Virtual academic conferencing: a scoping review of 1984-2021 literature. Novel modalities vs. long standing challenges in scholarly communication

Overview

• This study examines the growing body of research on virtual academic conferences, which have become more prevalent due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
• The researchers conducted a scoping review, analyzing 147 documents published up to October 2021.
• They categorized the literature, identified key themes, examined theoretical approaches, evaluated empirical findings, and synthesized the advantages and disadvantages of virtual academic conferences.

Plain English Explanation

The paper looks at the research on virtual academic conferences, which have become more common due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The researchers reviewed 147 documents published up to October 2021 to understand this topic better. They categorized the literature, found the main themes, looked at the theories used, evaluated the research findings, and summarized the pros and cons of virtual academic conferences.

The key finding is that the existing research on virtual academic conferences is mainly descriptive and lacks a strong theoretical framework for studying this phenomenon. Despite the rapid growth of literature on virtual conferencing during the pandemic, the understanding of this topic is still limited. The researchers provide recommendations for future research, such as examining the impact of virtual conferences on research productivity, quality, and collaboration, as well as their relationship to social, economic, and geopolitical inequalities in science, and their environmental aspects. They emphasize the need for developing a theoretical framework to guide future empirical studies on virtual academic conferences.

Technical Explanation

The researchers conducted a scoping review of the literature on virtual academic conferences, analyzing 147 documents available up to October 5th, 2021. They categorized the literature, identified main themes, examined theoretical approaches, evaluated empirical findings, and synthesized the advantages and disadvantages of virtual academic conferences.

The study found that the existing literature on virtual academic conferences is mainly descriptive and lacks a solid theoretical framework for studying the phenomenon. Despite the rapid growth of the literature documenting and discussing virtual conferencing induced by the pandemic, the understanding of the phenomenon is limited.

The researchers provide several recommendations for future research on academic virtual conferences, including:

• Examining the impact of virtual conferences on research productivity, quality, and collaboration
• Investigating the relations to social, economic, and geopolitical inequalities in science
• Analyzing the environmental aspects of virtual conferences

The paper stresses the need for further research that encompasses the development of a theoretical framework to guide empirical studies on virtual academic conferences.

Critical Analysis

The paper highlights the need for a more robust theoretical foundation to study the phenomenon of virtual academic conferences. While the existing literature provides a descriptive overview, the authors argue that a lack of clear theoretical frameworks limits our understanding of the long-term implications of this shift to virtual conferencing.

The recommendations for future research, such as exploring the impact on research productivity, collaboration, and inequalities, are valuable. However, the paper does not delve into potential methodological challenges in conducting such studies, which may be an area for further consideration.

Additionally, the paper could have benefited from a deeper discussion of the practical and logistical barriers to virtual conferences, as well as the unique opportunities they may present, particularly in terms of expanding accessibility and improving access to resources for researchers in different regions.

The researchers also do not address potential vulnerabilities or privacy concerns associated with virtual conferences, which could be an important area for future research.

Conclusion

This study provides a comprehensive review of the existing literature on virtual academic conferences, highlighting the need for a stronger theoretical foundation to guide future research. The recommendations for exploring the impact on research productivity, collaboration, inequalities, and environmental aspects are relevant and timely, as the academic community continues to grapple with the long-term implications of the shift to remote and hybrid conferencing models.

By addressing these gaps and developing a deeper understanding of topics, authors, and institutions involved in virtual conferencing research, the academic community can better harness the potential of eery spaces to facilitate meaningful and inclusive academic exchange.