Assessing the Feasibility, and Efficacy of Virtual Reality Navigational Training for Older Adults
0
🏋️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Researchers evaluated the feasibility of using virtual reality (VR) training to improve wayfinding performance in older adults.
- The study compared the effects of active VR training, passive video training, and no training on wayfinding tasks in a real-world building.
- Participants' time spent and distance traveled on the tasks were measured as the primary outcomes.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers wanted to see if using virtual reality (VR) could help older adults get better at finding their way around. They had three groups: one group did active training in VR, one group watched a video, and one group had no training. The VR training had 5 tasks in a digital version of a real building. After the training, everyone did 10 tasks in the real building, with half being familiar from the training and half being new.
The researchers measured how long it took the participants to complete the tasks and how far they traveled. They found that the VR group reported the VR training was fairly easy to use and they felt they knew where they were in the virtual building. There was no difference in performance on the familiar tasks, but on the new tasks, the VR group took less time and traveled a shorter distance compared to the control group. The video group also traveled a shorter distance on the new tasks, but not as much as the VR group. No one had any problems during or after the training.
Overall, this study suggests that VR training can help older adults find their way around better, especially in new or unfamiliar places. This research could be useful for developing VR-based navigation training programs for older adults.
Technical Explanation
The study used a randomized, double-blind design with three groups: active VR training, passive video training, and a control group with no training. The VR training involved 5 wayfinding tasks in a digital version of a real building. After the training, all participants completed 10 wayfinding tasks in the real building, with half being familiar from the training and half being new.
The primary outcome measures were the time spent and distance traveled on each wayfinding task, with a 10-minute limit. Participants in the VR group reported moderate usability of the training system and high self-location awareness. There were no differences in performance on the familiar tasks between groups. However, on the new tasks, the VR group took marginally less time and traveled a significantly shorter distance compared to the control group. The video training group also showed a marginal reduction in distance traveled on the new tasks, but not as much as the VR group. No adverse effects were reported during or after the interventions.
Critical Analysis
The study provides preliminary evidence that VR training can effectively improve wayfinding performance in older adults, with no reported adverse effects. However, the sample size was relatively small (n=49), and the differences between the VR and video training groups were not statistically significant.
Further research with larger and more diverse samples would be needed to validate the findings and better understand the relative benefits of active VR training versus passive video training. Additionally, the study did not assess the long-term retention of the wayfinding skills or the transfer of these skills to real-world navigation. Longitudinal studies and assessments in more naturalistic environments would help determine the practical significance of the VR training approach.
Conclusion
This study provides preliminary evidence that VR training can improve wayfinding performance in older adults, with no reported adverse effects. The VR training appears to be more effective than passive video training, particularly for tasks in new or unfamiliar environments. These findings suggest that VR-based navigation training could be a valuable tool for helping older adults maintain their independence and quality of life as they age. Further research is needed to fully understand the long-term benefits and practical applications of this approach.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏋️
0
Assessing the Feasibility, and Efficacy of Virtual Reality Navigational Training for Older Adults
Tong Bill Xu, Armin Mostafavi, Walter R. Boot, Sara Czaja, Saleh Kalantari
Objective. Evaluate the feasibility of Virtual Reality (VR) wayfinding training with aging adults, and examine the impact of the training on wayfinding performance. Design. Design involved wayfinding tasks in a study with three groups: active VR training, passive video training, and no training, assigned randomly. The training featured 5 tasks in a digital version of a real building. Post-training assessments had 10 tasks in this building, half familiar from training and half new. The study was double-blinded, with each intervention lasting 10 minutes. Participants. A convenience sample of 49 participants; inclusion criteria: age >58, unfamiliar with the building; exclusion criteria: mobility or vision impairments, history of motion sickness, or medical implants. Outcomes. Time spent and Distance traveled on each wayfinding task with a fixed 10-min limit. Results. Participants in VR group reported moderate usability (63.82, SD=14.55) with respect to the training intervention and high Self Location (3.71, SD=0.94). There were no differences in task performance among the groups in the similar tasks. In the new tasks, compared to the control condition, Time spent on tasks was marginally significantly reduced in the VR group; Distance traveled to finish tasks was also reduced in the VR group, and marginally significantly reduced in the Video training group. No differences were found between VR and Video conditions. No adverse effects were reported during or post intervention. Conclusions. This study provides preliminary evidence that VR training can effectively improve wayfinding performance in older adults with no reported adverse effect.
Read more7/18/2024
🏋️
0
Evaluating the efficacy of haptic feedback, 360{deg} treadmill-integrated Virtual Reality framework and longitudinal training on decision-making performance in a complex search-and-shoot simulation
Akash K Rao, Arnav Bhavsar, Shubhajit Roy Chowdhury, Sushil Chandra, Ramsingh Negi, Prakash Duraisamy, Varun Dutt
Virtual Reality (VR) has made significant strides, offering users a multitude of ways to interact with virtual environments. Each sensory modality in VR provides distinct inputs and interactions, enhancing the user's immersion and presence. However, the potential of additional sensory modalities, such as haptic feedback and 360{deg} locomotion, to improve decision-making performance has not been thoroughly investigated. This study addresses this gap by evaluating the impact of a haptic feedback, 360{deg} locomotion-integrated VR framework and longitudinal, heterogeneous training on decision-making performance in a complex search-and-shoot simulation. The study involved 32 participants from a defence simulation base in India, who were randomly divided into two groups: experimental (haptic feedback, 360{deg} locomotion-integrated VR framework with longitudinal, heterogeneous training) and placebo control (longitudinal, heterogeneous VR training without extrasensory modalities). The experiment lasted 10 days. On Day 1, all subjects executed a search-and-shoot simulation closely replicating the elements/situations in the real world. From Day 2 to Day 9, the subjects underwent heterogeneous training, imparted by the design of various complexity levels in the simulation using changes in behavioral attributes/artificial intelligence of the enemies. On Day 10, they repeated the search-and-shoot simulation executed on Day 1. The results showed that the experimental group experienced a gradual increase in presence, immersion, and engagement compared to the placebo control group. However, there was no significant difference in decision-making performance between the two groups on day 10. We intend to use these findings to design multisensory VR training frameworks that enhance engagement levels and decision-making performance.
Read more4/16/2024
0
SilverCycling: Exploring the Impact of Bike-Based Locomotion on Spatial Orientation for Older Adults in VR
Qiongyan Chen, Zhiqing Wu, Yucheng Liu, Lei Han, Zisu Li, Ge Lin Kan, Mingming Fan
Spatial orientation is essential for people to effectively navigate and interact with the environment in everyday life. With age-related cognitive decline, providing VR locomotion techniques with better spatial orientation performance for older adults becomes important. Such advancements not only make VR more accessible to older adults but also enable them to reap the potential health benefits of VR technology. Natural motion-based locomotion has been shown to be effective in enhancing younger users' performance in VR navigation tasks that require spatial orientation. However, there is a lack of understanding regarding the impact of natural motion-based locomotion on spatial orientation for older adults in VR. To address this gap, we selected the SilverCycling system, a VR bike-based locomotion technique that we developed, as a representative of natural motion-based locomotion, guided by findings from our pilot study. We conducted a user study with 16 older adults to compare SilverCycling with the joystick-based controller. The findings suggest SilverCycling's potential to significantly enhance spatial orientation in the open-road urban environment for older adults, offering a better user experience. Based on our findings, we identify key factors influencing spatial orientation and propose design recommendations to make VR locomotion more accessible and user-friendly for older adults.
Read more7/10/2024
0
Evaluating a VR System for Collecting Safety-Critical Vehicle-Pedestrian Interactions
Erica Weng, Kenta Mukoya, Deva Ramanan, Kris Kitani
Autonomous vehicles (AVs) require comprehensive and reliable pedestrian trajectory data to ensure safe operation. However, obtaining data of safety-critical scenarios such as jaywalking and near-collisions, or uncommon agents such as children, disabled pedestrians, and vulnerable road users poses logistical and ethical challenges. This paper evaluates a Virtual Reality (VR) system designed to collect pedestrian trajectory and body pose data in a controlled, low-risk environment. We substantiate the usefulness of such a system through semi-structured interviews with professionals in the AV field, and validate the effectiveness of the system through two empirical studies: a first-person user evaluation involving 62 participants, and a third-person evaluative survey involving 290 respondents. Our findings demonstrate that the VR-based data collection system elicits realistic responses for capturing pedestrian data in safety-critical or uncommon vehicle-pedestrian interaction scenarios.
Read more7/11/2024