Variance-based sensitivity analysis in the presence of correlated input variables

Overview

• Explains a method for conducting variance-based sensitivity analysis on models with correlated input variables
• Provides a way to account for the effects of input variable correlations, which can significantly impact the results of sensitivity analysis
• Demonstrates the approach using a case study involving a groundwater flow model

Plain English Explanation

Sensitivity analysis is a powerful tool used to understand how the inputs of a model affect its outputs. This paper presents a method for conducting sensitivity analysis on models where the input variables are correlated. In other words, the values of the input variables are not completely independent of each other.

When input variables are correlated, the traditional approaches to sensitivity analysis may not accurately capture the true impact of each input on the model's output. The researchers developed a new technique that can account for these correlations. This allows for a more realistic and informative sensitivity analysis, which can provide better insights into how the model behaves and which inputs are the most influential.

The method involves using a statistical approach called "variance decomposition" to quantify the contribution of each input variable to the overall variance in the model's output, while also considering the effects of the correlations between the inputs. The researchers demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach using a case study involving a groundwater flow model, showing how it can lead to different conclusions about the relative importance of the input variables compared to traditional sensitivity analysis techniques.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a methodology for conducting variance-based sensitivity analysis on models with correlated input variables. The key steps are:

1. Modeling the Correlations: The authors use a correlation matrix to model the relationships between the input variables. This allows them to capture the interdependencies between the inputs.

2. Variance Decomposition: They employ a variance decomposition approach to quantify the contribution of each input variable to the overall variance in the model's output. This involves partitioning the total variance into individual effects and interaction effects.

3. Sensitivity Indices: The authors define sensitivity indices, similar to the well-known Sobol' indices, that account for the input correlations. These indices provide a measure of the importance of each input variable in determining the model's output.

The methodology is demonstrated using a case study involving a groundwater flow model. The researchers show how the traditional sensitivity analysis approach can lead to different conclusions about the relative importance of the input variables compared to the proposed method that considers the input correlations.

Critical Analysis

The authors acknowledge that their approach relies on the assumption of a known correlation structure between the input variables. In practice, the true correlations may not be known with certainty, which could affect the accuracy of the sensitivity analysis results.

Additionally, the method may become computationally intensive for models with a large number of input variables, as it requires the estimation of higher-order interaction effects. The authors suggest that dimension reduction techniques could be explored to address this issue.

Further research could investigate the robustness of the method to different types of correlation structures, as well as its performance in comparison to other sensitivity analysis techniques that account for input dependencies, such as those based on Gaussian copulas or Bayesian networks.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel approach for conducting variance-based sensitivity analysis in the presence of correlated input variables. By explicitly modeling the input correlations, the method can provide a more accurate and informative assessment of the relative importance of the model inputs, which can lead to better understanding and improved decision-making. The demonstrated case study highlights the potential benefits of this technique over traditional sensitivity analysis methods, particularly for models where input dependencies play a significant role.