Whittle Index Learning Algorithms for Restless Bandits with Constant Stepsizes
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper explores Whittle index learning algorithms for restless bandits with constant stepsizes.
- Restless bandits are a class of multi-armed bandit problems where the rewards of the arms can change over time.
- Whittle index policies are a popular approach for making decisions in restless bandit problems.
- The paper proposes two new Whittle index learning algorithms that can learn the Whittle indices using constant stepsizes, which improves upon prior approaches.
Plain English Explanation
Imagine you're running a business with multiple products, each of which can fluctuate in profitability over time. This is like a restless bandit problem, where you have to decide which products to focus on at any given time to maximize your overall profits.
One way to approach this is using a Whittle index policy, which assigns a numeric score (the Whittle index) to each product based on its current state and potential for future profit. You can then focus on the products with the highest Whittle indices.
The challenge is that the true Whittle indices are often unknown, so you have to learn them over time. The paper proposes two new learning algorithms that can efficiently learn the Whittle indices using constant stepsizes, rather than the diminishing stepsizes used in prior approaches. This makes the learning process simpler and more practical.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents two Whittle index learning algorithms for restless bandits with constant stepsizes:
-
Whittle Index Learning with Constant Stepsize (WILC): This algorithm maintains an estimate of the Whittle indices and updates them using a constant stepsize rule. The updates are based on the observed rewards and the current index estimates.
-
Whittle Index Learning with Constant Stepsize and Exploration (WILCE): This algorithm builds on WILC by adding an exploration component, where the algorithm occasionally explores alternative actions to better estimate the Whittle indices.
The authors analyze the theoretical properties of these algorithms, showing that they converge to the true Whittle indices under certain conditions. They also conduct numerical experiments to demonstrate the performance of the proposed algorithms compared to prior approaches.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes valuable contributions to the field of restless bandit problems by proposing new Whittle index learning algorithms that use constant stepsizes. This is an important advancement, as prior algorithms relied on diminishing stepsizes, which can be less practical to implement.
One potential limitation of the research is that the theoretical analysis and numerical experiments are based on specific problem formulations and assumptions. It would be helpful to see the algorithms evaluated on a wider range of restless bandit scenarios to better understand their generalizability.
Additionally, the paper does not extensively discuss potential real-world applications or the implications of the proposed algorithms. Exploring how these algorithms could be applied in areas like resource allocation, online advertising, or healthcare would help contextualize the significance of the research.
Conclusion
This paper introduces two new Whittle index learning algorithms for restless bandits that use constant stepsizes, which improves upon prior approaches that relied on diminishing stepsizes. The proposed algorithms are shown to converge to the true Whittle indices under certain conditions and demonstrate promising performance in numerical experiments.
The research advances the state of the art in restless bandit problems and has the potential to enable more practical and scalable decision-making in a variety of real-world applications. Further exploration of the algorithms' performance across diverse problem domains and their real-world implications would be valuable next steps.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Whittle Index Learning Algorithms for Restless Bandits with Constant Stepsizes
Vishesh Mittal, Rahul Meshram, Surya Prakash
We study the Whittle index learning algorithm for restless multi-armed bandits. We consider index learning algorithm with Q-learning. We first present Q-learning algorithm with exploration policies -- epsilon-greedy, softmax, epsilon-softmax with constant stepsizes. We extend the study of Q-learning to index learning for single-armed restless bandit. The algorithm of index learning is two-timescale variant of stochastic approximation, on slower timescale we update index learning scheme and on faster timescale we update Q-learning assuming fixed index value. In Q-learning updates are in asynchronous manner. We study constant stepsizes two timescale stochastic approximation algorithm. We provide analysis of two-timescale stochastic approximation for index learning with constant stepsizes. Further, we present study on index learning with deep Q-network (DQN) learning and linear function approximation with state-aggregation method. We describe the performance of our algorithms using numerical examples. We have shown that index learning with Q learning, DQN and function approximations learns the Whittle index.
Read more9/10/2024
0
Faster Q-Learning Algorithms for Restless Bandits
Parvish Kakarapalli, Devendra Kayande, Rahul Meshram
We study the Whittle index learning algorithm for restless multi-armed bandits (RMAB). We first present Q-learning algorithm and its variants -- speedy Q-learning (SQL), generalized speedy Q-learning (GSQL) and phase Q-learning (PhaseQL). We also discuss exploration policies -- $epsilon$-greedy and Upper confidence bound (UCB). We extend the study of Q-learning and its variants with UCB policy. We illustrate using numerical example that Q-learning with UCB exploration policy has faster convergence and PhaseQL with UCB have fastest convergence rate. We next extend the study of Q-learning variants for index learning to RMAB. The algorithm of index learning is two-timescale variant of stochastic approximation, on slower timescale we update index learning scheme and on faster timescale we update Q-learning assuming fixed index value. We study constant stepsizes two timescale stochastic approximation algorithm. We describe the performance of our algorithms using numerical example. It illustrate that index learning with Q learning with UCB has faster convergence that $epsilon$ greedy. Further, PhaseQL (with UCB and $epsilon$ greedy) has the best convergence than other Q-learning algorithms.
Read more9/11/2024
🤿
0
Tabular and Deep Learning for the Whittle Index
Francisco Robledo Rela~no (LMAP, UPPA, UPV / EHU), Vivek Borkar (EE-IIT), Urtzi Ayesta (IRIT-RMESS, UPV/EHU, CNRS), Konstantin Avrachenkov (Inria)
The Whittle index policy is a heuristic that has shown remarkably good performance (with guaranteed asymptotic optimality) when applied to the class of problems known as Restless Multi-Armed Bandit Problems (RMABPs). In this paper we present QWI and QWINN, two reinforcement learning algorithms, respectively tabular and deep, to learn the Whittle index for the total discounted criterion. The key feature is the use of two time-scales, a faster one to update the state-action Q -values, and a relatively slower one to update the Whittle indices. In our main theoretical result we show that QWI, which is a tabular implementation, converges to the real Whittle indices. We then present QWINN, an adaptation of QWI algorithm using neural networks to compute the Q -values on the faster time-scale, which is able to extrapolate information from one state to another and scales naturally to large state-space environments. For QWINN, we show that all local minima of the Bellman error are locally stable equilibria, which is the first result of its kind for DQN-based schemes. Numerical computations show that QWI and QWINN converge faster than the standard Q -learning algorithm, neural-network based approximate Q-learning and other state of the art algorithms.
Read more6/5/2024
0
PCL-Indexability and Whittle Index for Restless Bandits with General Observation Models
Keqin Liu, Chengzhong Zhang
In this paper, we consider a general observation model for restless multi-armed bandit problems. The operation of the player needs to be based on certain feedback mechanism that is error-prone due to resource constraints or environmental or intrinsic noises. By establishing a general probabilistic model for dynamics of feedback/observation, we formulate the problem as a restless bandit with a countable belief state space starting from an arbitrary initial belief (a priori information). We apply the achievable region method with partial conservation law (PCL) to the infinite-state problem and analyze its indexability and priority index (Whittle index). Finally, we propose an approximation process to transform the problem into which the AG algorithm of Ni~no-Mora and Bertsimas for finite-state problems can be applied to. Numerical experiments show that our algorithm has an excellent performance.
Read more7/4/2024