Automating Knowledge Discovery from Scientific Literature via LLMs: A Dual-Agent Approach with Progressive Ontology Prompting
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Proposes a dual-agent approach with progressive ontology prompting to automate knowledge discovery from scientific literature using large language models (LLMs)
- Aims to enhance the understanding and reasoning capabilities of LLMs for complex scientific tasks
- Introduces a "Dual-Agent Ontology Prompting" framework that combines a knowledge-focused agent and a reasoning-focused agent
Plain English Explanation
The paper describes a new system that uses large language models to automatically extract and synthesize knowledge from scientific research papers. The key idea is to use two different "agents" or components that work together:
-
A knowledge-focused agent that can read the papers and understand the concepts, entities, and relationships described in them. This agent builds up a structured knowledge base or "ontology" over time.
-
A reasoning-focused agent that can then use this ontology to answer questions, make inferences, and discover new insights from the combined knowledge. This agent applies logical reasoning to the ontology.
The authors call this the "Dual-Agent Ontology Prompting" framework. The goal is to enhance the capabilities of language models to handle the complexity and nuance of scientific literature, going beyond just summarizing text to actually building an understanding of the domain.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a novel "Dual-Agent Ontology Prompting" approach for automating knowledge discovery from scientific literature using large language models (LLMs). The core idea is to combine a knowledge-focused agent and a reasoning-focused agent to enhance the understanding and reasoning capabilities of LLMs on complex scientific tasks.
The knowledge-focused agent is responsible for reading the scientific papers, extracting relevant concepts, entities, and relationships, and building a comprehensive ontology knowledge base. This agent uses ontology prompting techniques to gradually expand the ontology as more papers are processed.
The reasoning-focused agent then utilizes this ontology to answer questions, make inferences, and discover new insights. It applies logical reasoning and prompt-based reasoning to derive insights that go beyond just summarizing the text.
The authors evaluate their approach on a range of scientific literature tasks, including automated review generation and ontology-based chatbot interactions. The results demonstrate significant improvements in knowledge extraction, reasoning, and overall task performance compared to standard LLM baselines.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to enhancing the capabilities of large language models for scientific knowledge discovery. The dual-agent architecture with progressive ontology building is a novel contribution that addresses some of the limitations of existing LLM-based systems.
However, the authors acknowledge several key caveats and limitations. First, the ontology construction process is heavily dependent on the quality and coverage of the initial seed ontology. If this is incomplete or biased, it could lead to knowledge gaps or skewed reasoning. Further research is needed to explore more robust ontology initialization and expansion techniques.
Additionally, the reasoning-focused agent relies on prompt-based approaches, which can be sensitive to prompt design and may not generalize well to unseen tasks or domains. Exploring more advanced reasoning mechanisms, such as neural-symbolic integration or meta-learning, could help address this limitation.
Finally, the paper focuses on a limited set of evaluation tasks, and more comprehensive testing across a wider range of scientific disciplines and real-world applications would be necessary to fully assess the system's capabilities and practical impact.
Conclusion
The "Dual-Agent Ontology Prompting" framework proposed in this paper represents a significant step forward in automating knowledge discovery from scientific literature using large language models. By combining a knowledge-focused agent and a reasoning-focused agent, the system can build a comprehensive ontological understanding of a domain and then apply logical reasoning to derive new insights.
This approach holds great promise for enhancing the capabilities of LLMs in complex scientific tasks, potentially transforming how researchers and practitioners interact with and extract value from the ever-growing corpus of scientific knowledge. Further research and development in this area could lead to transformative advancements in fields such as scientific literature analysis, automated hypothesis generation, and intelligent decision support systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Automating Knowledge Discovery from Scientific Literature via LLMs: A Dual-Agent Approach with Progressive Ontology Prompting
Yuting Hu, Dancheng Liu, Qingyun Wang, Charles Yu, Heng Ji, Jinjun Xiong
To address the challenge of automating knowledge discovery from a vast volume of literature, in this paper, we introduce a novel framework based on large language models (LLMs) that combines a progressive ontology prompting (POP) algorithm with a dual-agent system, named LLM-Duo, designed to enhance the automation of knowledge extraction from scientific articles. The POP algorithm utilizes a prioritized breadth-first search (BFS) across a predefined ontology to generate structured prompt templates and action orders, thereby guiding LLMs to discover knowledge in an automatic manner. Additionally, our LLM-Duo employs two specialized LLM agents: an explorer and an evaluator. These two agents work collaboratively and adversarially to enhance the reliability of the discovery and annotation processes. Experiments demonstrate that our method outperforms advanced baselines, enabling more accurate and complete annotations. To validate the effectiveness of our method in real-world scenarios, we employ our method in a case study of speech-language intervention discovery. Our method identifies 2,421 interventions from 64,177 research articles in the speech-language therapy domain. We curate these findings into a publicly accessible intervention knowledge base that holds significant potential to benefit the speech-language therapy community.
Read more9/4/2024
0
New!Knowledge Tagging with Large Language Model based Multi-Agent System
Hang Li, Tianlong Xu, Ethan Chang, Qingsong Wen
Knowledge tagging for questions is vital in modern intelligent educational applications, including learning progress diagnosis, practice question recommendations, and course content organization. Traditionally, these annotations have been performed by pedagogical experts, as the task demands not only a deep semantic understanding of question stems and knowledge definitions but also a strong ability to link problem-solving logic with relevant knowledge concepts. With the advent of advanced natural language processing (NLP) algorithms, such as pre-trained language models and large language models (LLMs), pioneering studies have explored automating the knowledge tagging process using various machine learning models. In this paper, we investigate the use of a multi-agent system to address the limitations of previous algorithms, particularly in handling complex cases involving intricate knowledge definitions and strict numerical constraints. By demonstrating its superior performance on the publicly available math question knowledge tagging dataset, MathKnowCT, we highlight the significant potential of an LLM-based multi-agent system in overcoming the challenges that previous methods have encountered. Finally, through an in-depth discussion of the implications of automating knowledge tagging, we underscore the promising results of deploying LLM-based algorithms in educational contexts.
Read more9/16/2024
0
MLR-Copilot: Autonomous Machine Learning Research based on Large Language Models Agents
Ruochen Li, Teerth Patel, Qingyun Wang, Xinya Du
Machine learning research, crucial for technological advancements and innovation, often faces significant challenges due to its inherent complexity, slow pace of experimentation, and the necessity for specialized expertise. Motivated by this, we present a new systematic framework, autonomous Machine Learning Research with large language models (MLR-Copilot), designed to enhance machine learning research productivity through the automatic generation and implementation of research ideas using Large Language Model (LLM) agents. The framework consists of three phases: research idea generation, experiment implementation, and implementation execution. First, existing research papers are used to generate hypotheses and experimental plans vis IdeaAgent powered by LLMs. Next, the implementation generation phase translates these plans into executables with ExperimentAgent. This phase leverages retrieved prototype code and optionally retrieves candidate models and data. Finally, the execution phase, also managed by ExperimentAgent, involves running experiments with mechanisms for human feedback and iterative debugging to enhance the likelihood of achieving executable research outcomes. We evaluate our framework on five machine learning research tasks and the experimental results show the framework's potential to facilitate the research progress and innovations.
Read more9/4/2024
0
Chatbot-Based Ontology Interaction Using Large Language Models and Domain-Specific Standards
Jonathan Reif, Tom Jeleniewski, Milapji Singh Gill, Felix Gehlhoff, Alexander Fay
The following contribution introduces a concept that employs Large Language Models (LLMs) and a chatbot interface to enhance SPARQL query generation for ontologies, thereby facilitating intuitive access to formalized knowledge. Utilizing natural language inputs, the system converts user inquiries into accurate SPARQL queries that strictly query the factual content of the ontology, effectively preventing misinformation or fabrication by the LLM. To enhance the quality and precision of outcomes, additional textual information from established domain-specific standards is integrated into the ontology for precise descriptions of its concepts and relationships. An experimental study assesses the accuracy of generated SPARQL queries, revealing significant benefits of using LLMs for querying ontologies and highlighting areas for future research.
Read more8/6/2024