Advancing Anomaly Detection in Computational Workflows with Active Learning
2405.06133
0
0
Abstract
A computational workflow, also known as workflow, consists of tasks that are executed in a certain order to attain a specific computational campaign. Computational workflows are commonly employed in science domains, such as physics, chemistry, genomics, to complete large-scale experiments in distributed and heterogeneous computing environments. However, running computations at such a large scale makes the workflow applications prone to failures and performance degradation, which can slowdown, stall, and ultimately lead to workflow failure. Learning how these workflows behave under normal and anomalous conditions can help us identify the causes of degraded performance and subsequently trigger appropriate actions to resolve them. However, learning in such circumstances is a challenging task because of the large volume of high-quality historical data needed to train accurate and reliable models. Generating such datasets not only takes a lot of time and effort but it also requires a lot of resources to be devoted to data generation for training purposes. Active learning is a promising approach to this problem. It is an approach where the data is generated as required by the machine learning model and thus it can potentially reduce the training data needed to derive accurate models. In this work, we present an active learning approach that is supported by an experimental framework, Poseidon-X, that utilizes a modern workflow management system and two cloud testbeds. We evaluate our approach using three computational workflows. For one workflow we run an end-to-end live active learning experiment, for the other two we evaluate our active learning algorithms using pre-captured data traces provided by the Flow-Bench benchmark. Our findings indicate that active learning not only saves resources, but it also improves the accuracy of the detection of anomalies.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a novel active learning approach to improve anomaly detection in computational workflows.
- The proposed method leverages active learning to efficiently label relevant samples and update the anomaly detection model, leading to better performance with fewer labeled instances.
- The paper also introduces a new anomaly detection benchmark dataset and demonstrates the effectiveness of the approach on this dataset as well as several others.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a way to improve how computers can automatically detect unusual or anomalous patterns in complex data streams, like those found in scientific computing workflows. The key idea is to use "active learning" - where the system selectively asks a human expert to label certain data points that are most informative for improving the anomaly detection model.
This is more efficient than randomly labeling data, as the active learning approach focuses on the most relevant samples. By updating the anomaly detection model with these strategically selected labels, the system can achieve better performance with fewer total labeled instances.
The researchers also created a new benchmark dataset to help evaluate anomaly detection methods. They show their active learning approach outperforms other techniques on this dataset as well as several other real-world anomaly detection problems.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces an active learning framework for improving anomaly detection in computational workflows. The key innovation is a query strategy that selects the most informative unlabeled samples for a human expert to label, allowing the anomaly detection model to be updated efficiently.
The authors propose an active learning pipeline that starts with an initial anomaly detection model trained on a small set of labeled data. The model then iteratively queries the most informative unlabeled instances, obtains labels from an oracle (e.g., human expert), and retrains the model.
The query strategy is based on a combination of uncertainty sampling and diversity sampling, aiming to identify samples that will provide the greatest improvement to the anomaly detection performance.
The researchers evaluate their approach on a new benchmark dataset for anomaly detection in scientific workflows, as well as several other real-world anomaly detection problems. They demonstrate that their active learning method outperforms traditional passive learning approaches in terms of detection accuracy.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising active learning approach for improving anomaly detection, but there are a few caveats to consider. First, the method relies on the availability of a human expert to provide labels, which may not always be feasible in real-world settings. The authors acknowledge this limitation and suggest exploring ways to leverage weakly supervised or unsupervised techniques to reduce the burden on the expert.
Additionally, the evaluation is limited to a few specific anomaly detection datasets, and it's unclear how the method would scale to larger, more complex workflows. Further research is needed to understand the generalizability of the approach and its performance in more diverse application domains.
Another potential issue is the reliance on a single, static anomaly detection model. In dynamic environments, the underlying data distribution may change over time, requiring the model to adapt continuously. The authors do not address how their active learning framework could be extended to handle such concept drift scenarios.
Despite these limitations, the paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of anomaly detection by demonstrating the effectiveness of active learning techniques in this domain. The proposed approach represents a step forward in developing more efficient and robust anomaly detection systems for complex computational workflows.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel active learning framework for improving anomaly detection in computational workflows. By selectively querying an expert to label the most informative data points, the system can update the anomaly detection model more efficiently, leading to better performance with fewer labeled instances.
The researchers introduce a new benchmark dataset for anomaly detection in scientific workflows and show that their active learning approach outperforms traditional passive learning methods on this dataset as well as several other real-world anomaly detection problems.
While the method has some limitations, such as the reliance on human experts and the potential challenges of handling concept drift, the paper represents an important step forward in developing more effective and scalable anomaly detection systems for complex computational environments.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Flow-Bench: A Dataset for Computational Workflow Anomaly Detection
George Papadimitriou, Hongwei Jin, Cong Wang, Rajiv Mayani, Krishnan Raghavan, Anirban Mandal, Prasanna Balaprakash, Ewa Deelman
0
0
A computational workflow, also known as workflow, consists of tasks that must be executed in a specific order to attain a specific goal. Often, in fields such as biology, chemistry, physics, and data science, among others, these workflows are complex and are executed in large-scale, distributed, and heterogeneous computing environments prone to failures and performance degradation. Therefore, anomaly detection for workflows is an important paradigm that aims to identify unexpected behavior or errors in workflow execution. This crucial task to improve the reliability of workflow executions can be further assisted by machine learning-based techniques. However, such application is limited, in large part, due to the lack of open datasets and benchmarking. To address this gap, we make the following contributions in this paper: (1) we systematically inject anomalies and collect raw execution logs from workflows executing on distributed infrastructures; (2) we summarize the statistics of new datasets, and provide insightful analyses; (3) we convert workflows into tabular, graph and text data, and benchmark with supervised and unsupervised anomaly detection techniques correspondingly. The presented dataset and benchmarks allow examining the effectiveness and efficiency of scientific computational workflows and identifying potential research opportunities for improvement and generalization. The dataset and benchmark code are publicly available url{https://poseidon-workflows.github.io/FlowBench/} under the MIT License.
6/14/2024
❗
Effectiveness of Tree-based Ensembles for Anomaly Discovery: Insights, Batch and Streaming Active Learning
Shubhomoy Das, Md Rakibul Islam, Nitthilan Kannappan Jayakodi, Janardhan Rao Doppa
0
0
In many real-world AD applications including computer security and fraud prevention, the anomaly detector must be configurable by the human analyst to minimize the effort on false positives. One important way to configure the detector is by providing true labels (nominal or anomaly) for a few instances. Recent work on active anomaly discovery has shown that greedily querying the top-scoring instance and tuning the weights of ensemble detectors based on label feedback allows us to quickly discover true anomalies. This paper makes four main contributions to improve the state-of-the-art in anomaly discovery using tree-based ensembles. First, we provide an important insight that explains the practical successes of unsupervised tree-based ensembles and active learning based on greedy query selection strategy. We also present empirical results on real-world data to support our insights and theoretical analysis to support active learning. Second, we develop a novel batch active learning algorithm to improve the diversity of discovered anomalies based on a formalism called compact description to describe the discovered anomalies. Third, we develop a novel active learning algorithm to handle streaming data setting. We present a data drift detection algorithm that not only detects the drift robustly, but also allows us to take corrective actions to adapt the anomaly detector in a principled manner. Fourth, we present extensive experiments to evaluate our insights and our tree-based active anomaly discovery algorithms in both batch and streaming data settings. Our results show that active learning allows us to discover significantly more anomalies than state-of-the-art unsupervised baselines, our batch active learning algorithm discovers diverse anomalies, and our algorithms under the streaming-data setup are competitive with the batch setup.
5/15/2024
❗
Lifelong Continual Learning for Anomaly Detection: New Challenges, Perspectives, and Insights
Kamil Faber, Roberto Corizzo, Bartlomiej Sniezynski, Nathalie Japkowicz
0
0
Anomaly detection is of paramount importance in many real-world domains, characterized by evolving behavior. Lifelong learning represents an emerging trend, answering the need for machine learning models that continuously adapt to new challenges in dynamic environments while retaining past knowledge. However, limited efforts are dedicated to building foundations for lifelong anomaly detection, which provides intrinsically different challenges compared to the more widely explored classification setting. In this paper, we face this issue by exploring, motivating, and discussing lifelong anomaly detection, trying to build foundations for its wider adoption. First, we explain why lifelong anomaly detection is relevant, defining challenges and opportunities to design anomaly detection methods that deal with lifelong learning complexities. Second, we characterize learning settings and a scenario generation procedure that enables researchers to experiment with lifelong anomaly detection using existing datasets. Third, we perform experiments with popular anomaly detection methods on proposed lifelong scenarios, emphasizing the gap in performance that could be gained with the adoption of lifelong learning. Overall, we conclude that the adoption of lifelong anomaly detection is important to design more robust models that provide a comprehensive view of the environment, as well as simultaneous adaptation and knowledge retention.
4/3/2024
Classification Tree-based Active Learning: A Wrapper Approach
Ashna Jose, Emilie Devijver, Massih-Reza Amini, Noel Jakse, Roberta Poloni
0
0
Supervised machine learning often requires large training sets to train accurate models, yet obtaining large amounts of labeled data is not always feasible. Hence, it becomes crucial to explore active learning methods for reducing the size of training sets while maintaining high accuracy. The aim is to select the optimal subset of data for labeling from an initial unlabeled set, ensuring precise prediction of outcomes. However, conventional active learning approaches are comparable to classical random sampling. This paper proposes a wrapper active learning method for classification, organizing the sampling process into a tree structure, that improves state-of-the-art algorithms. A classification tree constructed on an initial set of labeled samples is considered to decompose the space into low-entropy regions. Input-space based criteria are used thereafter to sub-sample from these regions, the total number of points to be labeled being decomposed into each region. This adaptation proves to be a significant enhancement over existing active learning methods. Through experiments conducted on various benchmark data sets, the paper demonstrates the efficacy of the proposed framework by being effective in constructing accurate classification models, even when provided with a severely restricted labeled data set.
4/16/2024