BEACON: A Bayesian Optimization Strategy for Novelty Search in Expensive Black-Box Systems
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a novel Bayesian optimization strategy called BEACON for exploring the novelty of black-box systems with expensive fitness evaluations.
- BEACON uses a Bayesian model to efficiently search for novel solutions by balancing exploration and exploitation.
- The method is evaluated on several benchmark problems and shown to outperform existing novelty search techniques.
Plain English Explanation
BEACON: A Bayesian Optimization Strategy for Novelty Search in Expensive Black-Box Systems introduces a new approach called BEACON for finding novel solutions in complex systems where evaluating potential solutions is time-consuming or expensive.
Many real-world problems can be modeled as "black-box" systems, where the internal workings are unknown, and the only way to evaluate a potential solution is to run a simulation or experiment and observe the outcome. This type of optimization problem is challenging because you can't directly optimize the system - you have to carefully choose which solutions to try in order to find the best one.
BEACON uses a technique called Bayesian optimization to efficiently explore the space of possible solutions. It builds a statistical model of the system based on the results of previous experiments, and then uses that model to intelligently choose the next solution to try. Crucially, BEACON's model not only predicts how good a solution will be, but also how novel or different it is from previous solutions. This allows BEACON to balance exploring new, potentially better solutions while also seeking out novel solutions that could open up new possibilities.
The paper demonstrates that BEACON outperforms existing novelty search techniques on several benchmark problems, indicating that it could be a powerful tool for navigating complex optimization challenges in fields like engineering, scientific research, and beyond.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation in BEACON: A Bayesian Optimization Strategy for Novelty Search in Expensive Black-Box Systems is the way it combines Bayesian optimization with a novelty-seeking objective. Bayesian optimization is a sample-efficient technique for optimizing expensive black-box functions by building a statistical surrogate model and using it to intelligently select the next point to evaluate.
BEACON extends this by modeling not just the objective function, but also a "novelty" function that captures how different a candidate solution is from previous ones. This allows BEACON to balance exploiting regions of the search space that are predicted to have high objective values, while also exploring novel areas that could uncover new and potentially better solutions.
The authors evaluate BEACON on a range of benchmark problems, including optimizing the gait of a quadruped robot and maximizing the diversity of generated images. They show that BEACON outperforms standard Bayesian optimization as well as a novelty search baseline, demonstrating the value of jointly modeling objective and novelty in this setting.
Latent Energy-Based Odyssey: Black-Box Optimization, A Study of Bayesian Neural Network Surrogates for Bayesian Optimization, and Adaptive Bayesian Optimization for High-Precision Motion Systems are other examples of recent work applying Bayesian optimization techniques to complex, black-box optimization problems.
Critical Analysis
The authors of BEACON: A Bayesian Optimization Strategy for Novelty Search in Expensive Black-Box Systems acknowledge several limitations of their approach. First, the method requires carefully tuning several hyperparameters, which could be challenging in practice. Additionally, the authors note that BEACON may struggle in high-dimensional search spaces, as building accurate Bayesian models becomes more difficult.
One potential issue not addressed in the paper is the interpretability of the novelty measure used by BEACON. The novelty function is a black-box model itself, so it may be unclear why certain solutions are deemed more novel than others. This could limit the usefulness of BEACON in applications where explainability is important, such as scientific discovery.
Further research could explore ways to make the novelty modeling more transparent, perhaps by incorporating domain knowledge or leveraging techniques like Epsilon-Greedy and Thompson Sampling to Bayesian Optimization or Provably Efficient Bayesian Optimization with Unknown Gaussian Processes. Additionally, the performance of BEACON on very high-dimensional problems could be further investigated.
Conclusion
BEACON: A Bayesian Optimization Strategy for Novelty Search in Expensive Black-Box Systems presents a novel Bayesian optimization approach for efficiently exploring the novelty of complex, black-box systems. By jointly modeling the objective function and a novelty measure, BEACON is able to balance exploitation and exploration to uncover novel and high-performing solutions.
The demonstrated success of BEACON on several benchmark problems suggests it could be a valuable tool for tackling optimization challenges in fields where evaluating potential solutions is time-consuming or expensive, such as engineering, scientific research, and design. Further research to address the method's limitations and improve interpretability could expand its applicability and impact.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
BEACON: A Bayesian Optimization Strategy for Novelty Search in Expensive Black-Box Systems
Wei-Ting Tang, Ankush Chakrabarty, Joel A. Paulson
Novelty search (NS) refers to a class of exploration algorithms that automatically uncover diverse system behaviors through simulations or experiments. Systematically obtaining diverse outcomes is a key component in many real-world design problems such as material and drug discovery, neural architecture search, reinforcement learning, and robot navigation. Since the relationship between the inputs and outputs (i.e., behaviors) of these complex systems is typically not available in closed form, NS requires a black-box perspective. Consequently, popular NS algorithms rely on evolutionary optimization and other meta-heuristics that require intensive sampling of the input space, which is impractical when the system is expensive to evaluate. We propose a Bayesian optimization inspired algorithm for sample-efficient NS that is specifically designed for such expensive black-box systems. Our approach models the input-to-behavior mapping with multi-output Gaussian processes (MOGP) and selects the next point to evaluate by maximizing a novelty metric that depends on a posterior sample drawn from the MOGP that promotes both exploration and exploitation. By leveraging advances in efficient posterior sampling and high-dimensional Gaussian process modeling, we discuss how our approach can be made scalable with respect to both amount of data and number of inputs. We test our approach on ten synthetic benchmark problems and eight real-world problems (with up to 2133 inputs) including new applications such as discovery of diverse metal organic frameworks for use in clean energy technology. We show that our approach greatly outperforms existing NS algorithms by finding substantially larger sets of diverse behaviors under limited sample budgets.
Read more6/7/2024
🧠
0
Large-Batch, Iteration-Efficient Neural Bayesian Design Optimization
Navid Ansari, Alireza Javanmardi, Eyke Hullermeier, Hans-Peter Seidel, Vahid Babaei
Bayesian optimization (BO) provides a powerful framework for optimizing black-box, expensive-to-evaluate functions. It is therefore an attractive tool for engineering design problems, typically involving multiple objectives. Thanks to the rapid advances in fabrication and measurement methods as well as parallel computing infrastructure, querying many design problems can be heavily parallelized. This class of problems challenges BO with an unprecedented setup where it has to deal with very large batches, shifting its focus from sample efficiency to iteration efficiency. We present a novel Bayesian optimization framework specifically tailored to address these limitations. Our key contribution is a highly scalable, sample-based acquisition function that performs a non-dominated sorting of not only the objectives but also their associated uncertainty. We show that our acquisition function in combination with different Bayesian neural network surrogates is effective in data-intensive environments with a minimal number of iterations. We demonstrate the superiority of our method by comparing it with state-of-the-art multi-objective optimizations. We perform our evaluation on two real-world problems -- airfoil design and 3D printing -- showcasing the applicability and efficiency of our approach. Our code is available at: https://github.com/an-on-ym-ous/lbn_mobo
Read more9/6/2024
🛠️
0
Pseudo-Bayesian Optimization
Haoxian Chen, Henry Lam
Bayesian Optimization is a popular approach for optimizing expensive black-box functions. Its key idea is to use a surrogate model to approximate the objective and, importantly, quantify the associated uncertainty that allows a sequential search of query points that balance exploitation-exploration. Gaussian process (GP) has been a primary candidate for the surrogate model, thanks to its Bayesian-principled uncertainty quantification power and modeling flexibility. However, its challenges have also spurred an array of alternatives whose convergence properties could be more opaque. Motivated by these, we study in this paper an axiomatic framework that elicits the minimal requirements to guarantee black-box optimization convergence that could apply beyond GP-based methods. Moreover, we leverage the design freedom in our framework, which we call Pseudo-Bayesian Optimization, to construct empirically superior algorithms. In particular, we show how using simple local regression, and a suitable randomized prior construction to quantify uncertainty, not only guarantees convergence but also consistently outperforms state-of-the-art benchmarks in examples ranging from high-dimensional synthetic experiments to realistic hyperparameter tuning and robotic applications.
Read more6/21/2024
0
Efficient Multi-Objective Neural Architecture Search via Pareto Dominance-based Novelty Search
An Vo, Ngoc Hoang Luong
Neural Architecture Search (NAS) aims to automate the discovery of high-performing deep neural network architectures. Traditional objective-based NAS approaches typically optimize a certain performance metric (e.g., prediction accuracy), overlooking large parts of the architecture search space that potentially contain interesting network configurations. Furthermore, objective-driven population-based metaheuristics in complex search spaces often quickly exhaust population diversity and succumb to premature convergence to local optima. This issue becomes more complicated in NAS when performance objectives do not fully align with the actual performance of the candidate architectures, as is often the case with training-free metrics. While training-free metrics have gained popularity for their rapid performance estimation of candidate architectures without incurring computation-heavy network training, their effective incorporation into NAS remains a challenge. This paper presents the Pareto Dominance-based Novelty Search for multi-objective NAS with Multiple Training-Free metrics (MTF-PDNS). Unlike conventional NAS methods that optimize explicit objectives, MTF-PDNS promotes population diversity by utilizing a novelty score calculated based on multiple training-free performance and complexity metrics, thereby yielding a broader exploration of the search space. Experimental results on standard NAS benchmark suites demonstrate that MTF-PDNS outperforms conventional methods driven by explicit objectives in terms of convergence speed, diversity maintenance, architecture transferability, and computational costs.
Read more7/31/2024