Atomic Self-Consistency for Better Long Form Generations

Overview

• This paper introduces Atomic Self-Consistency (ASC), a technique to improve the recall of relevant information in long-form responses generated by large language models (LLMs).
• ASC builds on recent work like Universal Self-Consistency (USC), which uses multiple stochastic samples from an LLM to enhance response quality.
• Unlike USC, which selects the best single generation, ASC picks authentic subparts from the samples and merges them into a superior composite answer.

Plain English Explanation

Large language models (LLMs) are powerful tools that can generate human-like text on a variety of topics. However, these models can sometimes produce information that is incorrect or not fully relevant to the question asked - a phenomenon known as "hallucination." Recent research has aimed to address this issue by filtering out hallucinations, thereby improving the precision of the information in LLM responses.

This paper introduces a new technique called Atomic Self-Consistency (ASC) that takes a different approach to improving the quality of LLM responses. Instead of just selecting the "best" single response, ASC looks at multiple sample responses generated by the model and identifies the most relevant and accurate subparts from each one. It then combines these subparts into a single, more comprehensive and reliable answer.

The key insight behind ASC is that while a single sample response may have some flaws or missing information, the collective set of samples is likely to contain the necessary pieces to assemble a high-quality, consistent response. By selectively combining these pieces, ASC can produce answers that are more complete and accurate than any individual sample.

The authors demonstrate through extensive experiments that ASC outperforms previous approaches like Universal Self-Consistency (USC) on a variety of factual and open-ended question-answering datasets. This suggests that ASC is a promising technique for enhancing the long-form generation capabilities of LLMs.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces Atomic Self-Consistency (ASC), a novel technique for improving the recall of relevant information in long-form responses generated by large language models (LLMs). ASC builds on recent work like Universal Self-Consistency (USC), which uses multiple stochastic samples from an LLM to enhance response quality.

Unlike USC, which focuses on selecting the best single generation, ASC picks authentic subparts from the samples and merges them into a superior composite answer. The key innovation of ASC is its ability to identify and combine the most relevant and accurate pieces of information across multiple sample responses, rather than simply choosing the "best" single response.

Through extensive experiments and ablations on datasets like ASQA, QAMPARI, QUEST, and ELI5, the authors demonstrate that this merging of relevant subparts significantly outperforms the single-sample selection approach of USC. The results show that ASC achieves substantial gains over USC on both factual and open-ended question-answering tasks when used with large language models like ChatGPT and LLaMA2.

The authors' analysis also suggests that there is untapped potential for further enhancing long-form generations by leveraging the ensemble of multiple samples, as demonstrated by the RELIC and Small Language Model Can Self-Correct works.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising approach to improving the quality of long-form responses generated by large language models. By selectively combining the most relevant and accurate subparts from multiple sample responses, ASC appears to outperform previous techniques like USC that focus on selecting the "best" single response.

One potential limitation of the ASC approach is the complexity of the merging process, which may introduce additional computational overhead or engineering challenges compared to simpler selection-based methods. The authors do not provide detailed information on the computational efficiency or scalability of their approach.

Additionally, the paper does not explore the potential for biases or errors to be amplified when merging information from multiple samples. It would be valuable to investigate how ASC performs in cases where the samples contain conflicting or erroneous information, and whether the merging process can reliably identify and resolve such discrepancies.

Another area for further research could be the integration of ASC with other techniques for improving long-form generation, such as the automated information comparison approach or the self-correction capabilities explored in other works. Combining multiple complementary techniques may lead to even greater improvements in the consistency and reliability of LLM responses.

Overall, the ASC approach represents an interesting and potentially impactful contribution to the field of long-form generation using large language models. While the paper raises some interesting questions and areas for further exploration, the demonstrated performance gains on a variety of datasets suggest that ASC is a promising direction for enhancing the capabilities of these powerful language models.

Conclusion

This paper introduces Atomic Self-Consistency (ASC), a novel technique for improving the recall of relevant information in long-form responses generated by large language models (LLMs). ASC builds on recent work in this area by selectively combining the most accurate and relevant subparts from multiple sample responses, rather than simply selecting the "best" single response.

Through extensive experimentation, the authors show that the ASC approach significantly outperforms previous techniques like Universal Self-Consistency (USC) on a range of factual and open-ended question-answering tasks. This suggests that ASC is a promising direction for enhancing the consistency and reliability of long-form generation from LLMs.

While the paper raises some interesting questions about the complexity and potential biases of the ASC merging process, the demonstrated performance gains indicate that this technique has the potential to meaningfully improve the quality and usefulness of LLM-generated text. As large language models continue to advance, techniques like ASC will be increasingly important for ensuring the trustworthiness and reliability of their outputs.