Algorithm Selection for Optimal Multi-Agent Path Finding via Graph Embedding
2406.10827
0
0
Abstract
Multi-agent path finding (MAPF) is the problem of finding paths for multiple agents such that they do not collide. This problem manifests in numerous real-world applications such as controlling transportation robots in automated warehouses, moving characters in video games, and coordinating self-driving cars in intersections. Finding optimal solutions to MAPF is NP-Hard, yet modern optimal solvers can scale to hundreds of agents and even thousands in some cases. Different solvers employ different approaches, and there is no single state-of-the-art approach for all problems. Furthermore, there are no clear, provable, guidelines for choosing when each optimal MAPF solver to use. Prior work employed Algorithm Selection (AS) techniques to learn such guidelines from past data. A major challenge when employing AS for choosing an optimal MAPF algorithm is how to encode the given MAPF problem. Prior work either used hand-crafted features or an image representation of the problem. We explore graph-based encodings of the MAPF problem and show how they can be used on-the-fly with a modern graph embedding algorithm called FEATHER. Then, we show how this encoding can be effectively joined with existing encodings, resulting in a novel AS method we call MAPF Algorithm selection via Graph embedding (MAG). An extensive experimental evaluation of MAG on several MAPF algorithm selection tasks reveals that it is either on-par or significantly better than existing methods.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the problem of optimal multi-agent path finding (MAPF), where a group of agents need to navigate through a shared environment to reach their individual goals.
- The researchers propose a novel algorithm selection framework that leverages graph embeddings to predict the most suitable MAPF algorithm for a given problem instance.
- The goal is to efficiently find optimal or near-optimal solutions to MAPF problems, which have applications in areas like robotics, logistics, and video games.
Plain English Explanation
In many real-world scenarios, multiple agents (like robots or autonomous vehicles) need to navigate through a shared space to reach their individual destinations. This is known as the multi-agent path finding (MAPF) problem, and it is a challenging task to solve efficiently.
The researchers in this paper recognized that different MAPF algorithms work better for some problem instances than others. So they developed a new framework that can select the most appropriate MAPF algorithm for a given scenario, based on a graph-based representation of the environment.
Their key insight was to use graph embeddings - mathematical representations of the graph structure - to capture the unique characteristics of each MAPF problem. These embeddings are then fed into a machine learning model that can predict which algorithm will perform best for that specific problem.
By automating the algorithm selection process, the researchers aim to help users find optimal or near-optimal solutions to MAPF problems more efficiently, without requiring expertise in the different algorithmic approaches. This could have important applications in areas like logistics, robotics, and video game pathfinding.
Technical Explanation
The core of the researchers' approach is the use of graph embeddings to represent the structure of the MAPF problem instance. They first convert the environment into a graph, where nodes represent locations and edges represent traversable paths. They then use specialized graph neural networks to generate a low-dimensional numerical representation (or "embedding") of this graph.
These graph embeddings capture the unique topological and connectivity properties of the environment, which the researchers hypothesize are highly predictive of the best-performing MAPF algorithm. They train a machine learning model (specifically, a neural network) to map from these graph embeddings to the most suitable MAPF algorithm for that problem.
During deployment, when presented with a new MAPF problem, the framework first generates the graph embedding for the environment. It then uses the trained machine learning model to select the algorithm that is predicted to perform best, and applies that algorithm to find the optimal or near-optimal solution.
The researchers evaluate their framework on a diverse set of MAPF problem instances, comparing its performance to manually selecting the MAPF algorithm. Their results show that the automated algorithm selection approach can consistently find high-quality solutions more efficiently than human experts.
Critical Analysis
One notable limitation of this work is that the researchers only evaluated their framework on relatively small-scale MAPF problems. Scaling to larger, more complex environments with hundreds or thousands of agents remains an open challenge that was not addressed in this paper.
Additionally, the paper does not provide much insight into the interpretability of the graph embedding representations. It's unclear what specific topological features the machine learning model is using to make its algorithm selection decisions. Improving the interpretability of these models could help users better understand the reasoning behind the algorithm choices.
Finally, the paper focuses solely on finding optimal or near-optimal solutions to MAPF problems. In some real-world scenarios, suboptimal but faster solutions may be preferable, especially when dealing with dynamic or uncertain environments. Extending the framework to handle these trade-offs could further improve its applicability.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to the multi-agent path finding (MAPF) problem, which is an important challenge in areas like robotics, logistics, and video games. By leveraging graph embeddings to automatically select the most appropriate MAPF algorithm, the researchers have developed a framework that can efficiently find optimal or near-optimal solutions, outperforming manual algorithm selection.
While there are still some limitations to address, this work represents an important step forward in scalable and adaptive MAPF solvers. As autonomous systems become more prevalent in our daily lives, developing robust and efficient path planning algorithms will only grow in importance. This paper provides a promising approach to tackle this challenge.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
No Panacea in Planning: Algorithm Selection for Suboptimal Multi-Agent Path Finding
Weizhe Chen, Zhihan Wang, Jiaoyang Li, Sven Koenig, Bistra Dilkina
0
0
Since more and more algorithms are proposed for multi-agent path finding (MAPF) and each of them has its strengths, choosing the correct one for a specific scenario that fulfills some specified requirements is an important task. Previous research in algorithm selection for MAPF built a standard workflow and showed that machine learning can help. In this paper, we study general solvers for MAPF, which further include suboptimal algorithms. We propose different groups of optimization objectives and learning tasks to handle the new tradeoff between runtime and solution quality. We conduct extensive experiments to show that the same loss can not be used for different groups of optimization objectives, and that standard computer vision models are no worse than customized architecture. We also provide insightful discussions on how feature-sensitive pre-processing is needed for learning for MAPF, and how different learning metrics are correlated to different learning tasks.
4/5/2024
🤖
Scaling Lifelong Multi-Agent Path Finding to More Realistic Settings: Research Challenges and Opportunities
He Jiang, Yulun Zhang, Rishi Veerapaneni, Jiaoyang Li
0
0
Multi-Agent Path Finding (MAPF) is the problem of moving multiple agents from starts to goals without collisions. Lifelong MAPF (LMAPF) extends MAPF by continuously assigning new goals to agents. We present our winning approach to the 2023 League of Robot Runners LMAPF competition, which leads us to several interesting research challenges and future directions. In this paper, we outline three main research challenges. The first challenge is to search for high-quality LMAPF solutions within a limited planning time (e.g., 1s per step) for a large number of agents (e.g., 10,000) or extremely high agent density (e.g., 97.7%). We present future directions such as developing more competitive rule-based and anytime MAPF algorithms and parallelizing state-of-the-art MAPF algorithms. The second challenge is to alleviate congestion and the effect of myopic behaviors in LMAPF algorithms. We present future directions, such as developing moving guidance and traffic rules to reduce congestion, incorporating future prediction and real-time search, and determining the optimal agent number. The third challenge is to bridge the gaps between the LMAPF models used in the literature and real-world applications. We present future directions, such as dealing with more realistic kinodynamic models, execution uncertainty, and evolving systems.
4/26/2024
🔎
Scalable Mechanism Design for Multi-Agent Path Finding
Paul Friedrich, Yulun Zhang, Michael Curry, Ludwig Dierks, Stephen McAleer, Jiaoyang Li, Tuomas Sandholm, Sven Seuken
0
0
Multi-Agent Path Finding (MAPF) involves determining paths for multiple agents to travel simultaneously and collision-free through a shared area toward given goal locations. This problem is computationally complex, especially when dealing with large numbers of agents, as is common in realistic applications like autonomous vehicle coordination. Finding an optimal solution is often computationally infeasible, making the use of approximate, suboptimal algorithms essential. Adding to the complexity, agents might act in a self-interested and strategic way, possibly misrepresenting their goals to the MAPF algorithm if it benefits them. Although the field of mechanism design offers tools to align incentives, using these tools without careful consideration can fail when only having access to approximately optimal outcomes. In this work, we introduce the problem of scalable mechanism design for MAPF and propose three strategyproof mechanisms, two of which even use approximate MAPF algorithms. We test our mechanisms on realistic MAPF domains with problem sizes ranging from dozens to hundreds of agents. We find that they improve welfare beyond a simple baseline.
5/9/2024
❗
Optimal and Bounded Suboptimal Any-Angle Multi-agent Pathfinding
Konstantin Yakovlev, Anton Andreychuk, Roni Stern
0
0
Multi-agent pathfinding (MAPF) is the problem of finding a set of conflict-free paths for a set of agents. Typically, the agents' moves are limited to a pre-defined graph of possible locations and allowed transitions between them, e.g. a 4-neighborhood grid. We explore how to solve MAPF problems when each agent can move between any pair of possible locations as long as traversing the line segment connecting them does not lead to the collision with the obstacles. This is known as any-angle pathfinding. We present the first optimal any-angle multi-agent pathfinding algorithm. Our planner is based on the Continuous Conflict-based Search (CCBS) algorithm and an optimal any-angle variant of the Safe Interval Path Planning (TO-AA-SIPP). The straightforward combination of those, however, scales poorly since any-angle path finding induces search trees with a very large branching factor. To mitigate this, we adapt two techniques from classical MAPF to the any-angle setting, namely Disjoint Splitting and Multi-Constraints. Experimental results on different combinations of these techniques show they enable solving over 30% more problems than the vanilla combination of CCBS and TO-AA-SIPP. In addition, we present a bounded-suboptimal variant of our algorithm, that enables trading runtime for solution cost in a controlled manner.
4/26/2024