Which objects help me to act effectively? Reasoning about physically-grounded affordances
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores how reasoning about physically-grounded affordances can help agents act effectively in the world.
- Affordances are the action possibilities that objects offer an agent based on their physical properties and the agent's capabilities.
- The authors propose a framework for reasoning about affordances using visual and language understanding.
Plain English Explanation
The paper is about how agents, like robots or virtual assistants, can understand and reason about the "affordances" of objects in their environment. Affordances are the action possibilities that an object offers to an agent based on the object's physical properties and the agent's own capabilities. For example, a chair "affords" the action of sitting for a human, but not for a fish.
The key idea is that by reasoning about these affordances, an agent can more effectively plan and execute actions to achieve its goals. Rather than just recognizing an object, the agent also considers how it can use that object. The paper proposes a framework that combines visual perception and language understanding to enable this kind of physically-grounded reasoning about affordances.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a framework for
The framework uses both visual perception and language understanding to extract information about affordances. The visual component learns to recognize the physical features of objects that enable different actions, while the language component maps linguistic descriptions of objects and actions to those affordances.
To evaluate their approach, the authors conduct experiments on affordance prediction tasks, where the agent must predict what actions an object affords based on visual and textual inputs. The results show that their framework outperforms previous methods that relied solely on visual or language information.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for the importance of affordance reasoning in enabling agents to interact with the physical world effectively. By considering not just what objects are, but what they can be used for, the framework allows agents to plan more intelligent and purposeful actions.
However, the paper does not address some potential limitations and challenges of this approach. For example, it does not discuss how the framework would handle novel objects or situations that the agent has not encountered before. Additionally, the emphasis is on static affordances, but in the real world, affordances can change dynamically based on the context and the agent's own state.
Further research could explore how to make the framework more flexible and adaptive, perhaps by incorporating reinforcement learning or other techniques to allow the agent to continually update its understanding of affordances through interaction and experience.
Conclusion
This paper presents an innovative framework for enabling agents to reason about physically-grounded affordances, which can significantly improve their ability to interact with and manipulate the world around them. By combining visual and language understanding, the approach allows agents to go beyond simple object recognition and consider the action possibilities that objects offer.
While the paper has some limitations, it represents an important step forward in the field of embodied AI and highlights the potential benefits of grounding an agent's understanding of the world in the physical realities of its environment and capabilities. As the field of robotics and virtual agents continues to advance, these types of affordance-based reasoning techniques will likely become increasingly important for enabling agents to act effectively and intelligently in the real world.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Which objects help me to act effectively? Reasoning about physically-grounded affordances
Anne Kemmeren, Gertjan Burghouts, Michael van Bekkum, Wouter Meijer, Jelle van Mil
For effective interactions with the open world, robots should understand how interactions with known and novel objects help them towards their goal. A key aspect of this understanding lies in detecting an object's affordances, which represent the potential effects that can be achieved by manipulating the object in various ways. Our approach leverages a dialogue of large language models (LLMs) and vision-language models (VLMs) to achieve open-world affordance detection. Given open-vocabulary descriptions of intended actions and effects, the useful objects in the environment are found. By grounding our system in the physical world, we account for the robot's embodiment and the intrinsic properties of the objects it encounters. In our experiments, we have shown that our method produces tailored outputs based on different embodiments or intended effects. The method was able to select a useful object from a set of distractors. Finetuning the VLM for physical properties improved overall performance. These results underline the importance of grounding the affordance search in the physical world, by taking into account robot embodiment and the physical properties of objects.
Read more7/22/2024
0
Affordance Perception by a Knowledge-Guided Vision-Language Model with Efficient Error Correction
Gertjan Burghouts, Marianne Schaaphok, Michael van Bekkum, Wouter Meijer, Fieke Hillerstrom, Jelle van Mil
Mobile robot platforms will increasingly be tasked with activities that involve grasping and manipulating objects in open world environments. Affordance understanding provides a robot with means to realise its goals and execute its tasks, e.g. to achieve autonomous navigation in unknown buildings where it has to find doors and ways to open these. In order to get actionable suggestions, robots need to be able to distinguish subtle differences between objects, as they may result in different action sequences: doorknobs require grasp and twist, while handlebars require grasp and push. In this paper, we improve affordance perception for a robot in an open-world setting. Our contribution is threefold: (1) We provide an affordance representation with precise, actionable affordances; (2) We connect this knowledge base to a foundational vision-language models (VLM) and prompt the VLM for a wider variety of new and unseen objects; (3) We apply a human-in-the-loop for corrections on the output of the VLM. The mix of affordance representation, image detection and a human-in-the-loop is effective for a robot to search for objects to achieve its goals. We have demonstrated this in a scenario of finding various doors and the many different ways to open them.
Read more7/19/2024
0
AffordanceLLM: Grounding Affordance from Vision Language Models
Shengyi Qian, Weifeng Chen, Min Bai, Xiong Zhou, Zhuowen Tu, Li Erran Li
Affordance grounding refers to the task of finding the area of an object with which one can interact. It is a fundamental but challenging task, as a successful solution requires the comprehensive understanding of a scene in multiple aspects including detection, localization, and recognition of objects with their parts, of geo-spatial configuration/layout of the scene, of 3D shapes and physics, as well as of the functionality and potential interaction of the objects and humans. Much of the knowledge is hidden and beyond the image content with the supervised labels from a limited training set. In this paper, we make an attempt to improve the generalization capability of the current affordance grounding by taking the advantage of the rich world, abstract, and human-object-interaction knowledge from pretrained large-scale vision language models. Under the AGD20K benchmark, our proposed model demonstrates a significant performance gain over the competing methods for in-the-wild object affordance grounding. We further demonstrate it can ground affordance for objects from random Internet images, even if both objects and actions are unseen during training. Project site: https://jasonqsy.github.io/AffordanceLLM/
Read more4/19/2024
0
RAIL: Robot Affordance Imagination with Large Language Models
Ceng Zhang, Xin Meng, Dongchen Qi, Gregory S. Chirikjian
This paper introduces an automatic affordance reasoning paradigm tailored to minimal semantic inputs, addressing the critical challenges of classifying and manipulating unseen classes of objects in household settings. Inspired by human cognitive processes, our method integrates generative language models and physics-based simulators to foster analytical thinking and creative imagination of novel affordances. Structured with a tripartite framework consisting of analysis, imagination, and evaluation, our system analyzes the requested affordance names into interaction-based definitions, imagines the virtual scenarios, and evaluates the object affordance. If an object is recognized as possessing the requested affordance, our method also predicts the optimal pose for such functionality, and how a potential user can interact with it. Tuned on only a few synthetic examples across 3 affordance classes, our pipeline achieves a very high success rate on affordance classification and functional pose prediction of 8 classes of novel objects, outperforming learning-based baselines. Validation through real robot manipulating experiments demonstrates the practical applicability of the imagined user interaction, showcasing the system's ability to independently conceptualize unseen affordances and interact with new objects and scenarios in everyday settings.
Read more6/10/2024