Scaling Lifelong Multi-Agent Path Finding to More Realistic Settings: Research Challenges and Opportunities
2404.16162
0
0
🤖
Abstract
Multi-Agent Path Finding (MAPF) is the problem of moving multiple agents from starts to goals without collisions. Lifelong MAPF (LMAPF) extends MAPF by continuously assigning new goals to agents. We present our winning approach to the 2023 League of Robot Runners LMAPF competition, which leads us to several interesting research challenges and future directions. In this paper, we outline three main research challenges. The first challenge is to search for high-quality LMAPF solutions within a limited planning time (e.g., 1s per step) for a large number of agents (e.g., 10,000) or extremely high agent density (e.g., 97.7%). We present future directions such as developing more competitive rule-based and anytime MAPF algorithms and parallelizing state-of-the-art MAPF algorithms. The second challenge is to alleviate congestion and the effect of myopic behaviors in LMAPF algorithms. We present future directions, such as developing moving guidance and traffic rules to reduce congestion, incorporating future prediction and real-time search, and determining the optimal agent number. The third challenge is to bridge the gaps between the LMAPF models used in the literature and real-world applications. We present future directions, such as dealing with more realistic kinodynamic models, execution uncertainty, and evolving systems.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents the winning approach to the 2023 League of Robot Runners Lifelong Multi-Agent Path Finding (LMAPF) competition.
- LMAPF is an extension of the Multi-Agent Path Finding (MAPF) problem, where multiple agents must be continuously assigned new goals while avoiding collisions.
- The paper outlines three key research challenges in LMAPF and suggests future directions to address them.
Plain English Explanation
The paper discusses a problem called Lifelong Multi-Agent Path Finding (LMAPF). This is a complex task where multiple robots or "agents" need to navigate through an environment and reach their assigned destinations without colliding with each other. The challenge is that the robots' destinations are constantly changing, so the robots have to continuously adapt their paths.
The researchers presented a winning approach to a competition on this LMAPF problem. Their approach led them to identify several interesting research challenges and potential future directions to explore. The three main challenges they highlight are:
-
Searching for high-quality LMAPF solutions quickly: When dealing with a large number of robots (e.g., 10,000) or very congested environments, the researchers need to find good solution paths within a short time (e.g., 1 second per step). Future directions could include developing more efficient MAPF algorithms and parallelizing existing approaches.
-
Alleviating congestion and myopic behaviors: LMAPF algorithms can sometimes cause traffic jams or make short-sighted decisions that lead to suboptimal outcomes. Future work could explore using traffic rules, prediction models, and optimizing the number of robots to improve coordination.
-
Bridging the gap between LMAPF models and real-world applications: The LMAPF problem as studied in research may not fully capture the complexities of real-world scenarios, such as realistic robot dynamics, execution uncertainty, and evolving environments. Future research could address these more practical challenges.
By addressing these research challenges, the researchers aim to advance the field of LMAPF and make it more applicable to real-world robotics and logistics problems, such as warehouse management or autonomous transportation.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents the winning approach to the 2023 League of Robot Runners LMAPF competition. LMAPF is an extension of the MAPF problem, where multiple agents (e.g., robots) must be continuously assigned new goals to reach while avoiding collisions.
The researchers outline three key research challenges in LMAPF:
-
Searching for high-quality LMAPF solutions within limited planning time: When dealing with a large number of agents (e.g., 10,000) or extremely high agent density (e.g., 97.7%), the researchers need to find good solution paths quickly (e.g., within 1 second per step). Future directions include developing more competitive rule-based and anytime MAPF algorithms, as well as parallelizing state-of-the-art MAPF algorithms.
-
Alleviating congestion and the effect of myopic behaviors: LMAPF algorithms can sometimes lead to traffic congestion and make short-sighted decisions that result in suboptimal outcomes. Future work could focus on developing moving guidance and traffic rules to reduce congestion, incorporating future prediction and real-time search, and determining the optimal agent number.
-
Bridging the gaps between LMAPF models and real-world applications: The LMAPF problem as studied in research may not fully capture the complexities of real-world scenarios, such as realistic kinodynamic models, execution uncertainty, and evolving systems. Future research could address these more practical challenges.
By addressing these research challenges, the researchers aim to advance the field of LMAPF and make it more applicable to real-world robotics and logistics problems.
Critical Analysis
The paper identifies several interesting research challenges in LMAPF and suggests future directions to address them. However, the authors do not provide detailed solutions or experimental results to demonstrate the effectiveness of their proposed approaches.
While the researchers mention the need to deal with realistic robot dynamics, execution uncertainty, and evolving systems, they do not delve into the specifics of how these practical challenges could be addressed. More empirical evidence or case studies would be helpful to validate the relevance and feasibility of the proposed future research directions.
Additionally, the paper does not discuss potential limitations or drawbacks of the LMAPF problem formulation itself. It would be valuable to explore whether the LMAPF model captures all the essential aspects of real-world multi-agent coordination problems or if there are fundamental issues that need to be addressed.
Overall, the paper provides a solid overview of the research challenges in LMAPF and highlights promising future directions. However, more detailed investigations and empirical evaluations would be needed to fully assess the practicality and impact of the proposed solutions.
Conclusion
This paper presents the winning approach to the 2023 League of Robot Runners LMAPF competition and outlines three key research challenges in this field. The main challenges are: (1) quickly finding high-quality LMAPF solutions, (2) alleviating congestion and myopic behaviors, and (3) bridging the gap between LMAPF models and real-world applications.
By addressing these challenges, the researchers aim to advance the state of the art in LMAPF and make it more applicable to real-world robotics and logistics problems, such as warehouse management and autonomous transportation. The future research directions proposed in the paper, such as developing more efficient MAPF algorithms, incorporating traffic rules and prediction models, and dealing with realistic robot dynamics, could lead to significant improvements in the performance and practicality of LMAPF systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Caching-Augmented Lifelong Multi-Agent Path Finding
Yimin Tang, Zhenghong Yu, Yi Zheng, T. K. Satish Kumar, Jiaoyang Li, Sven Koenig
0
0
Multi-Agent Path Finding (MAPF), which involves finding collision-free paths for multiple robots, is crucial in various applications. Lifelong MAPF, where targets are reassigned to agents as soon as they complete their initial targets, offers a more accurate approximation of real-world warehouse planning. In this paper, we present a novel mechanism named Caching-Augmented Lifelong MAPF (CAL-MAPF), designed to improve the performance of Lifelong MAPF. We have developed a new type of map grid called cache for temporary item storage and replacement, and created a locking mechanism to improve the planning solution's stability. A task assigner (TA) is designed for CAL-MAPF to allocate target locations to agents and control agent status in different situations. CAL-MAPF has been evaluated using various cache replacement policies and input task distributions. We have identified three main factors significantly impacting CAL-MAPF performance through experimentation: suitable input task distribution, high cache hit rate, and smooth traffic. In general, CAL-MAPF has demonstrated potential for performance improvements in certain task distributions, map and agent configurations.
4/9/2024
🔎
Scalable Mechanism Design for Multi-Agent Path Finding
Paul Friedrich, Yulun Zhang, Michael Curry, Ludwig Dierks, Stephen McAleer, Jiaoyang Li, Tuomas Sandholm, Sven Seuken
0
0
Multi-Agent Path Finding (MAPF) involves determining paths for multiple agents to travel simultaneously and collision-free through a shared area toward given goal locations. This problem is computationally complex, especially when dealing with large numbers of agents, as is common in realistic applications like autonomous vehicle coordination. Finding an optimal solution is often computationally infeasible, making the use of approximate, suboptimal algorithms essential. Adding to the complexity, agents might act in a self-interested and strategic way, possibly misrepresenting their goals to the MAPF algorithm if it benefits them. Although the field of mechanism design offers tools to align incentives, using these tools without careful consideration can fail when only having access to approximately optimal outcomes. In this work, we introduce the problem of scalable mechanism design for MAPF and propose three strategyproof mechanisms, two of which even use approximate MAPF algorithms. We test our mechanisms on realistic MAPF domains with problem sizes ranging from dozens to hundreds of agents. We find that they improve welfare beyond a simple baseline.
5/9/2024
LNS2+RL: Combining Multi-agent Reinforcement Learning with Large Neighborhood Search in Multi-agent Path Finding
Yutong Wang, Tanishq Duhan, Jiaoyang Li, Guillaume Sartoretti
0
0
Multi-Agent Path Finding (MAPF) is a critical component of logistics and warehouse management, which focuses on planning collision-free paths for a team of robots in a known environment. Recent work introduced a novel MAPF approach, LNS2, which proposed to repair a quickly-obtainable set of infeasible paths via iterative re-planning, by relying on a fast, yet lower-quality, priority-based planner. At the same time, there has been a recent push for Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning (MARL) based MAPF algorithms, which let agents learn decentralized policies that exhibit improved cooperation over such priority planning, although inevitably remaining slower. In this paper, we introduce a new MAPF algorithm, LNS2+RL, which combines the distinct yet complementary characteristics of LNS2 and MARL to effectively balance their individual limitations and get the best from both worlds. During early iterations, LNS2+RL relies on MARL for low-level re-planning, which we show eliminates collisions much more than a priority-based planner. There, our MARL-based planner allows agents to reason about past and future/predicted information to gradually learn cooperative decision-making through a finely designed curriculum learning. At later stages of planning, LNS2+RL adaptively switches to priority-based planning to quickly resolve the remaining collisions, naturally trading-off solution quality and computational efficiency. Our comprehensive experiments on challenging tasks across various team sizes, world sizes, and map structures consistently demonstrate the superior performance of LNS2+RL compared to many MAPF algorithms, including LNS2, LaCAM, and EECBS, where LNS2+RL shows significantly better performance in complex scenarios. We finally experimentally validate our algorithm in a hybrid simulation of a warehouse mockup involving a team of 100 (real-world and simulated) robots.
5/29/2024
No Panacea in Planning: Algorithm Selection for Suboptimal Multi-Agent Path Finding
Weizhe Chen, Zhihan Wang, Jiaoyang Li, Sven Koenig, Bistra Dilkina
0
0
Since more and more algorithms are proposed for multi-agent path finding (MAPF) and each of them has its strengths, choosing the correct one for a specific scenario that fulfills some specified requirements is an important task. Previous research in algorithm selection for MAPF built a standard workflow and showed that machine learning can help. In this paper, we study general solvers for MAPF, which further include suboptimal algorithms. We propose different groups of optimization objectives and learning tasks to handle the new tradeoff between runtime and solution quality. We conduct extensive experiments to show that the same loss can not be used for different groups of optimization objectives, and that standard computer vision models are no worse than customized architecture. We also provide insightful discussions on how feature-sensitive pre-processing is needed for learning for MAPF, and how different learning metrics are correlated to different learning tasks.
4/5/2024