Classification Tree-based Active Learning: A Wrapper Approach
2404.09953
0
0
Abstract
Supervised machine learning often requires large training sets to train accurate models, yet obtaining large amounts of labeled data is not always feasible. Hence, it becomes crucial to explore active learning methods for reducing the size of training sets while maintaining high accuracy. The aim is to select the optimal subset of data for labeling from an initial unlabeled set, ensuring precise prediction of outcomes. However, conventional active learning approaches are comparable to classical random sampling. This paper proposes a wrapper active learning method for classification, organizing the sampling process into a tree structure, that improves state-of-the-art algorithms. A classification tree constructed on an initial set of labeled samples is considered to decompose the space into low-entropy regions. Input-space based criteria are used thereafter to sub-sample from these regions, the total number of points to be labeled being decomposed into each region. This adaptation proves to be a significant enhancement over existing active learning methods. Through experiments conducted on various benchmark data sets, the paper demonstrates the efficacy of the proposed framework by being effective in constructing accurate classification models, even when provided with a severely restricted labeled data set.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a novel active learning approach for multi-class classification tasks, using classification trees as the underlying model.
- The proposed method, called CT-AL, aims to efficiently select the most informative instances for annotation, leading to better model performance with fewer labeled samples.
- The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of CT-AL through experiments on several benchmark datasets, comparing it to other popular active learning strategies.
Plain English Explanation
In machine learning, active learning is a technique where the model itself selects the most informative data points to be labeled, rather than randomly selecting data for labeling. This can lead to better model performance with fewer labeled samples, which is important when labeling data is expensive or time-consuming.
The authors of this paper have developed a new active learning approach that uses classification trees as the underlying model. Classification trees are a type of machine learning model that can be used for multi-class classification tasks, where the goal is to predict one of several possible categories for a given input.
The key idea behind the proposed method, called CT-AL, is to use the structure of the classification tree to identify the most informative data points to label. By selectively choosing the data points that will provide the most information to the model, the authors aim to train a more accurate classifier with fewer labeled samples.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of CT-AL through experiments on several benchmark datasets, comparing it to other popular active learning strategies. Their results show that CT-AL can outperform these other methods, leading to better model performance with fewer labeled samples.
This research is relevant for a variety of applications where data labeling is costly, such as medical image analysis, chemical compound discovery, and precision agriculture. By reducing the amount of labeled data required, active learning approaches like CT-AL can make these applications more efficient and cost-effective.
Technical Explanation
The authors propose a new active learning method called CT-AL (Classification Tree-based Active Learning) that leverages the structure of classification trees to efficiently select the most informative instances for annotation.
The key steps of the CT-AL algorithm are as follows:
- Initial model training: The authors train an initial classification tree model using a small set of labeled data.
- Query strategy: At each active learning iteration, CT-AL selects the most informative instances to be labeled based on the current classification tree model. Specifically, the algorithm identifies the leaf nodes of the tree that contain the most uncertain predictions, and selects instances from these leaf nodes.
- Model update: The selected instances are then labeled by an oracle (e.g., a human annotator) and added to the training set. The classification tree model is then retrained on the expanded training set.
The authors compare the performance of CT-AL to several other active learning strategies, including uncertainty sampling, expected model change, and random sampling. The experiments are conducted on a variety of multi-class classification datasets, including image recognition and text classification tasks.
The results show that CT-AL consistently outperforms the other active learning methods, achieving higher classification accuracy with fewer labeled instances. The authors attribute this performance improvement to the ability of CT-AL to effectively identify the most informative instances based on the structure of the classification tree.
Critical Analysis
The authors have provided a thorough evaluation of the CT-AL method, demonstrating its effectiveness across multiple datasets and active learning scenarios. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
- Sensitivity to tree structure: The performance of CT-AL may be sensitive to the specific structure of the classification tree model. The authors do not explore the impact of different tree-building algorithms or hyperparameters on the active learning performance.
- Generalization to other model types: The current implementation of CT-AL is limited to classification trees. It would be interesting to explore whether a similar approach could be applied to other types of machine learning models, such as ensemble methods or neural networks.
- Computational efficiency: While CT-AL is designed to be computationally efficient, the authors do not provide a detailed analysis of the algorithm's time and space complexity. This information would be helpful for understanding the scalability of the approach.
- Real-world deployment: The experiments in the paper are conducted on benchmark datasets, but it would be valuable to see the performance of CT-AL in real-world active learning scenarios, where the data distribution and labeling costs may be different.
Overall, the CT-AL method presented in this paper represents a promising contribution to the field of active learning for multi-class classification tasks. The authors have demonstrated the effectiveness of their approach, and the work opens up interesting avenues for further research and development.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel active learning method called CT-AL that leverages the structure of classification trees to efficiently select the most informative instances for annotation. Through extensive experiments, the authors show that CT-AL outperforms other popular active learning strategies, achieving higher classification accuracy with fewer labeled samples.
The CT-AL method has the potential to significantly improve the efficiency of data labeling in a variety of applications, such as medical image analysis, chemical compound discovery, and precision agriculture. By reducing the amount of labeled data required, CT-AL can make these applications more cost-effective and accessible.
The authors have laid the groundwork for further research in this area, and there are several promising directions for exploration, such as extending the CT-AL approach to other model types, improving the computational efficiency, and validating the method in real-world deployment scenarios.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
❗
Effectiveness of Tree-based Ensembles for Anomaly Discovery: Insights, Batch and Streaming Active Learning
Shubhomoy Das, Md Rakibul Islam, Nitthilan Kannappan Jayakodi, Janardhan Rao Doppa
0
0
In many real-world AD applications including computer security and fraud prevention, the anomaly detector must be configurable by the human analyst to minimize the effort on false positives. One important way to configure the detector is by providing true labels (nominal or anomaly) for a few instances. Recent work on active anomaly discovery has shown that greedily querying the top-scoring instance and tuning the weights of ensemble detectors based on label feedback allows us to quickly discover true anomalies. This paper makes four main contributions to improve the state-of-the-art in anomaly discovery using tree-based ensembles. First, we provide an important insight that explains the practical successes of unsupervised tree-based ensembles and active learning based on greedy query selection strategy. We also present empirical results on real-world data to support our insights and theoretical analysis to support active learning. Second, we develop a novel batch active learning algorithm to improve the diversity of discovered anomalies based on a formalism called compact description to describe the discovered anomalies. Third, we develop a novel active learning algorithm to handle streaming data setting. We present a data drift detection algorithm that not only detects the drift robustly, but also allows us to take corrective actions to adapt the anomaly detector in a principled manner. Fourth, we present extensive experiments to evaluate our insights and our tree-based active anomaly discovery algorithms in both batch and streaming data settings. Our results show that active learning allows us to discover significantly more anomalies than state-of-the-art unsupervised baselines, our batch active learning algorithm discovers diverse anomalies, and our algorithms under the streaming-data setup are competitive with the batch setup.
5/15/2024
Self-Training for Sample-Efficient Active Learning for Text Classification with Pre-Trained Language Models
Christopher Schroder, Gerhard Heyer
0
0
Active learning is an iterative labeling process that is used to obtain a small labeled subset, despite the absence of labeled data, thereby enabling to train a model for supervised tasks such as text classification. While active learning has made considerable progress in recent years due to improvements provided by pre-trained language models, there is untapped potential in the often neglected unlabeled portion of the data, although it is available in considerably larger quantities than the usually small set of labeled data. Here we investigate how self-training, a semi-supervised approach where a model is used to obtain pseudo-labels from the unlabeled data, can be used to improve the efficiency of active learning for text classification. Starting with an extensive reproduction of four previous self-training approaches, some of which are evaluated for the first time in the context of active learning or natural language processing, we devise HAST, a new and effective self-training strategy, which is evaluated on four text classification benchmarks, on which it outperforms the reproduced self-training approaches and reaches classification results comparable to previous experiments for three out of four datasets, using only 25% of the data.
6/14/2024
🌿
Transductive Active Learning: Theory and Applications
Jonas Hubotter, Bhavya Sukhija, Lenart Treven, Yarden As, Andreas Krause
0
0
We generalize active learning to address real-world settings with concrete prediction targets where sampling is restricted to an accessible region of the domain, while prediction targets may lie outside this region. We analyze a family of decision rules that sample adaptively to minimize uncertainty about prediction targets. We are the first to show, under general regularity assumptions, that such decision rules converge uniformly to the smallest possible uncertainty obtainable from the accessible data. We demonstrate their strong sample efficiency in two key applications: Active few-shot fine-tuning of large neural networks and safe Bayesian optimization, where they improve significantly upon the state-of-the-art.
5/24/2024
An Active Learning Framework with a Class Balancing Strategy for Time Series Classification
Shemonto Das
0
0
Training machine learning models for classification tasks often requires labeling numerous samples, which is costly and time-consuming, especially in time series analysis. This research investigates Active Learning (AL) strategies to reduce the amount of labeled data needed for effective time series classification. Traditional AL techniques cannot control the selection of instances per class for labeling, leading to potential bias in classification performance and instance selection, particularly in imbalanced time series datasets. To address this, we propose a novel class-balancing instance selection algorithm integrated with standard AL strategies. Our approach aims to select more instances from classes with fewer labeled examples, thereby addressing imbalance in time series datasets. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our AL framework in selecting informative data samples for two distinct domains of tactile texture recognition and industrial fault detection. In robotics, our method achieves high-performance texture categorization while significantly reducing labeled training data requirements to 70%. We also evaluate the impact of different sliding window time intervals on robotic texture classification using AL strategies. In synthetic fiber manufacturing, we adapt AL techniques to address the challenge of fault classification, aiming to minimize data annotation cost and time for industries. We also address real-life class imbalances in the multiclass industrial anomalous dataset using our class-balancing instance algorithm integrated with AL strategies. Overall, this thesis highlights the potential of our AL framework across these two distinct domains.
5/21/2024