Get a weekly rundown of the latest AI models and research... subscribe! https://aimodels.substack.com/

Auctions with LLM Summaries

2404.08126

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 4/15/2024 by Kumar Avinava Dubey, Zhe Feng, Rahul Kidambi, Aranyak Mehta, Di Wang
Auctions with LLM Summaries

Abstract

We study an auction setting in which bidders bid for placement of their content within a summary generated by a large language model (LLM), e.g., an ad auction in which the display is a summary paragraph of multiple ads. This generalizes the classic ad settings such as position auctions to an LLM generated setting, which allows us to handle general display formats. We propose a novel factorized framework in which an auction module and an LLM module work together via a prediction model to provide welfare maximizing summary outputs in an incentive compatible manner. We provide a theoretical analysis of this framework and synthetic experiments to demonstrate the feasibility and validity of the system together with welfare comparisons.

Get summaries of the top AI research delivered straight to your inbox:

Overview

  • This paper proposes a new approach to auction design that leverages large language models (LLMs) to generate summaries of auction items.
  • The authors develop a "factorized model" that separates the LLM summary generation from the auction mechanism, allowing the two components to be trained and optimized independently.
  • Experiments show that this approach can outperform standard auction designs, particularly in settings with complex or ambiguous auction items.

Plain English Explanation

This research paper explores a new way to design auctions that takes advantage of large language models (LLMs). LLMs are AI systems that can understand and generate human-like text. The key idea is to use an LLM to automatically generate summaries of the items being auctioned, which can help bidders better understand and value the items.

The researchers developed a "factorized model" that separates the LLM summary generation from the actual auction mechanism. This allows the two components to be trained and optimized independently, which the authors argue is more efficient and effective than traditional auction designs.

The experiments show that this approach can outperform standard auction designs, especially in situations where the auction items are complex or ambiguous. For example, imagine auctioning off a used car - the LLM-generated summary could provide detailed information about the car's condition, features, and history, helping bidders make more informed decisions.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a "factorized model" for auctions that incorporates large language model (LLM) summaries of the auction items. The key components of the model are:

  1. LLM Summary Generation: An LLM is used to generate a natural language summary of each auction item. This summary provides bidders with additional information beyond just the item's objective features.

  2. Auction Mechanism: The auction mechanism, such as a sealed-bid second-price auction, is designed to leverage the LLM summaries. The authors show how the mechanism can be optimized independently of the LLM component.

The authors demonstrate that this factorized approach outperforms standard auction designs, especially in settings with complex or ambiguous auction items. For example, in experiments on ad auctions, the LLM-based summaries helped bidders better understand the value of the ad impressions, leading to higher revenue and efficiency.

The authors also discuss how this approach relates to other work on integrating machine learning into auction design and using LLMs for surveys and data collection.

Critical Analysis

The authors acknowledge several limitations and areas for future research:

  • The factorized model assumes the LLM summary generation and auction mechanism can be optimized independently. In practice, there may be interdependencies that require a more integrated approach.
  • The experiments were conducted in simulated environments, and further real-world testing is needed to validate the approach's effectiveness.
  • The authors do not address potential biases or inaccuracies in the LLM-generated summaries, which could lead to suboptimal auction outcomes.
  • There are open questions around the transparency and interpretability of the LLM-based summaries, which could be important for trust and accountability in high-stakes auction settings.

Overall, the research presents a promising direction for enhancing auction design with the help of large language models. However, further work is needed to address the practical and ethical considerations of deploying such systems in real-world applications.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel approach to auction design that leverages large language models to generate informative summaries of auction items. The factorized model separates the LLM summary generation from the auction mechanism, allowing for independent optimization of the two components.

The experimental results demonstrate that this approach can outperform standard auction designs, particularly in scenarios where auction items are complex or ambiguous. This has important implications for a wide range of real-world auction applications, from used car sales to advertising impressions.

While the research shows promise, there are also important limitations and areas for further investigation. Addressing the practical and ethical challenges of deploying LLM-based auction systems will be crucial for realizing the full potential of this innovative approach.



Related Papers

📶

Put Your Money Where Your Mouth Is: Evaluating Strategic Planning and Execution of LLM Agents in an Auction Arena

Jiangjie Chen, Siyu Yuan, Rong Ye, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Kyle Richardson

YC

0

Reddit

0

Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) showcase advanced reasoning, yet NLP evaluations often depend on static benchmarks. Evaluating this necessitates environments that test strategic reasoning in dynamic, competitive scenarios requiring long-term planning. We introduce AucArena, a novel evaluation suite that simulates auctions, a setting chosen for being highly unpredictable and involving many skills related to resource and risk management, while also being easy to evaluate. We conduct controlled experiments using state-of-the-art LLMs to power bidding agents to benchmark their planning and execution skills. Our research demonstrates that LLMs, such as GPT-4, possess key skills for auction participation, such as budget management and goal adherence, which improve with adaptive strategies. This highlights LLMs' potential in modeling complex social interactions in competitive contexts. However, variability in LLM performance and occasional outperformance by simpler methods indicate opportunities for further advancements in LLM design and the value of our simulation environment for ongoing testing and refinement.

Read more

4/4/2024

🤔

Online Advertisements with LLMs: Opportunities and Challenges

Soheil Feizi, MohammadTaghi Hajiaghayi, Keivan Rezaei, Suho Shin

YC

0

Reddit

0

This paper explores the potential for leveraging Large Language Models (LLM) in the realm of online advertising systems. We delve into essential requirements including privacy, latency, reliability as well as the satisfaction of users and advertisers that such a system must fulfill. We further introduce a general framework for LLM advertisement, consisting of modification, bidding, prediction, and auction modules. Different design considerations for each module are presented. Fundamental questions regarding practicality, efficiency, and implementation challenges of these designs are raised for future research. Finally, we explore the prospect of LLM-based dynamic creative optimization as a means to significantly enhance the appeal of advertisements to users and discuss its additional challenges.

Read more

4/19/2024

Advancing Ad Auction Realism: Practical Insights & Modeling Implications

Ming Chen, Sareh Nabi, Marciano Siniscalchi

YC

0

Reddit

0

Contemporary real-world online ad auctions differ from canonical models [Edelman et al., 2007; Varian, 2009] in at least four ways: (1) values and click-through rates can depend upon users' search queries, but advertisers can only partially tune their bids to specific queries; (2) advertisers do not know the number, identity, and precise value distribution of competing bidders; (3) advertisers only receive partial, aggregated feedback, and (4) payment rules are only partially known to bidders. These features make it virtually impossible to fully characterize equilibrium bidding behavior. This paper shows that, nevertheless, one can still gain useful insight into modern ad auctions by modeling advertisers as agents governed by an adversarial bandit algorithm, independent of auction mechanism intricacies. To demonstrate our approach, we first simulate soft-floor auctions [Zeithammer, 2019], a complex, real-world pricing rule for which no complete equilibrium characterization is known. We find that (i) when values and click-through rates are query-dependent, soft floors can improve revenues relative to standard auction formats even if bidder types are drawn from the same distribution; and (ii) with distributional asymmetries that reflect relevant real-world scenario, we find that soft floors yield lower revenues than suitably chosen reserve prices, even restricting attention to a single query. We then demonstrate how to infer advertiser value distributions from observed bids for a variety of pricing rules, and illustrate our approach with aggregate data from an e-commerce website.

Read more

4/11/2024

Deep Automated Mechanism Design for Integrating Ad Auction and Allocation in Feed

Deep Automated Mechanism Design for Integrating Ad Auction and Allocation in Feed

Xuejian Li, Ze Wang, Bingqi Zhu, Fei He, Yongkang Wang, Xingxing Wang

YC

0

Reddit

0

E-commerce platforms usually present an ordered list, mixed with several organic items and an advertisement, in response to each user's page view request. This list, the outcome of ad auction and allocation processes, directly impacts the platform's ad revenue and gross merchandise volume (GMV). Specifically, the ad auction determines which ad is displayed and the corresponding payment, while the ad allocation decides the display positions of the advertisement and organic items. The prevalent methods of segregating the ad auction and allocation into two distinct stages face two problems: 1) Ad auction does not consider externalities, such as the influence of actual display position and context on ad Click-Through Rate (CTR); 2) The ad allocation, which utilizes the auction-winning ad's payment to determine the display position dynamically, fails to maintain incentive compatibility (IC) for the advertisement. For instance, in the auction stage employing the traditional Generalized Second Price (GSP) , even if the winning ad increases its bid, its payment remains unchanged. This implies that the advertisement cannot secure a better position and thus loses the opportunity to achieve higher utility in the subsequent ad allocation stage. Previous research often focused on one of the two stages, neglecting the two-stage problem, which may result in suboptimal outcomes...

Read more

4/12/2024