Variance Reduction based Experience Replay for Policy Optimization
2110.08902
0
0
➖
Abstract
For reinforcement learning on complex stochastic systems, it is desirable to effectively leverage the information from historical samples collected in previous iterations to accelerate policy optimization. Classical experience replay, while effective, treats all observations uniformly, neglecting their relative importance. To address this limitation, we introduce a novel Variance Reduction Experience Replay (VRER) framework, enabling the selective reuse of relevant samples to improve policy gradient estimation. VRER, as an adaptable method that can seamlessly integrate with different policy optimization algorithms, forms the foundation of our sample efficient off-policy learning algorithm known as Policy Gradient with VRER (PG-VRER). Furthermore, the lack of a rigorous understanding of the experience replay approach in the literature motivates us to introduce a novel theoretical framework that accounts for sample dependencies induced by Markovian noise and behavior policy interdependencies. This framework is then employed to analyze the finite-time convergence of the proposed PG-VRER algorithm, revealing a crucial bias-variance trade-off in policy gradient estimation: the reuse of older experience tends to introduce a larger bias while simultaneously reducing gradient estimation variance. Extensive experiments have shown that VRER offers a notable and consistent acceleration in learning optimal policies and enhances the performance of state-of-the-art (SOTA) policy optimization approaches.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a novel Variance Reduction Experience Replay (VRER) framework to improve policy gradient estimation and accelerate policy optimization in reinforcement learning on complex stochastic systems.
- The paper also provides a theoretical analysis of the experience replay approach, accounting for sample dependencies induced by Markovian noise and behavior policy interdependencies.
- Experiments show that VRER offers a notable and consistent acceleration in learning optimal policies and enhances the performance of state-of-the-art policy optimization approaches.
Plain English Explanation
In reinforcement learning, an agent learns to make decisions by interacting with its environment and receiving rewards or penalties. When dealing with complex, unpredictable environments, it's important for the agent to effectively use the information it has gathered from past interactions to improve its decision-making.
[https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/higher-replay-ratio-empowers-sample-efficient-multi] Classical experience replay, where the agent stores past observations and randomly samples from them, is a useful technique. However, it treats all observations equally, even though some may be more important than others in helping the agent learn.
The authors introduce a new approach called Variance Reduction Experience Replay (VRER), which selectively reuses the most relevant past observations to improve the agent's policy optimization. This allows the agent to learn more efficiently, as it focuses on the experiences that are most valuable for improving its decision-making.
[https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/reduction-variance-overestimation-deep-q-learning] The paper also provides a theoretical analysis of the experience replay approach, accounting for the dependencies between observations due to the Markovian nature of the environment and the agent's own decision-making process. This analysis helps explain the tradeoffs between bias (how much the agent's estimates deviate from the true values) and variance (how much the agent's estimates vary) in the policy gradient estimation.
[https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/variance-reduced-policy-gradient-approaches-infinite-horizon] Experiments show that VRER can significantly accelerate the learning of optimal policies and improve the performance of state-of-the-art reinforcement learning algorithms. This is important because it allows agents to learn more quickly and effectively in complex, real-world environments.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel Variance Reduction Experience Replay (VRER) framework to improve policy gradient estimation and accelerate policy optimization in reinforcement learning. VRER selectively reuses relevant samples from the agent's past experiences to reduce the variance in policy gradient estimation, while maintaining a low bias.
[https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/variational-dynamic-self-supervised-exploration-deep-reinforcement] The key idea behind VRER is to assign higher importance weights to samples that are more informative for the current policy optimization. This is achieved by estimating the variance reduction potential of each sample and prioritizing the reuse of samples with higher variance reduction potential.
The authors also provide a theoretical analysis of the experience replay approach, accounting for sample dependencies induced by Markovian noise and behavior policy interdependencies. This analysis reveals a crucial bias-variance trade-off in policy gradient estimation: the reuse of older experience tends to introduce a larger bias while simultaneously reducing gradient estimation variance.
[https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/model-predictive-control-based-value-estimation-efficient] The proposed Policy Gradient with VRER (PG-VRER) algorithm integrates the VRER framework with state-of-the-art policy optimization methods, demonstrating a notable and consistent acceleration in learning optimal policies across a variety of benchmark tasks.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a rigorous theoretical analysis of the experience replay approach, which is a valuable contribution to the literature. The authors' analysis of the bias-variance trade-off in policy gradient estimation with experience replay is an important insight that can help researchers and practitioners design more effective reinforcement learning algorithms.
However, the paper does not address the potential computational overhead associated with the VRER framework, which may limit its practical applicability in real-world scenarios with limited computing resources. Additionally, the paper does not explore the performance of VRER in environments with sparse rewards or complex, high-dimensional state spaces, which are common challenges in real-world reinforcement learning problems.
[https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/higher-replay-ratio-empowers-sample-efficient-multi] Further research could investigate ways to reduce the computational cost of VRER, as well as its performance in more challenging reinforcement learning domains. Exploring the interplay between VRER and other sample-efficient techniques, such as meta-learning or hierarchical reinforcement learning, could also be a promising direction for future work.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel Variance Reduction Experience Replay (VRER) framework that selectively reuses relevant past observations to improve policy gradient estimation and accelerate policy optimization in complex reinforcement learning tasks. The theoretical analysis provided in the paper offers valuable insights into the bias-variance trade-off in experience replay-based policy optimization.
[https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/reduction-variance-overestimation-deep-q-learning] The empirical results demonstrate that VRER can consistently enhance the performance of state-of-the-art reinforcement learning algorithms, which is a significant contribution to the field. As reinforcement learning continues to be applied in increasingly complex and real-world domains, techniques like VRER that improve sample efficiency and learning speed will become increasingly important.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🤿
CUER: Corrected Uniform Experience Replay for Off-Policy Continuous Deep Reinforcement Learning Algorithms
Arda Sarp Yenicesu, Furkan B. Mutlu, Suleyman S. Kozat, Ozgur S. Oguz
0
0
The utilization of the experience replay mechanism enables agents to effectively leverage their experiences on several occasions. In previous studies, the sampling probability of the transitions was modified based on their relative significance. The process of reassigning sample probabilities for every transition in the replay buffer after each iteration is considered extremely inefficient. Hence, in order to enhance computing efficiency, experience replay prioritization algorithms reassess the importance of a transition as it is sampled. However, the relative importance of the transitions undergoes dynamic adjustments when the agent's policy and value function are iteratively updated. Furthermore, experience replay is a mechanism that retains the transitions generated by the agent's past policies, which could potentially diverge significantly from the agent's most recent policy. An increased deviation from the agent's most recent policy results in a greater frequency of off-policy updates, which has a negative impact on the agent's performance. In this paper, we develop a novel algorithm, Corrected Uniform Experience Replay (CUER), which stochastically samples the stored experience while considering the fairness among all other experiences without ignoring the dynamic nature of the transition importance by making sampled state distribution more on-policy. CUER provides promising improvements for off-policy continuous control algorithms in terms of sample efficiency, final performance, and stability of the policy during the training.
6/14/2024
vMFER: Von Mises-Fisher Experience Resampling Based on Uncertainty of Gradient Directions for Policy Improvement
Yiwen Zhu, Jinyi Liu, Wenya Wei, Qianyi Fu, Yujing Hu, Zhou Fang, Bo An, Jianye Hao, Tangjie Lv, Changjie Fan
0
0
Reinforcement Learning (RL) is a widely employed technique in decision-making problems, encompassing two fundamental operations -- policy evaluation and policy improvement. Enhancing learning efficiency remains a key challenge in RL, with many efforts focused on using ensemble critics to boost policy evaluation efficiency. However, when using multiple critics, the actor in the policy improvement process can obtain different gradients. Previous studies have combined these gradients without considering their disagreements. Therefore, optimizing the policy improvement process is crucial to enhance learning efficiency. This study focuses on investigating the impact of gradient disagreements caused by ensemble critics on policy improvement. We introduce the concept of uncertainty of gradient directions as a means to measure the disagreement among gradients utilized in the policy improvement process. Through measuring the disagreement among gradients, we find that transitions with lower uncertainty of gradient directions are more reliable in the policy improvement process. Building on this analysis, we propose a method called von Mises-Fisher Experience Resampling (vMFER), which optimizes the policy improvement process by resampling transitions and assigning higher confidence to transitions with lower uncertainty of gradient directions. Our experiments demonstrate that vMFER significantly outperforms the benchmark and is particularly well-suited for ensemble structures in RL.
5/15/2024
New!A Simple Mixture Policy Parameterization for Improving Sample Efficiency of CVaR Optimization
Yudong Luo, Yangchen Pan, Han Wang, Philip Torr, Pascal Poupart
0
0
Reinforcement learning algorithms utilizing policy gradients (PG) to optimize Conditional Value at Risk (CVaR) face significant challenges with sample inefficiency, hindering their practical applications. This inefficiency stems from two main facts: a focus on tail-end performance that overlooks many sampled trajectories, and the potential of gradient vanishing when the lower tail of the return distribution is overly flat. To address these challenges, we propose a simple mixture policy parameterization. This method integrates a risk-neutral policy with an adjustable policy to form a risk-averse policy. By employing this strategy, all collected trajectories can be utilized for policy updating, and the issue of vanishing gradients is counteracted by stimulating higher returns through the risk-neutral component, thus lifting the tail and preventing flatness. Our empirical study reveals that this mixture parameterization is uniquely effective across a variety of benchmark domains. Specifically, it excels in identifying risk-averse CVaR policies in some Mujoco environments where the traditional CVaR-PG fails to learn a reasonable policy.
7/1/2024
🤯
CIER: A Novel Experience Replay Approach with Causal Inference in Deep Reinforcement Learning
Jingwen Wang, Dehui Du, Yida Li, Yiyang Li, Yikang Chen
0
0
In the training process of Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL), agents require repetitive interactions with the environment. With an increase in training volume and model complexity, it is still a challenging problem to enhance data utilization and explainability of DRL training. This paper addresses these challenges by focusing on the temporal correlations within the time dimension of time series. We propose a novel approach to segment multivariate time series into meaningful subsequences and represent the time series based on these subsequences. Furthermore, the subsequences are employed for causal inference to identify fundamental causal factors that significantly impact training outcomes. We design a module to provide feedback on the causality during DRL training. Several experiments demonstrate the feasibility of our approach in common environments, confirming its ability to enhance the effectiveness of DRL training and impart a certain level of explainability to the training process. Additionally, we extended our approach with priority experience replay algorithm, and experimental results demonstrate the continued effectiveness of our approach.
5/15/2024