On the Adversarial Robustness of Learning-based Image Compression Against Rate-Distortion Attacks

Overview

• This paper explores the vulnerability of learning-based image compression (LIC) algorithms to adversarial attacks.
• Existing studies have focused on attacks targeting a single dimension, either bitrate or distortion, and assume control over the compression ratio.
• The authors present two new attack paradigms - Specific-ratio Rate-Distortion Attack (SRDA) and Agnostic-ratio Rate-Distortion Attack (ARDA) - that can target both bitrate and distortion simultaneously, without requiring control over the compression ratio.
• The paper also introduces a suite of assessment tools to evaluate the impact of these attacks from various perspectives.
• Extensive experiments are conducted on eight prominent LIC algorithms to assess their inherent vulnerabilities, and the effectiveness of two defense techniques is explored.

Plain English Explanation

Learning-based image compression algorithms have been shown to be very effective at reducing the file size of images without significantly degrading their quality. However, recent studies have found that these algorithms can be tricked by adversarial samples, which are carefully crafted images designed to fool the algorithms.

In the past, these adversarial attacks have typically targeted a single aspect of the compression algorithm, either the bitrate (how much the file size is reduced) or the distortion (how much the image quality is affected). Additionally, the attackers were assumed to have control over the compression ratio, which determines the balance between bitrate and distortion.

The authors of this paper argue that these assumptions are too simplistic and do not reflect real-world scenarios, where attackers may not have such precise control over the compression process. To address this, they propose two new attack paradigms that can target both bitrate and distortion simultaneously, without requiring control over the compression ratio.

The first attack, called the Specific-ratio Rate-Distortion Attack (SRDA), is designed to work with a specific compression ratio, while the second, called the Agnostic-ratio Rate-Distortion Attack (ARDA), can work with any compression ratio.

To evaluate the impact of these attacks, the authors introduce a suite of assessment tools that can look at the attacks from different angles, such as how they affect the overall image quality or the ability to identify specific features in the image.

Using these tools, the researchers conducted extensive experiments on eight prominent LIC algorithms to assess their vulnerabilities to the new attacks. They also explored the effectiveness of two defense techniques in improving the algorithms' performance under these joint rate-distortion attacks.

The findings from this research can provide valuable insights for the development of more robust and secure image compression algorithms that can withstand a wider range of adversarial attacks.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents two novel attack paradigms for learning-based image compression (LIC) algorithms:

1. Specific-ratio Rate-Distortion Attack (SRDA): This attack targets a specific compression ratio, aiming to degrade both the bitrate and distortion simultaneously. It does this by crafting adversarial samples that exploit the internal structure of the LIC algorithm's submodels.

2. Agnostic-ratio Rate-Distortion Attack (ARDA): This attack does not require control over the compression ratio and can work with any ratio. It achieves this by directly optimizing the adversarial samples to maximize the joint rate-distortion impact across the entire LIC algorithm.

To evaluate the effectiveness of these attacks, the authors introduce a suite of multi-granularity assessment tools. These tools can analyze the impact of the attacks on various aspects of the compressed images, such as overall quality, the ability to identify specific features, and the robustness of no-reference quality metrics.

The researchers then conduct extensive experiments on eight prominent LIC algorithms, including AutoEncoders, Generative Adversarial Networks, and Recurrent Neural Networks. The results reveal significant vulnerabilities in these algorithms to the new attack paradigms, with the ARDA attack proving particularly effective.

Furthermore, the paper explores the efficacy of two defense techniques - adversarial training and ensemble compression - in improving the performance of LIC algorithms under these joint rate-distortion attacks. The findings suggest that these defense strategies can help to enhance the adversarial robustness of the compression algorithms, but more research is needed to develop comprehensive solutions.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a comprehensive and well-designed study that addresses an important gap in the existing research on the adversarial robustness of learning-based image compression algorithms. The authors' introduction of the SRDA and ARDA attack paradigms, which can target both bitrate and distortion simultaneously without requiring control over the compression ratio, is a significant contribution to the field.

However, the paper also acknowledges several limitations and areas for future research. For example, the authors note that the proposed attacks may not be directly applicable to all LIC algorithms, as the internal structure and optimization objectives of these algorithms can vary. Additionally, the effectiveness of the defense techniques explored in the paper is limited, suggesting that more advanced approaches may be needed to truly enhance the adversarial robustness of LIC algorithms.

Furthermore, the paper does not explore the potential real-world implications of these adversarial attacks on the deployment of LIC algorithms in practical applications, such as image sharing or cloud storage services. It would be valuable for future research to investigate the impact of these attacks in more realistic scenarios and the potential countermeasures that could be implemented to mitigate the risks.

Overall, this paper provides a solid foundation for understanding the vulnerabilities of LIC algorithms to joint rate-distortion attacks and offers a starting point for the development of more robust and secure compression algorithms. The insights and techniques presented here can serve as a valuable reference for researchers and practitioners working in this field.

Conclusion

This paper presents a comprehensive study on the adversarial robustness of learning-based image compression algorithms. The authors introduce two novel attack paradigms, SRDA and ARDA, that can target both bitrate and distortion simultaneously without requiring control over the compression ratio. The extensive experiments conducted on eight prominent LIC algorithms reveal significant vulnerabilities to these joint rate-distortion attacks.

The findings from this research can provide valuable insights for the development of more secure and resilient image compression algorithms that can withstand a wider range of adversarial threats. The introduction of the multi-granularity assessment tools also offers a valuable framework for evaluating the adversarial robustness of compression algorithms from various perspectives.

While the paper explores the effectiveness of two defense techniques, the limited success of these approaches suggests that more advanced strategies may be needed to truly enhance the adversarial robustness of LIC algorithms. Future research should also investigate the real-world implications of these attacks and explore practical countermeasures to ensure the safe and reliable deployment of learning-based image compression in various applications.