Analyzing Transport Policies in Developing Countries with ABM
2404.19745
0
0
Abstract
Deciphering travel behavior and mode choices is a critical aspect of effective urban transportation system management, particularly in developing countries where unique socio-economic and cultural conditions complicate decision-making. Agent-based simulations offer a valuable tool for modeling transportation systems, enabling a nuanced understanding and policy impact evaluation. This work aims to shed light on the effects of transport policies and analyzes travel behavior by simulating agents making mode choices for their daily commutes. Agents gather information from the environment and their social network to assess the optimal transport option based on personal satisfaction criteria. Our findings, stemming from simulating a free-fare policy for public transit in a developing-country city, reveal a significant influence on decision-making, fostering public service use while positively influencing pollution levels, accident rates, and travel speed.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents an agent-based simulation model to analyze the impact of transport policies in developing countries.
- The model simulates the behavior of different types of agents, such as commuters, public transport operators, and policymakers, to explore how transport policies affect urban mobility patterns.
- The researchers apply the model to a case study in a major city in a developing country to evaluate the effectiveness of various policy interventions.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers developed a computer simulation to study how different transportation policies might affect people's travel habits in cities in developing countries. In the simulation, there are different "agents" that represent different groups, like commuters who need to get to work, public transportation providers, and policymakers who decide on transportation rules and investments.
The simulation allows the researchers to test out various transportation policies, such as building new roads or changing the cost of bus fares, and see how those policies impact things like how people choose to travel, the efficiency of the transportation system, and the accessibility of jobs and services for different groups of people.
By using this simulation approach, the researchers can experiment with different policy ideas without having to actually implement them in the real world first. This allows them to identify which transportation policies might be most effective at improving mobility and accessibility for the residents of developing cities, which often face unique transportation challenges compared to more developed cities.
Technical Explanation
The researchers developed an agent-based model (ABM) to simulate the transportation system in a developing city. The model includes several types of agents, such as:
- Commuters who need to travel to work and other destinations
- Public transport operators who provide bus and other transit services
- Policymakers who make decisions about transportation infrastructure and regulations
The model simulates how these different agents interact and make decisions about travel mode, route, and departure time. It also incorporates factors like road networks, public transit schedules, and transportation costs.
The researchers applied the model to a case study city and evaluated the impacts of various transportation policies, such as:
- Increasing the capacity and frequency of the public transit system
- Introducing congestion pricing or other demand management strategies
- Investing in new road infrastructure or improving existing roads
The simulation results allowed the researchers to assess how these policies would affect factors like overall travel time, accessibility of jobs and services, and equity of transportation access across different socioeconomic groups.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a useful framework for using agent-based simulation to analyze transportation policies in developing cities, which often face complex mobility challenges that are difficult to study using traditional modeling approaches.
However, the researchers acknowledge that the model relies on several simplifying assumptions and does not capture all the nuances of real-world transportation systems. For example, the model does not account for factors like travel mode choice behavior or the impact of informal transportation services.
Additionally, the case study application is limited to a single city, so the generalizability of the findings to other developing cities may be constrained. Further research is needed to validate the model's predictive capabilities and explore its applicability in diverse urban contexts.
Conclusion
This paper demonstrates the potential of agent-based simulation as a tool for analyzing transportation policies in developing cities. By modeling the complex interactions between different stakeholders and the transportation system, the researchers are able to provide insights into the likely impacts of various policy interventions.
While the model has some limitations, it represents a valuable step forward in using computational approaches to address the unique mobility challenges facing cities in the developing world. The findings from this research could inform policymakers and transportation planners as they work to improve urban accessibility and equity through strategic investments and regulatory changes.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📈
An agent-based model of modal choice with perception biases and habits
Carole Adam (STEAMER, LIG, UGA, LIG), Benoit Gaudou (UT Capitole, IRIT-SMAC, IRIT)
0
0
This paper presents an agent-based model of mobility choice, influenced by human factors such as habits and perception biases. It is implemented in a Netlogo simulator, calibrated from results of an online survey about perceptions of mobility. The simulator can be played online. It allows to modify urban infrastructure and observe modal report.
6/5/2024
Simulating the economic impact of rationality through reinforcement learning and agent-based modelling
Simone Brusatin, Tommaso Padoan, Andrea Coletta, Domenico Delli Gatti, Aldo Glielmo
0
0
Agent-based models (ABMs) are simulation models used in economics to overcome some of the limitations of traditional frameworks based on general equilibrium assumptions. However, agents within an ABM follow predetermined, not fully rational, behavioural rules which can be cumbersome to design and difficult to justify. Here we leverage multi-agent reinforcement learning (RL) to expand the capabilities of ABMs with the introduction of fully rational agents that learn their policy by interacting with the environment and maximising a reward function. Specifically, we propose a 'Rational macro ABM' (R-MABM) framework by extending a paradigmatic macro ABM from the economic literature. We show that gradually substituting ABM firms in the model with RL agents, trained to maximise profits, allows for a thorough study of the impact of rationality on the economy. We find that RL agents spontaneously learn three distinct strategies for maximising profits, with the optimal strategy depending on the level of market competition and rationality. We also find that RL agents with independent policies, and without the ability to communicate with each other, spontaneously learn to segregate into different strategic groups, thus increasing market power and overall profits. Finally, we find that a higher degree of rationality in the economy always improves the macroeconomic environment as measured by total output, depending on the specific rational policy, this can come at the cost of higher instability. Our R-MABM framework is general, it allows for stable multi-agent learning, and represents a principled and robust direction to extend existing economic simulators.
5/6/2024
🎯
Private Agent-Based Modeling
Ayush Chopra, Arnau Quera-Bofarull, Nurullah Giray-Kuru, Michael Wooldridge, Ramesh Raskar
0
0
The practical utility of agent-based models in decision-making relies on their capacity to accurately replicate populations while seamlessly integrating real-world data streams. Yet, the incorporation of such data poses significant challenges due to privacy concerns. To address this issue, we introduce a paradigm for private agent-based modeling wherein the simulation, calibration, and analysis of agent-based models can be achieved without centralizing the agents attributes or interactions. The key insight is to leverage techniques from secure multi-party computation to design protocols for decentralized computation in agent-based models. This ensures the confidentiality of the simulated agents without compromising on simulation accuracy. We showcase our protocols on a case study with an epidemiological simulation comprising over 150,000 agents. We believe this is a critical step towards deploying agent-based models to real-world applications.
4/22/2024
A deep causal inference model for fully-interpretable travel behaviour analysis
Kimia Kamal, Bilal Farooq
0
0
Transport policy assessment often involves causal questions, yet the causal inference capabilities of traditional travel behavioural models are at best limited. We present the deep CAusal infeRence mOdel for traveL behavIour aNAlysis (CAROLINA), a framework that explicitly models causality in travel behaviour, enhances predictive accuracy, and maintains interpretability by leveraging causal inference, deep learning, and traditional discrete choice modelling. Within this framework, we introduce a Generative Counterfactual model for forecasting human behaviour by adapting the Normalizing Flow method. Through the case studies of virtual reality-based pedestrian crossing behaviour, revealed preference travel behaviour from London, and synthetic data, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed models in uncovering causal relationships, prediction accuracy, and assessing policy interventions. Our results show that intervention mechanisms that can reduce pedestrian stress levels lead to a 38.5% increase in individuals experiencing shorter waiting times. Reducing the travel distances in London results in a 47% increase in sustainable travel modes.
5/6/2024