Automated Model Selection for Tabular Data
2401.00961
0
0
Abstract
Structured data in the form of tabular datasets contain features that are distinct and discrete, with varying individual and relative importances to the target. Combinations of one or more features may be more predictive and meaningful than simple individual feature contributions. R's mixed effect linear models library allows users to provide such interactive feature combinations in the model design. However, given many features and possible interactions to select from, model selection becomes an exponentially difficult task. We aim to automate the model selection process for predictions on tabular datasets incorporating feature interactions while keeping computational costs small. The framework includes two distinct approaches for feature selection: a Priority-based Random Grid Search and a Greedy Search method. The Priority-based approach efficiently explores feature combinations using prior probabilities to guide the search. The Greedy method builds the solution iteratively by adding or removing features based on their impact. Experiments on synthetic demonstrate the ability to effectively capture predictive feature combinations.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents an automated model selection approach for tabular data problems, with a focus on generalized linear models.
- The proposed method aims to automatically select the best-performing model from a set of candidate models, without requiring manual hyperparameter tuning.
- The authors evaluate their approach on a variety of benchmark datasets and compare it to other automated model selection techniques.
Plain English Explanation
The paper describes a new way to automatically choose the best machine learning model for a given dataset, without requiring a human expert to manually test and tune different models. This is particularly useful for tabular data, which is the type of data often found in spreadsheets or databases, where the information is arranged in rows and columns.
The key idea is to have a system that can automatically try out different machine learning models, like linear regression or logistic regression, and then select the one that performs the best on the given dataset. This could save a lot of time and effort compared to the traditional approach of a human expert manually testing and tuning each model.
The authors evaluate their automated model selection approach on a variety of standard benchmark datasets and compare it to other automated techniques. The results suggest that their method is able to effectively identify the best-performing model without requiring human intervention.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes an automated model selection approach for tabular data problems, with a focus on generalized linear models. The key components of the proposed method are:
- Candidate Model Generation: The system automatically generates a set of candidate generalized linear models with different hyperparameter configurations.
- Performance Estimation: For each candidate model, the system estimates its performance using cross-validation on the training data.
- Model Selection: The system selects the candidate model with the best estimated performance as the final model.
The authors evaluate their approach on a variety of benchmark datasets and compare it to other automated model selection techniques, such as Bayesian optimization and random search. The results show that their method is able to effectively identify the best-performing model, often outperforming the other approaches.
Furthermore, the paper discusses the potential for large language models to be used for automating feature engineering and model selection tasks, which could further improve the efficiency of the overall modeling process.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and thorough evaluation of the proposed automated model selection approach. The authors have considered multiple benchmark datasets and compared their method to several other state-of-the-art techniques.
One potential limitation of the study is that it focuses solely on generalized linear models, which may not be the best-performing models for all types of tabular data problems. It would be interesting to see how the method performs when extended to a broader range of machine learning models, such as decision trees, random forests, or neural networks.
Additionally, the paper does not address the issue of interpretability, which can be an important consideration for some real-world applications. It would be valuable to explore ways of making the selected models more interpretable, perhaps by incorporating additional constraints or objectives into the model selection process.
Overall, the paper presents a compelling approach to automated model selection for tabular data and demonstrates its effectiveness on a variety of benchmark datasets. The insights and techniques discussed in this work could have significant implications for improving the efficiency and accessibility of machine learning in a wide range of domains.
Conclusion
This paper introduces an automated model selection approach for tabular data problems, with a focus on generalized linear models. The proposed method aims to automatically select the best-performing model from a set of candidate models, without requiring manual hyperparameter tuning.
The authors' evaluation shows that their approach is able to effectively identify the optimal model, often outperforming other automated techniques. This could have important implications for making machine learning more accessible and efficient, particularly in domains where tabular data is common.
While the current work is limited to generalized linear models, the authors discuss the potential for large language models to be used for automating feature engineering and model selection tasks, which could further enhance the capabilities of this type of approach.
Overall, this paper represents an important contribution to the field of automated machine learning, and the insights and techniques presented could be valuable for a wide range of real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📈
Automated Model Selection for Generalized Linear Models
Benjamin Schwendinger, Florian Schwendinger, Laura Vana-Gur
0
0
In this paper, we show how mixed-integer conic optimization can be used to combine feature subset selection with holistic generalized linear models to fully automate the model selection process. Concretely, we directly optimize for the Akaike and Bayesian information criteria while imposing constraints designed to deal with multicollinearity in the feature selection task. Specifically, we propose a novel pairwise correlation constraint that combines the sign coherence constraint with ideas from classical statistical models like Ridge regression and the OSCAR model.
4/26/2024
Enhancing Tabular Data Optimization with a Flexible Graph-based Reinforced Exploration Strategy
Xiaohan Huang, Dongjie Wang, Zhiyuan Ning, Ziyue Qiao, Qingqing Long, Haowei Zhu, Min Wu, Yuanchun Zhou, Meng Xiao
0
0
Tabular data optimization methods aim to automatically find an optimal feature transformation process that generates high-value features and improves the performance of downstream machine learning tasks. Current frameworks for automated feature transformation rely on iterative sequence generation tasks, optimizing decision strategies through performance feedback from downstream tasks. However, these approaches fail to effectively utilize historical decision-making experiences and overlook potential relationships among generated features, thus limiting the depth of knowledge extraction. Moreover, the granularity of the decision-making process lacks dynamic backtracking capabilities for individual features, leading to insufficient adaptability when encountering inefficient pathways, adversely affecting overall robustness and exploration efficiency. To address the limitations observed in current automatic feature engineering frameworks, we introduce a novel method that utilizes a feature-state transformation graph to effectively preserve the entire feature transformation journey, where each node represents a specific transformation state. During exploration, three cascading agents iteratively select nodes and idea mathematical operations to generate new transformation states. This strategy leverages the inherent properties of the graph structure, allowing for the preservation and reuse of valuable transformations. It also enables backtracking capabilities through graph pruning techniques, which can rectify inefficient transformation paths. To validate the efficacy and flexibility of our approach, we conducted comprehensive experiments and detailed case studies, demonstrating superior performance in diverse scenarios.
6/12/2024
🛸
An Automatic Prompt Generation System for Tabular Data Tasks
Ashlesha Akella, Abhijit Manatkar, Brij Chavda, Hima Patel
0
0
Efficient processing of tabular data is important in various industries, especially when working with datasets containing a large number of columns. Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated their ability on several tasks through carefully crafted prompts. However, creating effective prompts for tabular datasets is challenging due to the structured nature of the data and the need to manage numerous columns. This paper presents an innovative auto-prompt generation system suitable for multiple LLMs, with minimal training. It proposes two novel methods; 1) A Reinforcement Learning-based algorithm for identifying and sequencing task-relevant columns 2) Cell-level similarity-based approach for enhancing few-shot example selection. Our approach has been extensively tested across 66 datasets, demonstrating improved performance in three downstream tasks: data imputation, error detection, and entity matching using two distinct LLMs; Google flan-t5-xxl and Mixtral 8x7B.
5/10/2024
FeatNavigator: Automatic Feature Augmentation on Tabular Data
Jiaming Liang, Chuan Lei, Xiao Qin, Jiani Zhang, Asterios Katsifodimos, Christos Faloutsos, Huzefa Rangwala
0
0
Data-centric AI focuses on understanding and utilizing high-quality, relevant data in training machine learning (ML) models, thereby increasing the likelihood of producing accurate and useful results. Automatic feature augmentation, aiming to augment the initial base table with useful features from other tables, is critical in data preparation as it improves model performance, robustness, and generalizability. While recent works have investigated automatic feature augmentation, most of them have limited capabilities in utilizing all useful features as many of them are in candidate tables not directly joinable with the base table. Worse yet, with numerous join paths leading to these distant features, existing solutions fail to fully exploit them within a reasonable compute budget. We present FeatNavigator, an effective and efficient framework that explores and integrates high-quality features in relational tables for ML models. FeatNavigator evaluates a feature from two aspects: (1) the intrinsic value of a feature towards an ML task (i.e., feature importance) and (2) the efficacy of a join path connecting the feature to the base table (i.e., integration quality). FeatNavigator strategically selects a small set of available features and their corresponding join paths to train a feature importance estimation model and an integration quality prediction model. Furthermore, FeatNavigator's search algorithm exploits both estimated feature importance and integration quality to identify the optimized feature augmentation plan. Our experimental results show that FeatNavigator outperforms state-of-the-art solutions on five public datasets by up to 40.1% in ML model performance.
6/17/2024