Beyond Score Changes: Adversarial Attack on No-Reference Image Quality Assessment from Two Perspectives

Overview

• This paper explores adversarial attacks on no-reference image quality assessment (NR-IQA) models, which are used to evaluate image quality without a reference image.
• The authors propose a multi-objective optimization approach to generate adversarial examples that can fool NR-IQA models in two ways: by changing the predicted quality score and by changing the model's ranking of images.
• The paper provides insights into the vulnerabilities of NR-IQA models and the challenges of developing robust image quality assessment systems.

Plain English Explanation

Image quality assessment is an important task in many applications, such as photography, video streaming, and image editing. No-reference image quality assessment (NR-IQA) models can evaluate image quality without needing a reference image, which is useful when a reference is not available.

However, the authors of this paper discovered that these NR-IQA models can be "fooled" by adversarial attacks. Adversarial attacks are small, carefully crafted changes to an image that can cause machine learning models to make incorrect predictions.

The researchers developed a new technique that can generate adversarial examples that achieve two goals: 1) changing the predicted quality score of an image, and 2) changing the model's ranking of images from best to worst quality. This means the model can be tricked into thinking a low-quality image is high-quality, or vice versa.

By demonstrating these vulnerabilities, the paper provides important insights into the robustness of NR-IQA models and the challenges of building reliable image quality assessment systems. The findings could help researchers develop more robust and secure NR-IQA models that are less susceptible to adversarial attacks.

Technical Explanation

The authors propose a multi-objective optimization approach to generate adversarial examples that can fool NR-IQA models in two ways: by changing the predicted quality score and by changing the model's ranking of images.

Their method optimizes two objective functions simultaneously:

1. Score Change Objective: This objective aims to maximize the change in the predicted quality score of the adversarial image compared to the original image.

2. Ranking Change Objective: This objective aims to maximize the change in the model's ranking of the adversarial image compared to the original image within a set of reference images.

The authors evaluated their approach on several popular NR-IQA models using standard benchmark datasets. They found that their multi-granular adversarial attack was able to successfully fool the NR-IQA models, often achieving a large change in the predicted quality score and the model's ranking of the adversarial image.

These results highlight the vulnerability of NR-IQA models to adversarial attacks and the need for developing more robust and secure image quality assessment systems.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough analysis of the vulnerabilities of NR-IQA models to adversarial attacks. However, the authors acknowledge some limitations:

• The proposed attack is white-box, meaning it requires access to the target NR-IQA model's architecture and parameters. Black-box attacks, where the attacker has no access to the model, may be more realistic in practical scenarios.

• The authors only tested their attack on a limited set of NR-IQA models and datasets. Evaluating the attack on a wider range of models and datasets would provide a more comprehensive understanding of the vulnerabilities.

• The paper does not explore potential defenses or methods to make NR-IQA models more robust against adversarial attacks. Developing such countermeasures is an important area for future research.

Overall, the paper makes a valuable contribution by highlighting the need for more secure and robust image quality assessment systems, which is crucial for many real-world applications.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates that no-reference image quality assessment (NR-IQA) models can be vulnerable to adversarial attacks that can change the predicted quality score and the model's ranking of images. The authors propose a multi-objective optimization approach to generate such adversarial examples, providing insights into the weaknesses of current NR-IQA models.

These findings underscore the importance of developing more robust and secure image quality assessment systems that can withstand adversarial attacks. Future research should focus on exploring defense mechanisms and multi-view evaluation techniques to improve the reliability and trustworthiness of NR-IQA models in real-world applications.