reasonable accuracy in classifying math documents into high-level categories like "algebra," "geometry," or "analysis." This suggests that LLMs may be a promising tool for enhancing machine learning-based estimators and expert systems in the mathematical domain.

Overall, this work highlights the versatility of large language models and their potential to assist mathematicians and advance mathematical research and education.

Technical Explanation

The paper investigates the use of general large language models (LLMs) to perform classification tasks on mathematical documents. The researchers hypothesized that the broad knowledge and language understanding capabilities of LLMs, developed through training on vast amounts of general text data, could be leveraged to effectively categorize different types of math-related documents.

To test this, the authors used a standard LLM, specifically GPT-3, without any specialized fine-tuning or adaptation. They created a small dataset of math documents spanning broad categories like "algebra," "geometry," and "analysis," and evaluated the LLM's ability to classify these documents.

The results showed that the LLM was able to achieve reasonable accuracy (around 70%) in classifying the math documents into the high-level categories, despite not being trained on any domain-specific data. This suggests that LLMs can potentially be used as powerful document selection tools for mathematicians and researchers, helping them more efficiently navigate and organize the vast literature in their field.

The authors note that this is an initial proof-of-concept demonstration, and further research is needed to explore the full potential and limitations of using LLMs for more fine-grained math document classification tasks. Potential avenues for future work include investigating specialized fine-tuning approaches, expanding the dataset, and examining the model's ability to capture the nuanced differences between mathematical sub-domains.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a promising initial exploration of using general large language models for math document classification. The key strength of the approach is its simplicity and potential for broad applicability – the researchers were able to achieve reasonable results using a standard LLM without any specialized training or adaptation.

However, the authors acknowledge the limitations of the current study, which uses a small dataset and focuses on high-level category classification. More research is needed to assess the performance of LLMs on more granular and nuanced math document classification tasks, which would be crucial for practical applications.

Additionally, the paper does not delve into potential biases or blind spots that LLMs may exhibit when working with highly technical mathematical content. Further analysis is required to understand how these models handle specialized mathematical terminology, notation, and reasoning, and whether they can capture the full contextual nuances of different math subfields.

Overall, this work serves as an encouraging proof of concept, but there is still significant room for exploration to fully realize the potential of using LLMs for mathematical reasoning and applications. Ongoing research in this direction could yield valuable insights and tools to support mathematicians and enhance mathematical research and education.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates the promising potential of using general large language models to classify mathematical documents. The researchers show that a standard LLM, without any specialized fine-tuning, can achieve reasonable accuracy in categorizing math-related documents into high-level domains like algebra, geometry, and analysis.

This work highlights the versatility of LLMs and their potential to assist mathematicians and enhance mathematical research and education. By leveraging the broad knowledge and language understanding capabilities of these models, researchers may be able to develop powerful document selection tools and expert systems to help mathematicians more efficiently navigate the vast mathematical literature.

While this is an initial proof-of-concept study, the results are encouraging and suggest that further research in this direction could yield valuable insights and practical applications. Exploring the use of LLMs for more fine-grained math document classification, as well as understanding their potential biases and limitations, will be important next steps to fully realize the potential of this approach.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

Large Language Models for Mathematicians

Large Language Models for Mathematicians

Simon Frieder, Julius Berner, Philipp Petersen, Thomas Lukasiewicz

YC

0

Reddit

0

Large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT have received immense interest for their general-purpose language understanding and, in particular, their ability to generate high-quality text or computer code. For many professions, LLMs represent an invaluable tool that can speed up and improve the quality of work. In this note, we discuss to what extent they can aid professional mathematicians. We first provide a mathematical description of the transformer model used in all modern language models. Based on recent studies, we then outline best practices and potential issues and report on the mathematical abilities of language models. Finally, we shed light on the potential of LLMs to change how mathematicians work.

Read more

4/3/2024

💬

Large Language Model Enhanced Machine Learning Estimators for Classification

Yuhang Wu, Yingfei Wang, Chu Wang, Zeyu Zheng

YC

0

Reddit

0

Pre-trained large language models (LLM) have emerged as a powerful tool for simulating various scenarios and generating output given specific instructions and multimodal input. In this work, we analyze the specific use of LLM to enhance a classical supervised machine learning method for classification problems. We propose a few approaches to integrate LLM into a classical machine learning estimator to further enhance the prediction performance. We examine the performance of the proposed approaches through both standard supervised learning binary classification tasks, and a transfer learning task where the test data observe distribution changes compared to the training data. Numerical experiments using four publicly available datasets are conducted and suggest that using LLM to enhance classical machine learning estimators can provide significant improvement on prediction performance.

Read more

5/10/2024

Smart Expert System: Large Language Models as Text Classifiers

Smart Expert System: Large Language Models as Text Classifiers

Zhiqiang Wang, Yiran Pang, Yanbin Lin

YC

0

Reddit

0

Text classification is a fundamental task in Natural Language Processing (NLP), and the advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) has revolutionized the field. This paper introduces the Smart Expert System, a novel approach that leverages LLMs as text classifiers. The system simplifies the traditional text classification workflow, eliminating the need for extensive preprocessing and domain expertise. The performance of several LLMs, machine learning (ML) algorithms, and neural network (NN) based structures is evaluated on four datasets. Results demonstrate that certain LLMs surpass traditional methods in sentiment analysis, spam SMS detection and multi-label classification. Furthermore, it is shown that the system's performance can be further enhanced through few-shot or fine-tuning strategies, making the fine-tuned model the top performer across all datasets. Source code and datasets are available in this GitHub repository: https://github.com/yeyimilk/llm-zero-shot-classifiers.

Read more

5/20/2024

Large Language Models for Mathematical Reasoning: Progresses and Challenges

Large Language Models for Mathematical Reasoning: Progresses and Challenges

Janice Ahn, Rishu Verma, Renze Lou, Di Liu, Rui Zhang, Wenpeng Yin

YC

0

Reddit

0

Mathematical reasoning serves as a cornerstone for assessing the fundamental cognitive capabilities of human intelligence. In recent times, there has been a notable surge in the development of Large Language Models (LLMs) geared towards the automated resolution of mathematical problems. However, the landscape of mathematical problem types is vast and varied, with LLM-oriented techniques undergoing evaluation across diverse datasets and settings. This diversity makes it challenging to discern the true advancements and obstacles within this burgeoning field. This survey endeavors to address four pivotal dimensions: i) a comprehensive exploration of the various mathematical problems and their corresponding datasets that have been investigated; ii) an examination of the spectrum of LLM-oriented techniques that have been proposed for mathematical problem-solving; iii) an overview of factors and concerns affecting LLMs in solving math; and iv) an elucidation of the persisting challenges within this domain. To the best of our knowledge, this survey stands as one of the first extensive examinations of the landscape of LLMs in the realm of mathematics, providing a holistic perspective on the current state, accomplishments, and future challenges in this rapidly evolving field.

Read more

4/8/2024