Active Learning for Non-Parametric Choice Models
0
⚙️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The research paper explores the problem of actively learning a non-parametric choice model based on consumers' decisions.
- The authors present a negative result showing that such choice models may not be identifiable.
- To address this, they introduce a directed acyclic graph (DAG) representation of the choice model, which can encode all the information that can be inferred from the available data.
- The authors establish that given exact choice probabilities, one can reconstruct the DAG.
- However, estimating the DAG from noisy choice frequency data obtained during an active learning process leads to inaccuracies.
- To overcome this challenge, the authors present an inclusion-exclusion approach to manage error propagation across DAG levels, leading to more accurate DAG estimation.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers in this study are trying to understand how consumers make choices, such as what products they choose to buy. They want to create a model that can accurately predict these choices, but they've found that the traditional models may not work very well.
To address this, the researchers came up with a new way to represent the choice model using a special type of graph called a directed acyclic graph (DAG). This graph can capture all the information that can be learned from the available data on consumer choices.
The researchers found that if they have perfect information on the probabilities of consumers choosing different sets of items, they can reconstruct the DAG. However, when they try to estimate the DAG from noisy data obtained through an active learning process (where they repeatedly offer different sets of items and observe what consumers choose), the estimates become less accurate.
To fix this, the researchers developed a new technique that effectively manages the errors that can arise as the DAG is built up from the data. This allows them to more accurately estimate the underlying choice model from the noisy data collected through their active learning process.
The researchers tested their algorithm on both synthetic data and real-world data on consumer preferences, and found that it outperforms other non-active learning approaches in recovering the frequent preferences of consumers. This shows the value of their algorithm and the broader usefulness of active learning techniques for modeling consumer behavior.
Technical Explanation
The researchers present a negative result showing that non-parametric choice models based on consumers' decisions may not be identifiable. To overcome this, they introduce a directed acyclic graph (DAG) representation of the choice model, which can provably encode all the information about the choice model that can be inferred from the available data.
The authors establish that given exact choice probabilities for a collection of item sets, one can reconstruct the DAG. However, attempting to extend this methodology to estimate the DAG from noisy choice frequency data obtained during an active learning process leads to inaccuracies.
To address this challenge, the researchers present an inclusion-exclusion approach that effectively manages error propagation across DAG levels, leading to a more accurate estimate of the DAG. This technique allows their algorithm to efficiently (in polynomial time) estimate the DAG representation of an underlying non-parametric choice model when the set of frequent rankings is drawn uniformly at random.
The algorithm learns the distribution over the most popular items among frequent preference types by actively and repeatedly offering assortments of items and observing the chosen item. The researchers demonstrate that their algorithm more effectively recovers a set of frequent preferences on both synthetic and publicly available datasets on consumers' preferences, compared to corresponding non-active learning estimation algorithms.
Critical Analysis
The authors acknowledge that their approach relies on the assumption that the set of frequent rankings is drawn uniformly at random, which may not always hold in real-world scenarios. Additionally, the paper does not address the potential issue of the choice model being sensitive to the specific set of items offered during the active learning process.
While the inclusion-exclusion approach helps manage error propagation, it is not clear how well it would scale to larger and more complex choice models. The authors also do not discuss the potential impact of different types of noise or uncertainty in the choice frequency data on the performance of their algorithm.
Furthermore, the paper does not explore the practical implications of the learned choice model, such as how it could be used to inform product design, pricing, or marketing strategies. Investigating these applications and the real-world impact of the proposed approach would be a valuable area for future research.
Conclusion
This research paper presents a novel approach to actively learning a non-parametric choice model based on consumers' decisions. The authors introduce a DAG representation of the choice model that can encode all the information that can be inferred from the available data, and develop an inclusion-exclusion technique to estimate this DAG from noisy choice frequency data obtained through an active learning process.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their algorithm in recovering frequent preferences on both synthetic and real-world datasets, highlighting the value of active learning techniques for modeling consumer behavior. While the approach has some limitations, it represents an important step forward in understanding and predicting consumer choices, which has implications for a wide range of industries and applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
⚙️
0
Active Learning for Non-Parametric Choice Models
Fransisca Susan (MIT Operations Research Center), Negin Golrezaei (MIT Sloan School of Management), Ehsan Emamjomeh-Zadeh (Meta Platforms, Inc), David Kempe (University of Southern California, Los Angeles)
We study the problem of actively learning a non-parametric choice model based on consumers' decisions. We present a negative result showing that such choice models may not be identifiable. To overcome the identifiability problem, we introduce a directed acyclic graph (DAG) representation of the choice model. This representation provably encodes all the information about the choice model which can be inferred from the available data, in the sense that it permits computing all choice probabilities. We establish that given exact choice probabilities for a collection of item sets, one can reconstruct the DAG. However, attempting to extend this methodology to estimate the DAG from noisy choice frequency data obtained during an active learning process leads to inaccuracies. To address this challenge, we present an inclusion-exclusion approach that effectively manages error propagation across DAG levels, leading to a more accurate estimate of the DAG. Utilizing this technique, our algorithm estimates the DAG representation of an underlying non-parametric choice model. The algorithm operates efficiently (in polynomial time) when the set of frequent rankings is drawn uniformly at random. It learns the distribution over the most popular items among frequent preference types by actively and repeatedly offering assortments of items and observing the chosen item. We demonstrate that our algorithm more effectively recovers a set of frequent preferences on both synthetic and publicly available datasets on consumers' preferences, compared to corresponding non-active learning estimation algorithms. These findings underscore the value of our algorithm and the broader applicability of active-learning approaches in modeling consumer behavior.
Read more4/26/2024
💬
0
Kernel-Based Differentiable Learning of Non-Parametric Directed Acyclic Graphical Models
Yurou Liang, Oleksandr Zadorozhnyi, Mathias Drton
Causal discovery amounts to learning a directed acyclic graph (DAG) that encodes a causal model. This model selection problem can be challenging due to its large combinatorial search space, particularly when dealing with non-parametric causal models. Recent research has sought to bypass the combinatorial search by reformulating causal discovery as a continuous optimization problem, employing constraints that ensure the acyclicity of the graph. In non-parametric settings, existing approaches typically rely on finite-dimensional approximations of the relationships between nodes, resulting in a score-based continuous optimization problem with a smooth acyclicity constraint. In this work, we develop an alternative approximation method by utilizing reproducing kernel Hilbert spaces (RKHS) and applying general sparsity-inducing regularization terms based on partial derivatives. Within this framework, we introduce an extended RKHS representer theorem. To enforce acyclicity, we advocate the log-determinant formulation of the acyclicity constraint and show its stability. Finally, we assess the performance of our proposed RKHS-DAGMA procedure through simulations and illustrative data analyses.
Read more8/21/2024
0
Amortized Active Learning for Nonparametric Functions
Cen-You Li, Marc Toussaint, Barbara Rakitsch, Christoph Zimmer
Active learning (AL) is a sequential learning scheme aiming to select the most informative data. AL reduces data consumption and avoids the cost of labeling large amounts of data. However, AL trains the model and solves an acquisition optimization for each selection. It becomes expensive when the model training or acquisition optimization is challenging. In this paper, we focus on active nonparametric function learning, where the gold standard Gaussian process (GP) approaches suffer from cubic time complexity. We propose an amortized AL method, where new data are suggested by a neural network which is trained up-front without any real data (Figure 1). Our method avoids repeated model training and requires no acquisition optimization during the AL deployment. We (i) utilize GPs as function priors to construct an AL simulator, (ii) train an AL policy that can zero-shot generalize from simulation to real learning problems of nonparametric functions and (iii) achieve real-time data selection and comparable learning performances to time-consuming baseline methods.
Read more9/12/2024
0
Deep Bayesian Active Learning for Preference Modeling in Large Language Models
Luckeciano C. Melo, Panagiotis Tigas, Alessandro Abate, Yarin Gal
Leveraging human preferences for steering the behavior of Large Language Models (LLMs) has demonstrated notable success in recent years. Nonetheless, data selection and labeling are still a bottleneck for these systems, particularly at large scale. Hence, selecting the most informative points for acquiring human feedback may considerably reduce the cost of preference labeling and unleash the further development of LLMs. Bayesian Active Learning provides a principled framework for addressing this challenge and has demonstrated remarkable success in diverse settings. However, previous attempts to employ it for Preference Modeling did not meet such expectations. In this work, we identify that naive epistemic uncertainty estimation leads to the acquisition of redundant samples. We address this by proposing the Bayesian Active Learner for Preference Modeling (BAL-PM), a novel stochastic acquisition policy that not only targets points of high epistemic uncertainty according to the preference model but also seeks to maximize the entropy of the acquired prompt distribution in the feature space spanned by the employed LLM. Notably, our experiments demonstrate that BAL-PM requires 33% to 68% fewer preference labels in two popular human preference datasets and exceeds previous stochastic Bayesian acquisition policies.
Read more6/17/2024