AINeedsPlanner: A Workbook to Support Effective Collaboration Between AI Experts and Clients
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a workbook called \wbname to support effective collaboration between AI experts and clients.
- The workbook aims to facilitate the planning and development of AI applications by improving the flow of information and understanding between the two parties.
- It covers related work in areas like anticipating collaborative data-driven tasks, data-driven project planning, explainable AI, personalized learning, and AI-assisted event-driven systems.
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a workbook designed to improve the collaboration between AI experts and the clients who hire them. The key challenge is that these two groups often have very different backgrounds, expertise, and ways of communicating. This can lead to misunderstandings and inefficiencies when planning and developing AI applications.
The workbook aims to bridge this gap by providing a structured process and set of tools to facilitate the flow of information and mutual understanding between the AI team and the client. This includes helping them align on goals, scope, and expectations; documenting requirements and constraints; and establishing clear communication channels.
By using the workbook, the hope is that the two sides will be better able to understand each other's perspectives, anticipate potential issues, and work together more effectively throughout the AI development lifecycle. This can lead to higher-quality applications that better meet the client's needs.
Technical Explanation
The paper outlines the key components of the \wbname workbook, which is designed to guide the collaboration between AI experts and their clients. It covers areas like:
- Application Planning: Helping the two parties establish a shared understanding of the AI application goals, scope, timeline, and requirements through structured templates and worksheets.
- Information Flow: Providing tools to document and track the exchange of information, decisions, and action items between the AI team and client.
- Knowledge Sharing: Facilitating the transfer of domain expertise from the client to the AI team, and the communication of technical concepts from the AI team to the client.
- Conflict Resolution: Defining processes for identifying and resolving misalignments or disagreements that may arise during the collaboration.
The workbook is designed to be flexible and adaptable to different types of AI projects and client-AI team dynamics. It draws on best practices and lessons learned from related areas of research, such as anticipating collaborative data-driven tasks, data-driven project planning, explainable AI, personalized learning, and AI-assisted event-driven systems.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-thought-out workbook that aims to address a significant challenge in the AI industry - the gap between AI experts and their clients. By providing a structured approach to collaboration, the workbook has the potential to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of AI development projects.
However, the paper does not delve deeply into the specific challenges or obstacles that the workbook is designed to overcome. It would be helpful to have more insight into the types of misunderstandings, conflicts, or communication breakdowns that commonly arise between AI teams and clients, and how the workbook is intended to address these issues.
Additionally, the paper would benefit from a more thorough evaluation or validation of the workbook's effectiveness. While the authors mention drawing on best practices from related research, it would be valuable to see evidence of the workbook's real-world impact, either through case studies or user feedback.
Conclusion
The \wbname workbook presented in this paper is a promising tool for enhancing the collaboration between AI experts and their clients. By providing a structured process and set of tools to facilitate information flow, knowledge sharing, and conflict resolution, the workbook aims to bridge the gap between these two groups and lead to more successful AI development projects.
While the paper could benefit from a more in-depth exploration of the specific challenges the workbook is designed to address and validation of its effectiveness, the overall concept is well-conceived and has the potential to drive meaningful improvements in the AI industry.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
AINeedsPlanner: A Workbook to Support Effective Collaboration Between AI Experts and Clients
Dae Hyun Kim, Hyungyu Shin, Shakhnozakhon Yadgarova, Jinho Son, Hariharan Subramonyam, Juho Kim
Clients often partner with AI experts to develop AI applications tailored to their needs. In these partnerships, careful planning and clear communication are critical, as inaccurate or incomplete specifications can result in misaligned model characteristics, expensive reworks, and potential friction between collaborators. Unfortunately, given the complexity of requirements ranging from functionality, data, and governance, effective guidelines for collaborative specification of requirements in client-AI expert collaborations are missing. In this work, we introduce AINeedsPlanner, a workbook that AI experts and clients can use to facilitate effective interchange and clear specifications. The workbook is based on (1) an interview of 10 completed AI application project teams, which identifies and characterizes steps in AI application planning and (2) a study with 12 AI experts, which defines a taxonomy of AI experts' information needs and dimensions that affect the information needs. Finally, we demonstrate the workbook's utility with two case studies in real-world settings.
Read more5/28/2024
0
KG-Planner: Knowledge-Informed Graph Neural Planning for Collaborative Manipulators
Wansong Liu, Kareem Eltouny, Sibo Tian, Xiao Liang, Minghui Zheng
This paper presents a novel knowledge-informed graph neural planner (KG-Planner) to address the challenge of efficiently planning collision-free motions for robots in high-dimensional spaces, considering both static and dynamic environments involving humans. Unlike traditional motion planners that struggle with finding a balance between efficiency and optimality, the KG-Planner takes a different approach. Instead of relying solely on a neural network or imitating the motions of an oracle planner, our KG-Planner integrates explicit physical knowledge from the workspace. The integration of knowledge has two key aspects: (1) we present an approach to design a graph that can comprehensively model the workspace's compositional structure. The designed graph explicitly incorporates critical elements such as robot joints, obstacles, and their interconnections. This representation allows us to capture the intricate relationships between these elements. (2) We train a Graph Neural Network (GNN) that excels at generating nearly optimal robot motions. In particular, the GNN employs a layer-wise propagation rule to facilitate the exchange and update of information among workspace elements based on their connections. This propagation emphasizes the influence of these elements throughout the planning process. To validate the efficacy and efficiency of our KG-Planner, we conduct extensive experiments in both static and dynamic environments. These experiments include scenarios with and without human workers. The results of our approach are compared against existing methods, showcasing the superior performance of the KG-Planner. A short video introduction of this work is available (video link provided in the paper).
Read more5/14/2024
0
Anticipate & Collab: Data-driven Task Anticipation and Knowledge-driven Planning for Human-robot Collaboration
Shivam Singh, Karthik Swaminathan, Raghav Arora, Ramandeep Singh, Ahana Datta, Dipanjan Das, Snehasis Banerjee, Mohan Sridharan, Madhava Krishna
An agent assisting humans in daily living activities can collaborate more effectively by anticipating upcoming tasks. Data-driven methods represent the state of the art in task anticipation, planning, and related problems, but these methods are resource-hungry and opaque. Our prior work introduced a proof of concept framework that used an LLM to anticipate 3 high-level tasks that served as goals for a classical planning system that computed a sequence of low-level actions for the agent to achieve these goals. This paper describes DaTAPlan, our framework that significantly extends our prior work toward human-robot collaboration. Specifically, DaTAPlan planner computes actions for an agent and a human to collaboratively and jointly achieve the tasks anticipated by the LLM, and the agent automatically adapts to unexpected changes in human action outcomes and preferences. We evaluate DaTAPlan capabilities in a realistic simulation environment, demonstrating accurate task anticipation, effective human-robot collaboration, and the ability to adapt to unexpected changes. Project website: https://dataplan-hrc.github.io
Read more4/5/2024
0
App Planner: Utilizing Generative AI in K-12 Mobile App Development Education
David Kim, Prerna Ravi, Randi Williams, Daeun Yoo
App Planner is an interactive support tool for K-12 students, designed to assist in creating mobile applications. By utilizing generative AI, App Planner helps students articulate the problem and solution through guided conversations via a chat-based interface. It assists them in brainstorming and formulating new ideas for applications, provides feedback on those ideas, and stimulates creative thinking. Here we report usability tests from our preliminary study with high-school students who appreciated App Planner for aiding the app design process and providing new viewpoints on human aspects especially the potential negative impact of their creation.
Read more4/30/2024