Benchmarking Deep Learning Architectures for Urban Vegetation Point Cloud Semantic Segmentation from MLS
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper focuses on benchmarking different deep learning architectures for segmenting urban vegetation points from mobile laser scanning data.
- Accurate identification of vegetation points is crucial for urban forest management and planning.
- The researchers compared the performance of several state-of-the-art deep learning models on a benchmark dataset.
Plain English Explanation
In this research, the authors wanted to find the best way to automatically identify vegetation points in 3D point cloud data collected from urban areas using mobile laser scanning technology. Accurately detecting vegetation is important for managing and planning urban forests, which provide many benefits like improving air quality, reducing urban heat, and enhancing the overall livability of cities.
The researchers tested several advanced deep learning models, which are a type of artificial intelligence algorithm that can learn to recognize patterns in data. They compared the performance of these models on a benchmark dataset, which is a standardized dataset that researchers use to evaluate and compare the capabilities of different algorithms.
By benchmarking these deep learning architectures, the authors aimed to identify the most effective approach for segmenting urban vegetation points from 3D point cloud data. This information can help urban planners and environmental managers develop better tools and strategies for managing and monitoring urban forests.
Technical Explanation
The authors evaluated the performance of several state-of-the-art deep learning architectures for the task of urban vegetation points segmentation, including PointNet, PointNet++, DGCNN, and RSNet. They used a benchmark dataset called OpenTrench3D, which contains 3D point cloud data of urban environments labeled with vegetation and other categories.
The researchers trained and evaluated the deep learning models on the OpenTrench3D dataset and compared their performance in terms of metrics like overall accuracy, F1-score, and IoU (Intersection over Union). They also analyzed the inference time and memory usage of the models to assess their practical applicability.
The results showed that the PointNet++ model achieved the best overall performance, with high accuracy and F1-scores for vegetation segmentation. The authors also found that the RSNet model had the fastest inference time, making it a good choice for real-time applications.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough evaluation of several state-of-the-art deep learning architectures for urban vegetation segmentation, which is a valuable contribution to the field. However, the authors acknowledge some limitations of their study, such as the relatively small size of the benchmark dataset and the fact that it only represents a specific urban environment.
To further strengthen the research, it would be helpful to evaluate the models on additional datasets representing diverse urban landscapes, as the performance of the algorithms may vary depending on the characteristics of the environment. Additionally, the authors could explore the robustness of the models to factors like varying point cloud density, occlusions, and seasonal changes in vegetation.
Another potential area for improvement is the incorporation of additional contextual information, such as aerial imagery or GIS data, which could potentially enhance the segmentation accuracy. The authors could also investigate the transferability of the trained models to other urban areas, which would be crucial for the practical deployment of these techniques.
Conclusion
This study provides a comprehensive benchmark of deep learning architectures for urban vegetation points segmentation, with the PointNet++ model emerging as the top performer. The insights gained from this research can inform the development of more accurate and efficient tools for urban forest management and planning.
By leveraging advanced deep learning techniques, urban planners and environmental managers can better monitor and maintain urban vegetation, which is essential for improving the liveability and sustainability of cities. The findings of this work can be further built upon to create more robust and versatile solutions for urban vegetation segmentation, ultimately contributing to the sustainable development of urban environments.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Benchmarking Deep Learning Architectures for Urban Vegetation Point Cloud Semantic Segmentation from MLS
Aditya Aditya, Bharat Lohani, Jagannath Aryal, Stephan Winter
Vegetation is crucial for sustainable and resilient cities providing various ecosystem services and well-being of humans. However, vegetation is under critical stress with rapid urbanization and expanding infrastructure footprints. Consequently, mapping of this vegetation is essential in the urban environment. Recently, deep learning for point cloud semantic segmentation has shown significant progress. Advanced models attempt to obtain state-of-the-art performance on benchmark datasets, comprising multiple classes and representing real world scenarios. However, class specific segmentation with respect to vegetation points has not been explored. Therefore, selection of a deep learning model for vegetation points segmentation is ambiguous. To address this problem, we provide a comprehensive assessment of point-based deep learning models for semantic segmentation of vegetation class. We have selected seven representative point-based models, namely PointCNN, KPConv (omni-supervised), RandLANet, SCFNet, PointNeXt, SPoTr and PointMetaBase. These models are investigated on three different datasets, specifically Chandigarh, Toronto3D and Kerala, which are characterized by diverse nature of vegetation and varying scene complexity combined with changing per-point features and class-wise composition. PointMetaBase and KPConv (omni-supervised) achieve the highest mIoU on the Chandigarh (95.24%) and Toronto3D datasets (91.26%), respectively while PointCNN provides the highest mIoU on the Kerala dataset (85.68%). The paper develops a deeper insight, hitherto not reported, into the working of these models for vegetation segmentation and outlines the ingredients that should be included in a model specifically for vegetation segmentation. This paper is a step towards the development of a novel architecture for vegetation points segmentation.
Read more5/2/2024
🤿
0
A comprehensive overview of deep learning techniques for 3D point cloud classification and semantic segmentation
Sushmita Sarker, Prithul Sarker, Gunner Stone, Ryan Gorman, Alireza Tavakkoli, George Bebis, Javad Sattarvand
Point cloud analysis has a wide range of applications in many areas such as computer vision, robotic manipulation, and autonomous driving. While deep learning has achieved remarkable success on image-based tasks, there are many unique challenges faced by deep neural networks in processing massive, unordered, irregular and noisy 3D points. To stimulate future research, this paper analyzes recent progress in deep learning methods employed for point cloud processing and presents challenges and potential directions to advance this field. It serves as a comprehensive review on two major tasks in 3D point cloud processing-- namely, 3D shape classification and semantic segmentation.
Read more5/21/2024
🤿
0
Deep Learning-Based 3D Instance and Semantic Segmentation: A Review
Siddiqui Muhammad Yasir, Hyunsik Ahn
The process of segmenting point cloud data into several homogeneous areas with points in the same region having the same attributes is known as 3D segmentation. Segmentation is challenging with point cloud data due to substantial redundancy, fluctuating sample density and lack of apparent organization. The research area has a wide range of robotics applications, including intelligent vehicles, autonomous mapping and navigation. A number of researchers have introduced various methodologies and algorithms. Deep learning has been successfully used to a spectrum of 2D vision domains as a prevailing A.I. methods. However, due to the specific problems of processing point clouds with deep neural networks, deep learning on point clouds is still in its initial stages. This study examines many strategies that have been presented to 3D instance and semantic segmentation and gives a complete assessment of current developments in deep learning-based 3D segmentation. In these approaches benefits, draw backs, and design mechanisms are studied and addressed. This study evaluates the impact of various segmentation algorithms on competitiveness on various publicly accessible datasets, as well as the most often used pipelines, their advantages and limits, insightful findings and intriguing future research directions.
Read more6/21/2024
0
Training point-based deep learning networks for forest segmentation with synthetic data
Francisco Raverta Capua, Juan Schandin, Pablo De Crist'oforis
Remote sensing through unmanned aerial systems (UAS) has been increasing in forestry in recent years, along with using machine learning for data processing. Deep learning architectures, extensively applied in natural language and image processing, have recently been extended to the point cloud domain. However, the availability of point cloud datasets for training and testing remains limited. Creating forested environment point cloud datasets is expensive, requires high-precision sensors, and is time-consuming as manual point classification is required. Moreover, forest areas could be inaccessible or dangerous for humans, further complicating data collection. Then, a question arises whether it is possible to use synthetic data to train deep learning networks without the need to rely on large volumes of real forest data. To answer this question, we developed a realistic simulator that procedurally generates synthetic forest scenes. Thanks to this, we have conducted a comparative study of different state-of-the-art point-based deep learning networks for forest segmentation. Using created datasets, we determined the feasibility of using synthetic data to train deep learning networks to classify point clouds from real forest datasets. Both the simulator and the datasets are released as part of this work.
Read more4/19/2024