Bayesian identification of nonseparable Hamiltonians with multiplicative noise using deep learning and reduced-order modeling

Overview

• This paper presents a Bayesian approach for learning complex Hamiltonian systems from noisy data.
• The key aspects include a Gaussian filter for handling vector-valued, statistically-dependent noise, a novel algorithm for efficient Bayesian system identification, and the incorporation of structure-preserving methods.
• The approach is evaluated on both canonical and chaotic Hamiltonian models, demonstrating significant improvements over standard machine learning methods, especially in the presence of high levels of multiplicative noise.
• The method is also applied to a high-dimensional model of the nonlinear Schrödinger equation.

Plain English Explanation

Hamiltonian systems are a class of physical models that describe the motion of objects, such as planets or molecules, under the influence of forces. These systems can be very complex and difficult to learn from noisy or incomplete data.

This paper introduces a Bayesian approach for learning the structure of Hamiltonian systems from noisy measurements. The key idea is to incorporate prior knowledge about the underlying physics into the learning process, rather than treating the system as a black box.

The approach has three main components:

1. A specialized Gaussian filter that can handle complex, statistically-dependent noise in the measurements, including both additive and multiplicative types.
2. A novel algorithm that makes the Bayesian learning process more efficient, allowing it to scale to high-dimensional systems.
3. The ability to incorporate structure-preserving methods, which ensure that the learned model respects the underlying physical constraints of the Hamiltonian system.

By using this Bayesian approach, the researchers were able to achieve significant improvements in the accuracy of their models compared to standard machine learning methods, especially when dealing with highly noisy data. They demonstrated the effectiveness of their approach on both simple and chaotic Hamiltonian systems, as well as a high-dimensional model of a nonlinear quantum mechanical process.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a Bayesian framework for learning nonseparable Hamiltonian systems from vector-valued, statistically-dependent measurement data, which can include both additive and multiplicative noise.

The key technical contributions are:

1. Gaussian Filter: The authors derive a novel Gaussian filter that can handle the complex noise model, allowing for the accurate evaluation of the likelihood function within the Bayesian posterior.

2. Efficient Algorithm: They develop a novel algorithm for cost-effective application of Bayesian system identification to high-dimensional systems.

3. Structure Preservation: The framework incorporates structure-preserving methods, which ensure that the learned model respects the underlying physical constraints of the Hamiltonian system.

The performance of the method is evaluated on both a canonical nonseparable Hamiltonian model and a chaotic double pendulum model, using small, noisy training datasets. The results show that the Bayesian approach can yield up to 724 times improvement in Hamiltonian mean squared error compared to standard machine learning methods, especially in the presence of high levels of multiplicative noise.

The authors also demonstrate the utility of their algorithm on a 64-dimensional model of the spatially-discretized nonlinear Schrödinger equation, with data corrupted by up to 20% multiplicative noise.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a comprehensive and technically sound approach to learning Hamiltonian systems from noisy data. The incorporation of Bayesian methods and structure-preserving techniques is a promising direction, as it allows for the effective integration of physical domain knowledge into the learning process.

One potential limitation is the computational complexity of the proposed algorithm, especially for very high-dimensional systems. While the authors claim that their method is cost-effective, the scalability of the approach may still be a concern for some real-world applications.

Additionally, the paper does not explore the robustness of the method to model misspecification or the impact of prior distribution choices on the final results. It would be interesting to see how the approach performs when the underlying Hamiltonian structure is not known a priori or when there are uncertainties in the noise model.

Finally, the authors do not discuss the potential practical challenges in applying this method to real-world systems, such as the availability and quality of the required measurement data, or the potential implications of the learned models for decision-making or control problems.

Overall, this paper presents a valuable contribution to the field of Hamiltonian system identification, but further research may be needed to address some of the limitations and explore the practical applicability of the method.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel Bayesian approach for learning complex Hamiltonian systems from noisy, vector-valued data. The key innovations include a Gaussian filter for handling statistically-dependent noise, an efficient algorithm for Bayesian system identification, and the incorporation of structure-preserving methods.

The results demonstrate significant improvements in model accuracy compared to standard machine learning techniques, particularly in the presence of high levels of multiplicative noise. The method is shown to be effective on both canonical and chaotic Hamiltonian systems, as well as a high-dimensional model of the nonlinear Schrödinger equation.

This work represents an important step forward in the field of Hamiltonian system identification, with potential applications in physics, engineering, and beyond. By leveraging the underlying physical structure of these systems, the Bayesian approach offers a promising avenue for learning accurate models from limited and noisy data.