Achieving Near-Optimal Convergence for Distributed Minimax Optimization with Adaptive Stepsizes
2406.02939
0
0
🛠️
Abstract
In this paper, we show that applying adaptive methods directly to distributed minimax problems can result in non-convergence due to inconsistency in locally computed adaptive stepsizes. To address this challenge, we propose D-AdaST, a Distributed Adaptive minimax method with Stepsize Tracking. The key strategy is to employ an adaptive stepsize tracking protocol involving the transmission of two extra (scalar) variables. This protocol ensures the consistency among stepsizes of nodes, eliminating the steady-state error due to the lack of coordination of stepsizes among nodes that commonly exists in vanilla distributed adaptive methods, and thus guarantees exact convergence. For nonconvex-strongly-concave distributed minimax problems, we characterize the specific transient times that ensure time-scale separation of stepsizes and quasi-independence of networks, leading to a near-optimal convergence rate of $tilde{mathcal{O}} left( epsilon ^{-left( 4+delta right)} right)$ for any small $delta > 0$, matching that of the centralized counterpart. To our best knowledge, D-AdaST is the first distributed adaptive method achieving near-optimal convergence without knowing any problem-dependent parameters for nonconvex minimax problems. Extensive experiments are conducted to validate our theoretical results.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper addresses the challenge of non-convergence in applying adaptive methods directly to distributed minimax problems.
- To address this, the authors propose a new method called D-AdaST (Distributed Adaptive minimax with Stepsize Tracking).
- D-AdaST employs an adaptive stepsize tracking protocol to ensure consistency among the stepsizes of nodes, eliminating the steady-state error that can occur in vanilla distributed adaptive methods.
- For nonconvex-strongly-concave distributed minimax problems, D-AdaST achieves a near-optimal convergence rate that matches the centralized counterpart, without requiring knowledge of any problem-dependent parameters.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on a common problem in distributed optimization: when you try to directly apply adaptive methods (methods that can adjust their parameters based on the data) to distributed minimax problems (problems where you're trying to find a balance between two competing objectives), the results can sometimes fail to converge. This is due to an inconsistency in the locally computed adaptive stepsizes (the step size, or how far the algorithm moves in each iteration, can vary across different nodes in the distributed system).
To solve this, the researchers propose a new method called D-AdaST. The key idea is to use an "adaptive stepsize tracking protocol" - this means they have the different nodes in the distributed system communicate a few extra pieces of information to each other, which allows them to keep their stepsizes aligned and consistent. This eliminates the steady-state error that can occur when the nodes don't coordinate their stepsizes properly.
Importantly, for a challenging class of problems called "nonconvex-strongly-concave distributed minimax problems", the researchers show that D-AdaST can achieve a near-optimal convergence rate - that is, it can find a good solution very quickly. And it can do this without requiring the algorithm to know any problem-specific details ahead of time, which is a significant advantage.
Technical Explanation
The core innovation in the paper is the D-AdaST algorithm, which stands for "Distributed Adaptive minimax with Stepsize Tracking". To address the non-convergence issue that can arise when applying adaptive methods directly to distributed minimax problems, the key strategy in D-AdaST is to employ an adaptive stepsize tracking protocol.
This protocol involves the transmission of two extra (scalar) variables between nodes in the distributed system. This extra communication allows the nodes to coordinate their stepsizes, eliminating the steady-state error that can occur due to a lack of coordination in vanilla distributed adaptive methods.
The researchers provide a detailed convergence analysis for nonconvex-strongly-concave distributed minimax problems. They characterize the specific "transient times" (the number of iterations required for the algorithm to reach a stable state) that ensure a time-scale separation of stepsizes and quasi-independence of networks. This leads to a near-optimal convergence rate of $\tilde{\mathcal{O}}\left(\epsilon^{-(4+\delta)}\right)$ for any small $\delta > 0$, matching the rate of the centralized counterpart.
Importantly, D-AdaST achieves this near-optimal convergence without requiring any problem-dependent parameters to be known ahead of time, which is a significant advantage over previous methods like AdaGossip and distributed minimax optimization under second-order information.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a solid theoretical analysis and experimental validation of the D-AdaST algorithm. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
-
The analysis is focused on nonconvex-strongly-concave distributed minimax problems, which is a specific and relatively narrow class of problems. It would be valuable to see how D-AdaST performs on a broader range of distributed minimax problems, including those that are not strongly concave.
-
The extra communication required for the stepsize tracking protocol may introduce additional overhead, especially in large-scale distributed systems. The trade-offs between this overhead and the convergence benefits should be further explored.
-
The paper does not address the potential impact of network topology or failures on the performance of D-AdaST. Investigating the algorithm's robustness to these factors could be an interesting area for future research.
-
While the near-optimal convergence rate is a significant achievement, the practical implications and real-world applicability of the algorithm could be further emphasized and discussed.
Overall, the D-AdaST algorithm represents an important contribution to the field of distributed optimization, and the paper provides a solid foundation for future research in this area.
Conclusion
In this paper, the researchers have addressed a key challenge in applying adaptive methods to distributed minimax problems: the issue of non-convergence due to inconsistent locally computed adaptive stepsizes. Their proposed D-AdaST algorithm uses an adaptive stepsize tracking protocol to ensure consistency among the stepsizes of nodes, eliminating the steady-state error that can occur in vanilla distributed adaptive methods.
For the class of nonconvex-strongly-concave distributed minimax problems, D-AdaST achieves a near-optimal convergence rate that matches the centralized counterpart, without requiring any problem-dependent parameters to be known ahead of time. This is a significant advancement, as it allows for efficient distributed optimization of complex problems without the need for extensive problem-specific tuning.
While the paper focuses on a specific class of problems, the principles and techniques behind D-AdaST could potentially be extended to a wider range of distributed optimization challenges. As the field of distributed machine learning continues to grow, methods like D-AdaST that can reliably and efficiently solve distributed minimax problems will become increasingly valuable.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛠️
Adaptive and Optimal Second-order Optimistic Methods for Minimax Optimization
Ruichen Jiang, Ali Kavis, Qiujiang Jin, Sujay Sanghavi, Aryan Mokhtari
0
0
We propose adaptive, line search-free second-order methods with optimal rate of convergence for solving convex-concave min-max problems. By means of an adaptive step size, our algorithms feature a simple update rule that requires solving only one linear system per iteration, eliminating the need for line search or backtracking mechanisms. Specifically, we base our algorithms on the optimistic method and appropriately combine it with second-order information. Moreover, distinct from common adaptive schemes, we define the step size recursively as a function of the gradient norm and the prediction error in the optimistic update. We first analyze a variant where the step size requires knowledge of the Lipschitz constant of the Hessian. Under the additional assumption of Lipschitz continuous gradients, we further design a parameter-free version by tracking the Hessian Lipschitz constant locally and ensuring the iterates remain bounded. We also evaluate the practical performance of our algorithm by comparing it to existing second-order algorithms for minimax optimization.
6/5/2024
✨
Decentralized Stochastic Gradient Descent Ascent for Finite-Sum Minimax Problems
Hongchang Gao
0
0
Minimax optimization problems have attracted significant attention in recent years due to their widespread application in numerous machine learning models. To solve the minimax problem, a wide variety of stochastic optimization methods have been proposed. However, most of them ignore the distributed setting where the training data is distributed on multiple workers. In this paper, we developed a novel decentralized stochastic gradient descent ascent method for the finite-sum minimax problem. In particular, by employing the variance-reduced gradient, our method can achieve $O(frac{sqrt{n}kappa^3}{(1-lambda)^2epsilon^2})$ sample complexity and $O(frac{kappa^3}{(1-lambda)^2epsilon^2})$ communication complexity for the nonconvex-strongly-concave minimax problem. As far as we know, our work is the first one to achieve such theoretical complexities for this kind of minimax problem. At last, we apply our method to AUC maximization, and the experimental results confirm the effectiveness of our method.
6/12/2024
🔍
An Efficient Stochastic Algorithm for Decentralized Nonconvex-Strongly-Concave Minimax Optimization
Lesi Chen, Haishan Ye, Luo Luo
0
0
This paper studies the stochastic nonconvex-strongly-concave minimax optimization over a multi-agent network. We propose an efficient algorithm, called Decentralized Recursive gradient descEnt Ascent Method (DREAM), which achieves the best-known theoretical guarantee for finding the $epsilon$-stationary points. Concretely, it requires $mathcal{O}(min (kappa^3epsilon^{-3},kappa^2 sqrt{N} epsilon^{-2} ))$ stochastic first-order oracle (SFO) calls and $tilde{mathcal{O}}(kappa^2 epsilon^{-2})$ communication rounds, where $kappa$ is the condition number and $N$ is the total number of individual functions. Our numerical experiments also validate the superiority of DREAM over previous methods.
5/15/2024
Safeguarding adaptive methods: global convergence of Barzilai-Borwein and other stepsize choices
Hongjia Ou, Andreas Themelis
0
0
Leveraging on recent advancements on adaptive methods for convex minimization problems, this paper provides a linesearch-free proximal gradient framework for globalizing the convergence of popular stepsize choices such as Barzilai-Borwein and one-dimensional Anderson acceleration. This framework can cope with problems in which the gradient of the differentiable function is merely locally Holder continuous. Our analysis not only encompasses but also refines existing results upon which it builds. The theory is corroborated by numerical evidence that showcases the synergetic interplay between fast stepsize selections and adaptive methods.
5/14/2024