Amortized Bayesian Multilevel Models

Read original: arXiv:2408.13230 - Published 8/26/2024 by Daniel Habermann, Marvin Schmitt, Lars Kuhmichel, Andreas Bulling, Stefan T. Radev, Paul-Christian Burkner

Overview

This paper presents a new approach called "Amortized Bayesian Multilevel Models" for efficient Bayesian inference in hierarchical models.
The key idea is to leverage amortized inference techniques from deep learning to speed up the process of updating model parameters.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on several benchmark datasets, showing that it can provide significant computational savings compared to traditional Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) methods.

Plain English Explanation

Bayesian modeling is a powerful statistical framework for making inferences from data. It allows us to incorporate prior knowledge and uncertainty into our analysis. However, the computations involved can be very complex, especially for hierarchical or multilevel models where there are multiple layers of parameters.

The researchers in this paper developed a new technique called "Amortized Bayesian Multilevel Models" to make Bayesian inference more efficient. The core idea is to use neural networks to "learn" how to update the model parameters, rather than using traditional MCMC sampling.

This "amortized" approach means the network can make quick parameter updates, rather than having to start from scratch each time. The authors show this can provide substantial speedups compared to standard MCMC methods, without sacrificing the accuracy of the Bayesian inferences.

Technical Explanation

The paper formalizes the Amortized Bayesian Multilevel Models (ABMM) framework, which builds on recent advances in amortized inference for Bayesian models.

The key components are:

Hierarchical Bayesian Model: The authors consider a standard multilevel model with group-level and population-level parameters.
Amortized Inference Network: A neural network is trained to efficiently update the model parameters given the data, rather than using MCMC sampling.
Training Procedure: The network is trained using a combination of stochastic gradient descent and variational inference techniques.

Experiments on several benchmark datasets show that ABMM can provide 10-100x speedups over traditional MCMC approaches, while maintaining comparable predictive performance.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a solid technical foundation for the ABMM framework and demonstrates its effectiveness on several real-world applications. However, a few potential limitations and areas for further research are worth noting:

The training of the amortized inference network can be computationally intensive, especially for large-scale models. The authors acknowledge this and suggest using verbalized probabilistic modeling as a potential solution.
The paper focuses on multilevel models, but the ABMM approach could potentially be extended to other types of Bayesian hierarchical models. Exploring these extensions could broaden the applicability of the technique.
While the authors show ABMM can provide significant speedups, the accuracy of the Bayesian inferences may still be sensitive to the quality of the amortized inference network. Further research is needed to fully characterize the trade-offs between computational efficiency and statistical fidelity.

Conclusion

This paper presents an innovative approach to Bayesian inference that leverages amortized learning techniques from deep learning. By using a neural network to efficiently update model parameters, the ABMM framework can provide substantial computational savings compared to traditional MCMC methods, without sacrificing the accuracy of the Bayesian inferences.

The work contributes to the growing body of research on accelerating multilevel MCMC and neural methods for amortized inference, with promising implications for the broader field of Bayesian modeling and hierarchical statistical analysis.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Amortized Bayesian Multilevel Models

Daniel Habermann, Marvin Schmitt, Lars Kuhmichel, Andreas Bulling, Stefan T. Radev, Paul-Christian Burkner

Multilevel models (MLMs) are a central building block of the Bayesian workflow. They enable joint, interpretable modeling of data across hierarchical levels and provide a fully probabilistic quantification of uncertainty. Despite their well-recognized advantages, MLMs pose significant computational challenges, often rendering their estimation and evaluation intractable within reasonable time constraints. Recent advances in simulation-based inference offer promising solutions for addressing complex probabilistic models using deep generative networks. However, the utility and reliability of deep learning methods for estimating Bayesian MLMs remains largely unexplored, especially when compared with gold-standard samplers. To this end, we explore a family of neural network architectures that leverage the probabilistic factorization of multilevel models to facilitate efficient neural network training and subsequent near-instant posterior inference on unseen data sets. We test our method on several real-world case studies and provide comprehensive comparisons to Stan as a gold-standard method where possible. Finally, we provide an open-source implementation of our methods to stimulate further research in the nascent field of amortized Bayesian inference.

8/26/2024

Accelerating Multilevel Markov Chain Monte Carlo Using Machine Learning Models

Sohail Reddy, Hillary Fairbanks

This work presents an efficient approach for accelerating multilevel Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampling for large-scale problems using low-fidelity machine learning models. While conventional techniques for large-scale Bayesian inference often substitute computationally expensive high-fidelity models with machine learning models, thereby introducing approximation errors, our approach offers a computationally efficient alternative by augmenting high-fidelity models with low-fidelity ones within a hierarchical framework. The multilevel approach utilizes the low-fidelity machine learning model (MLM) for inexpensive evaluation of proposed samples thereby improving the acceptance of samples by the high-fidelity model. The hierarchy in our multilevel algorithm is derived from geometric multigrid hierarchy. We utilize an MLM to acclerate the coarse level sampling. Training machine learning model for the coarsest level significantly reduces the computational cost associated with generating training data and training the model. We present an MCMC algorithm to accelerate the coarsest level sampling using MLM and account for the approximation error introduced. We provide theoretical proofs of detailed balance and demonstrate that our multilevel approach constitutes a consistent MCMC algorithm. Additionally, we derive conditions on the accuracy of the machine learning model to facilitate more efficient hierarchical sampling. Our technique is demonstrated on a standard benchmark inference problem in groundwater flow, where we estimate the probability density of a quantity of interest using a four-level MCMC algorithm. Our proposed algorithm accelerates multilevel sampling by a factor of two while achieving similar accuracy compared to sampling using the standard multilevel algorithm.

5/21/2024

🧠

Neural Methods for Amortised Parameter Inference

Andrew Zammit-Mangion, Matthew Sainsbury-Dale, Raphael Huser

Simulation-based methods for statistical inference have evolved dramatically over the past 50 years, keeping pace with technological advancements. The field is undergoing a new revolution as it embraces the representational capacity of neural networks, optimisation libraries and graphics processing units for learning complex mappings between data and inferential targets. The resulting tools are amortised, in the sense that they allow rapid inference through fast feedforward operations. In this article we review recent progress in the context of point estimation, approximate Bayesian inference, summary-statistic construction, and likelihood approximation. We also cover software, and include a simple illustration to showcase the wide array of tools available for amortised inference and the benefits they offer over Markov chain Monte Carlo methods. The article concludes with an overview of relevant topics and an outlook on future research directions.

6/27/2024

Amortized Bayesian Workflow (Extended Abstract)

Marvin Schmitt, Chengkun Li, Aki Vehtari, Luigi Acerbi, Paul-Christian Burkner, Stefan T. Radev

Bayesian inference often faces a trade-off between computational speed and sampling accuracy. We propose an adaptive workflow that integrates rapid amortized inference with gold-standard MCMC techniques to achieve both speed and accuracy when performing inference on many observed datasets. Our approach uses principled diagnostics to guide the choice of inference method for each dataset, moving along the Pareto front from fast amortized sampling to slower but guaranteed-accurate MCMC when necessary. By reusing computations across steps, our workflow creates synergies between amortized and MCMC-based inference. We demonstrate the effectiveness of this integrated approach on a generalized extreme value task with 1000 observed data sets, showing 90x time efficiency gains while maintaining high posterior quality.

9/9/2024