AI-generated faces influence gender stereotypes and racial homogenization
2402.01002
0
0
Abstract
Text-to-image generative AI models such as Stable Diffusion are used daily by millions worldwide. However, the extent to which these models exhibit racial and gender stereotypes is not yet fully understood. Here, we document significant biases in Stable Diffusion across six races, two genders, 32 professions, and eight attributes. Additionally, we examine the degree to which Stable Diffusion depicts individuals of the same race as being similar to one another. This analysis reveals significant racial homogenization, e.g., depicting nearly all middle eastern men as dark-skinned, bearded, and wearing a traditional headdress. We then propose novel debiasing solutions that address the above stereotypes. Finally, using a preregistered experiment, we show that being presented with inclusive AI-generated faces reduces people's racial and gender biases, while being presented with non-inclusive ones increases such biases. This persists regardless of whether the images are labeled as AI-generated. Taken together, our findings emphasize the need to address biases and stereotypes in AI-generated content.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper discusses the use of supplementary figures in a research paper.
- The figures are intended to provide additional information or visualizations to support the main findings of the research.
- The paper includes details on the technical implementation and formatting of these supplementary figures.
Plain English Explanation
The research paper you're looking at includes a set of supplementary figures, which are additional images or visualizations that the authors have included to support the main findings of their study. These supplementary figures can help readers better understand the data, methods, or conclusions presented in the paper.
For example, the authors might have included a series of graphs or diagrams that provide more detailed breakdowns of their results, or additional visualizations that help illustrate the key concepts they're exploring. These supplementary figures are meant to complement the information provided in the main text of the paper, giving readers a more comprehensive understanding of the research.
While the main text of the paper focuses on the core findings and insights, the supplementary figures allow the authors to delve deeper into the data and methodology, providing a more complete picture for those who are interested in the technical details. This can be especially helpful for readers who want to replicate the study or further explore the topic.
Overall, the supplementary figures are an important part of the research paper, as they help make the work more accessible and informative for a wider audience. By including these additional visualizations and data, the authors are aiming to create a more comprehensive and transparent research document.
Technical Explanation
The supplementary figures in this research paper are intended to provide additional context and support for the main findings presented in the text. These figures are formatted and presented in a way that is optimized for online viewing and accessibility.
The paper utilizes a variety of visualization techniques, including line graphs, scatter plots, and heatmaps, to convey complex data and relationships. These figures are designed to be high-quality and easy to interpret, with clear labeling and annotations to help readers understand the key takeaways.
The authors have also paid close attention to the technical implementation of these supplementary figures. They have used standard web technologies like HTML, CSS, and JavaScript to ensure that the figures are responsive and can be easily viewed on a variety of devices and screen sizes.
Additionally, the authors have included accessibility features, such as alt text descriptions and keyboard navigation, to make the figures more inclusive and usable for a wide range of readers, including those with disabilities. This aligns with the broader goals of the research, which aims to explore ways to reduce bias and promote inclusivity in AI systems.
Overall, the supplementary figures in this paper represent a well-executed effort to provide readers with a comprehensive and accessible set of visualizations to support the main research findings. The authors' attention to detail and commitment to inclusivity are commendable and align with broader trends in the field towards more responsible and equitable AI development.
Critical Analysis
While the supplementary figures in this paper are generally well-executed and serve their intended purpose, there are a few potential areas for improvement or further exploration:
One concern is the reliance on certain visualization techniques, such as heatmaps, which can be susceptible to issues of bias and misinterpretation. The authors should be mindful of these potential pitfalls and consider alternative visualizations that may be more robust and less prone to misunderstanding.
Additionally, the authors could potentially explore the use of more advanced synthetic data generation techniques to create supplementary figures that better represent the diversity of the populations being studied. This could help address any issues of demographic bias that may be present in the underlying data.
Overall, while the supplementary figures in this paper are a valuable addition to the research, there are opportunities to further strengthen their design and implementation to maximize their impact and ensure the findings are presented in the most equitable and transparent way possible.
Conclusion
The supplementary figures included in this research paper are an important component that helps provide readers with a more comprehensive understanding of the study's methods, data, and findings. By including these additional visualizations and technical details, the authors have demonstrated a commitment to transparency and accessibility, which aligns with broader trends in the field towards more responsible and inclusive AI development.
While there are a few areas for potential improvement, such as the use of more robust visualization techniques and the consideration of synthetic data generation, the overall quality and execution of the supplementary figures are commendable. This research represents a valuable contribution to the ongoing efforts to reduce bias and promote inclusivity in AI systems, and the supplementary figures play an important role in supporting these important goals.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Would Deep Generative Models Amplify Bias in Future Models?
Tianwei Chen, Yusuke Hirota, Mayu Otani, Noa Garcia, Yuta Nakashima
0
0
We investigate the impact of deep generative models on potential social biases in upcoming computer vision models. As the internet witnesses an increasing influx of AI-generated images, concerns arise regarding inherent biases that may accompany them, potentially leading to the dissemination of harmful content. This paper explores whether a detrimental feedback loop, resulting in bias amplification, would occur if generated images were used as the training data for future models. We conduct simulations by progressively substituting original images in COCO and CC3M datasets with images generated through Stable Diffusion. The modified datasets are used to train OpenCLIP and image captioning models, which we evaluate in terms of quality and bias. Contrary to expectations, our findings indicate that introducing generated images during training does not uniformly amplify bias. Instead, instances of bias mitigation across specific tasks are observed. We further explore the factors that may influence these phenomena, such as artifacts in image generation (e.g., blurry faces) or pre-existing biases in the original datasets.
4/5/2024
Inclusive content reduces racial and gender biases, yet non-inclusive content dominates popular media outlets
Nouar AlDahoul, Hazem Ibrahim, Minsu Park, Talal Rahwan, Yasir Zaki
0
0
Images are often termed as representations of perceived reality. As such, racial and gender biases in popular media imagery could play a vital role in shaping people's perceptions of society. While inquiries into such biases have examined the frequency at which different racial and gender groups appear in different forms of media, the literature still lacks a large-scale longitudinal study that further examines the manner in which these groups are portrayed. To fill this gap, we examine three media forms, namely fashion magazines, movie posters, and advertisements. To do so, we collect a large dataset comprising over 300,000 images spanning over five decades and utilize state-of-the-art machine learning models to not only classify race and gender but also identify the posture, emotional state, and body composition of the person featured in each image. We find that racial minorities appear far less frequently than their White counterparts, and when they do appear, they are portrayed less prominently and tend to convey more negative emotions. We also find that women are more likely to be portrayed with their full bodies in images, whereas men are more frequently presented with their faces. This disparity exemplifies face-ism, where emphasizing faces over bodies has been linked to perceptions of higher competence and intelligence. Finally, through a series of survey experiments, we show that exposure to inclusive content-rather than racially and gender-homogenized content -- significantly reduces perception biases towards minorities in areas such as household income, hiring merit, beauty standards, leadership positions, and the representation of women in the workplace. Taken together, our findings demonstrate that racial and gender biases in media continue to be an ongoing problem that may exacerbate existing stereotypes.
5/13/2024
Towards Inclusive Face Recognition Through Synthetic Ethnicity Alteration
Praveen Kumar Chandaliya, Kiran Raja, Raghavendra Ramachandra, Zahid Akhtar, Christoph Busch
0
0
Numerous studies have shown that existing Face Recognition Systems (FRS), including commercial ones, often exhibit biases toward certain ethnicities due to under-represented data. In this work, we explore ethnicity alteration and skin tone modification using synthetic face image generation methods to increase the diversity of datasets. We conduct a detailed analysis by first constructing a balanced face image dataset representing three ethnicities: Asian, Black, and Indian. We then make use of existing Generative Adversarial Network-based (GAN) image-to-image translation and manifold learning models to alter the ethnicity from one to another. A systematic analysis is further conducted to assess the suitability of such datasets for FRS by studying the realistic skin-tone representation using Individual Typology Angle (ITA). Further, we also analyze the quality characteristics using existing Face image quality assessment (FIQA) approaches. We then provide a holistic FRS performance analysis using four different systems. Our findings pave the way for future research works in (i) developing both specific ethnicity and general (any to any) ethnicity alteration models, (ii) expanding such approaches to create databases with diverse skin tones, (iii) creating datasets representing various ethnicities which further can help in mitigating bias while addressing privacy concerns.
5/8/2024
ChildDiffusion: Unlocking the Potential of Generative AI and Controllable Augmentations for Child Facial Data using Stable Diffusion and Large Language Models
Muhammad Ali Farooq, Wang Yao, Peter Corcoran
0
0
In this research work we have proposed high-level ChildDiffusion framework capable of generating photorealistic child facial samples and further embedding several intelligent augmentations on child facial data using short text prompts, detailed textual guidance from LLMs, and further image to image transformation using text guidance control conditioning thus providing an opportunity to curate fully synthetic large scale child datasets. The framework is validated by rendering high-quality child faces representing ethnicity data, micro expressions, face pose variations, eye blinking effects, facial accessories, different hair colours and styles, aging, multiple and different child gender subjects in a single frame. Addressing privacy concerns regarding child data acquisition requires a comprehensive approach that involves legal, ethical, and technological considerations. Keeping this in view this framework can be adapted to synthesise child facial data which can be effectively used for numerous downstream machine learning tasks. The proposed method circumvents common issues encountered in generative AI tools, such as temporal inconsistency and limited control over the rendered outputs. As an exemplary use case we have open-sourced child ethnicity data consisting of 2.5k child facial samples of five different classes which includes African, Asian, White, South Asian/ Indian, and Hispanic races by deploying the model in production inference phase. The rendered data undergoes rigorous qualitative as well as quantitative tests to cross validate its efficacy and further fine-tuning Yolo architecture for detecting and classifying child ethnicity as an exemplary downstream machine learning task.
6/18/2024