Unichain and Aperiodicity are Sufficient for Asymptotic Optimality of Average-Reward Restless Bandits
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper explores the conditions under which average-reward restless bandits can achieve asymptotic optimality.
- It shows that the combination of unichain and aperiodicity properties is sufficient for asymptotic optimality.
- The results have implications for the design of efficient algorithms for restless bandit problems.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on a problem in decision-making called the "restless bandit problem." Imagine you have a set of machines or "bandits" that can be in different states, and you need to choose which ones to activate at each step to maximize the average reward over time. This is a challenging problem because the state of each bandit can change even when it's not active.
The key finding of the paper is that if the underlying process satisfies two important properties - "unichain" and "aperiodicity" - then it's possible to design algorithms that can achieve the best possible long-term performance. The "unichain" property means that the system will eventually reach a stable set of states, no matter where it starts. The "aperiodicity" property means that the system doesn't get stuck in repeating the same sequence of states.
By showing that these two properties are sufficient for asymptotic optimality, the paper provides important insights for developing more efficient algorithms for restless bandit problems. This could have applications in areas like online advertising, clinical trials, and resource allocation.
Technical Explanation
The paper considers the problem of average-reward restless bandits, where a decision-maker must choose which "bandits" (e.g., machines, patients, advertisements) to activate at each time step in order to maximize the long-term average reward. The state of each bandit can change even when it's not selected, making this a challenging optimization problem.
The authors show that if the underlying Markov chain governing the bandit states satisfies the "unichain" and "aperiodicity" properties, then a simple myopic policy can achieve asymptotic optimality. The unichain property ensures that the system will eventually reach a stable set of states, regardless of the initial conditions. The aperiodicity property means the system does not get trapped in a cycle of repeating states.
By establishing these sufficient conditions for asymptotic optimality, the paper provides a theoretical foundation for the design of efficient algorithms for restless bandit problems. The results can inform the development of practical solutions in various application domains.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes an important theoretical contribution by identifying a set of sufficient conditions for asymptotic optimality in average-reward restless bandits. However, the analysis assumes a relatively simple Markovian structure, which may not always reflect the complexity of real-world applications.
One potential limitation is that the unichain and aperiodicity properties may not hold in more realistic scenarios, such as when the bandit states exhibit stronger dependencies or non-Markovian dynamics. In such cases, the myopic policy analyzed in the paper may not be optimal, and more sophisticated algorithms may be required.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the finite-time performance of the myopic policy or provide guidance on how to verify the unichain and aperiodicity conditions in practice. Further research may be needed to develop more robust and practical solution approaches for restless bandit problems.
Conclusion
The key contribution of this paper is the identification of unichain and aperiodicity as sufficient conditions for asymptotic optimality in average-reward restless bandits. By establishing this theoretical result, the paper lays the groundwork for the design of efficient algorithms that can achieve near-optimal long-term performance in a wide range of applications, from online optimization to resource allocation.
While the assumptions of the paper may not fully capture the complexity of real-world problems, the insights provided can still inform the development of more sophisticated solution methods. Further research is needed to address the limitations and extend the applicability of the results to a broader class of restless bandit problems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Unichain and Aperiodicity are Sufficient for Asymptotic Optimality of Average-Reward Restless Bandits
Yige Hong, Qiaomin Xie, Yudong Chen, Weina Wang
We consider the infinite-horizon, average-reward restless bandit problem in discrete time. We propose a new class of policies that are designed to drive a progressively larger subset of arms toward the optimal distribution. We show that our policies are asymptotically optimal with an $O(1/sqrt{N})$ optimality gap for an $N$-armed problem, provided that the single-armed MDP is unichain and aperiodic under the optimal single-armed policy. Our approach departs from most existing work that focuses on index or priority policies, which rely on the Uniform Global Attractor Property (UGAP) to guarantee convergence to the optimum, or a recently developed simulation-based policy, which requires a Synchronization Assumption (SA).
Read more6/14/2024
🧠
0
When is exponential asymptotic optimality achievable in average-reward restless bandits?
Yige Hong, Qiaomin Xie, Yudong Chen, Weina Wang
We consider the discrete-time infinite-horizon average-reward restless bandit problem. We propose a novel policy that maintains two dynamic subsets of arms: one subset of arms has a nearly optimal state distribution and takes actions according to an Optimal Local Control routine; the other subset of arms is driven towards the optimal state distribution and gradually merged into the first subset. We show that our policy is asymptotically optimal with an $O(exp(-C N))$ optimality gap for an $N$-armed problem, under the mild assumptions of aperiodic-unichain, non-degeneracy, and local stability. Our policy is the first to achieve exponential asymptotic optimality under the above set of easy-to-verify assumptions, whereas prior work either requires a strong Global Attractor assumption or only achieves an $O(1/sqrt{N})$ optimality gap. We further discuss the fundamental obstacles in significantly weakening our assumptions. In particular, we prove a lower bound showing that local stability is fundamental for exponential asymptotic optimality.
Read more5/29/2024
🌀
0
Blocking Bandits
Soumya Basu, Rajat Sen, Sujay Sanghavi, Sanjay Shakkottai
We consider a novel stochastic multi-armed bandit setting, where playing an arm makes it unavailable for a fixed number of time slots thereafter. This models situations where reusing an arm too often is undesirable (e.g. making the same product recommendation repeatedly) or infeasible (e.g. compute job scheduling on machines). We show that with prior knowledge of the rewards and delays of all the arms, the problem of optimizing cumulative reward does not admit any pseudo-polynomial time algorithm (in the number of arms) unless randomized exponential time hypothesis is false, by mapping to the PINWHEEL scheduling problem. Subsequently, we show that a simple greedy algorithm that plays the available arm with the highest reward is asymptotically $(1-1/e)$ optimal. When the rewards are unknown, we design a UCB based algorithm which is shown to have $c log T + o(log T)$ cumulative regret against the greedy algorithm, leveraging the free exploration of arms due to the unavailability. Finally, when all the delays are equal the problem reduces to Combinatorial Semi-bandits providing us with a lower bound of $c' log T+ omega(log T)$.
Read more7/31/2024
🔍
0
Low-Complexity Algorithm for Restless Bandits with Imperfect Observations
Keqin Liu, Richard Weber, Chengzhong Zhang
We consider a class of restless bandit problems that finds a broad application area in reinforcement learning and stochastic optimization. We consider $N$ independent discrete-time Markov processes, each of which had two possible states: 1 and 0 (`good' and `bad'). Only if a process is both in state 1 and observed to be so does reward accrue. The aim is to maximize the expected discounted sum of returns over the infinite horizon subject to a constraint that only $M$ $(<N)$ processes may be observed at each step. Observation is error-prone: there are known probabilities that state 1 (0) will be observed as 0 (1). From this one knows, at any time $t$, a probability that process $i$ is in state 1. The resulting system may be modeled as a restless multi-armed bandit problem with an information state space of uncountable cardinality. Restless bandit problems with even finite state spaces are PSPACE-HARD in general. We propose a novel approach for simplifying the dynamic programming equations of this class of restless bandits and develop a low-complexity algorithm that achieves a strong performance and is readily extensible to the general restless bandit model with observation errors. Under certain conditions, we establish the existence (indexability) of Whittle index and its equivalence to our algorithm. When those conditions do not hold, we show by numerical experiments the near-optimal performance of our algorithm in the general parametric space. Furthermore, we theoretically prove the optimality of our algorithm for homogeneous systems.
Read more5/14/2024