An Adversarial Approach to Evaluating the Robustness of Event Identification Models
2402.12338
0
0
š
Abstract
Intelligent machine learning approaches are finding active use for event detection and identification that allow real-time situational awareness. Yet, such machine learning algorithms have been shown to be susceptible to adversarial attacks on the incoming telemetry data. This paper considers a physics-based modal decomposition method to extract features for event classification and focuses on interpretable classifiers including logistic regression and gradient boosting to distinguish two types of events: load loss and generation loss. The resulting classifiers are then tested against an adversarial algorithm to evaluate their robustness. The adversarial attack is tested in two settings: the white box setting, wherein the attacker knows exactly the classification model; and the gray box setting, wherein the attacker has access to historical data from the same network as was used to train the classifier, but does not know the classification model. Thorough experiments on the synthetic South Carolina 500-bus system highlight that a relatively simpler model such as logistic regression is more susceptible to adversarial attacks than gradient boosting.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores using machine learning techniques for real-time event detection and classification, with a focus on robustness against adversarial attacks.
- The researchers propose a physics-based modal decomposition method to extract features for event classification, and test logistic regression and gradient boosting as interpretable classifiers.
- The classifiers are evaluated against adversarial attacks in both white box (attacker knows the model) and gray box (attacker has access to historical data) settings.
- Experiments on a 500-bus synthetic power system show that a simpler model like logistic regression is more susceptible to adversarial attacks than the more complex gradient boosting.
Plain English Explanation
Machine learning is being used more and more to quickly detect and identify important events, like power grid failures, in real-time. However, these machine learning models can be tricked by adversarial attacks that manipulate the input data.
This paper looks at a method to extract meaningful features from the power grid data using physics-based techniques. They then test two different machine learning algorithms - logistic regression and gradient boosting - to classify two types of events: load loss and generation loss.
The researchers then attack these models with adversarial techniques. In the white box setting, the attacker knows exactly how the classification model works. In the gray box setting, the attacker has access to past data from the same power grid, but doesn't know the model details.
The experiments show that the simpler logistic regression model is more vulnerable to these adversarial attacks compared to the more complex gradient boosting model. This suggests that using more powerful, but still interpretable, machine learning models can help make event detection systems more robust against malicious attempts to fool them.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes using a physics-based modal decomposition method to extract meaningful features from power grid sensor data for event classification. They evaluate two interpretable machine learning algorithms - logistic regression and gradient boosting - to distinguish between load loss and generation loss events.
To test the robustness of these classifiers, the researchers apply adversarial attacks in two settings:
- White box: The attacker knows the exact details of the classification model.
- Gray box: The attacker has access to historical data from the same power grid, but does not know the classification model.
Experiments are conducted on a 500-bus synthetic power system model. The results show that the simpler logistic regression model is more susceptible to adversarial attacks compared to the more complex gradient boosting approach. This suggests that using more powerful, yet still interpretable, machine learning models can improve the reliability of real-time event detection systems in the face of adversarial threats.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough evaluation of the robustness of the proposed event classification models against adversarial attacks. However, the researchers acknowledge that the experiments are limited to a synthetic power system, and further validation on real-world power grid data would be needed to assess the practical applicability of the approach.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the trade-offs between model complexity, interpretability, and robustness in depth. While the results suggest that gradient boosting is more resistant to adversarial attacks than logistic regression, it would be valuable to understand the underlying reasons for this behavior and whether there are other machine learning techniques that could offer an even better balance of these important factors.
Lastly, the paper does not discuss potential mitigation strategies or defense mechanisms that could be employed to further enhance the reliability of the event detection system, such as adversarial training or semantic-aware adversarial attacks. Exploring these avenues could provide valuable insights for building robust real-time situational awareness systems.
Conclusion
This paper presents a promising approach to improve the reliability of machine learning-based event detection and identification systems in the power grid domain. By using a physics-based feature extraction method and evaluating interpretable classifiers, the researchers demonstrate that more sophisticated machine learning models can be more resilient to adversarial attacks compared to simpler alternatives.
The findings of this work highlight the importance of considering model robustness, in addition to accuracy and interpretability, when designing real-time situational awareness systems. As machine learning becomes increasingly prevalent in critical infrastructure monitoring and control, ensuring the security and reliability of these systems is of paramount importance for maintaining grid stability and resilience.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
āØ
Reliable Feature Selection for Adversarially Robust Cyber-Attack Detection
Jo~ao Vitorino, Miguel Silva, Eva Maia, Isabel Prac{c}a
0
0
The growing cybersecurity threats make it essential to use high-quality data to train Machine Learning (ML) models for network traffic analysis, without noisy or missing data. By selecting the most relevant features for cyber-attack detection, it is possible to improve both the robustness and computational efficiency of the models used in a cybersecurity system. This work presents a feature selection and consensus process that combines multiple methods and applies them to several network datasets. Two different feature sets were selected and were used to train multiple ML models with regular and adversarial training. Finally, an adversarial evasion robustness benchmark was performed to analyze the reliability of the different feature sets and their impact on the susceptibility of the models to adversarial examples. By using an improved dataset with more data diversity, selecting the best time-related features and a more specific feature set, and performing adversarial training, the ML models were able to achieve a better adversarially robust generalization. The robustness of the models was significantly improved without their generalization to regular traffic flows being affected, without increases of false alarms, and without requiring too many computational resources, which enables a reliable detection of suspicious activity and perturbed traffic flows in enterprise computer networks.
4/8/2024
From Attack to Defense: Insights into Deep Learning Security Measures in Black-Box Settings
Firuz Juraev, Mohammed Abuhamad, Eric Chan-Tin, George K. Thiruvathukal, Tamer Abuhmed
0
0
Deep Learning (DL) is rapidly maturing to the point that it can be used in safety- and security-crucial applications. However, adversarial samples, which are undetectable to the human eye, pose a serious threat that can cause the model to misbehave and compromise the performance of such applications. Addressing the robustness of DL models has become crucial to understanding and defending against adversarial attacks. In this study, we perform comprehensive experiments to examine the effect of adversarial attacks and defenses on various model architectures across well-known datasets. Our research focuses on black-box attacks such as SimBA, HopSkipJump, MGAAttack, and boundary attacks, as well as preprocessor-based defensive mechanisms, including bits squeezing, median smoothing, and JPEG filter. Experimenting with various models, our results demonstrate that the level of noise needed for the attack increases as the number of layers increases. Moreover, the attack success rate decreases as the number of layers increases. This indicates that model complexity and robustness have a significant relationship. Investigating the diversity and robustness relationship, our experiments with diverse models show that having a large number of parameters does not imply higher robustness. Our experiments extend to show the effects of the training dataset on model robustness. Using various datasets such as ImageNet-1000, CIFAR-100, and CIFAR-10 are used to evaluate the black-box attacks. Considering the multiple dimensions of our analysis, e.g., model complexity and training dataset, we examined the behavior of black-box attacks when models apply defenses. Our results show that applying defense strategies can significantly reduce attack effectiveness. This research provides in-depth analysis and insight into the robustness of DL models against various attacks, and defenses.
5/6/2024
šļø
Adversarial Patterns: Building Robust Android Malware Classifiers
Dipkamal Bhusal, Nidhi Rastogi
0
0
Machine learning models are increasingly being adopted across various fields, such as medicine, business, autonomous vehicles, and cybersecurity, to analyze vast amounts of data, detect patterns, and make predictions or recommendations. In the field of cybersecurity, these models have made significant improvements in malware detection. However, despite their ability to understand complex patterns from unstructured data, these models are susceptible to adversarial attacks that perform slight modifications in malware samples, leading to misclassification from malignant to benign. Numerous defense approaches have been proposed to either detect such adversarial attacks or improve model robustness. These approaches have resulted in a multitude of attack and defense techniques and the emergence of a field known as `adversarial machine learning.' In this survey paper, we provide a comprehensive review of adversarial machine learning in the context of Android malware classifiers. Android is the most widely used operating system globally and is an easy target for malicious agents. The paper first presents an extensive background on Android malware classifiers, followed by an examination of the latest advancements in adversarial attacks and defenses. Finally, the paper provides guidelines for designing robust malware classifiers and outlines research directions for the future.
4/16/2024
A Systematic Evaluation of Adversarial Attacks against Speech Emotion Recognition Models
Nicolas Facchinetti, Federico Simonetta, Stavros Ntalampiras
0
0
Speech emotion recognition (SER) is constantly gaining attention in recent years due to its potential applications in diverse fields and thanks to the possibility offered by deep learning technologies. However, recent studies have shown that deep learning models can be vulnerable to adversarial attacks. In this paper, we systematically assess this problem by examining the impact of various adversarial white-box and black-box attacks on different languages and genders within the context of SER. We first propose a suitable methodology for audio data processing, feature extraction, and CNN-LSTM architecture. The observed outcomes highlighted the significant vulnerability of CNN-LSTM models to adversarial examples (AEs). In fact, all the considered adversarial attacks are able to significantly reduce the performance of the constructed models. Furthermore, when assessing the efficacy of the attacks, minor differences were noted between the languages analyzed as well as between male and female speech. In summary, this work contributes to the understanding of the robustness of CNN-LSTM models, particularly in SER scenarios, and the impact of AEs. Interestingly, our findings serve as a baseline for a) developing more robust algorithms for SER, b) designing more effective attacks, c) investigating possible defenses, d) improved understanding of the vocal differences between different languages and genders, and e) overall, enhancing our comprehension of the SER task.
4/30/2024