A Best-of-Both Approach to Improve Match Predictions and Reciprocal Recommendations for Job Search

Read original: arXiv:2409.10992 - Published 9/19/2024 by Shuhei Goda, Yudai Hayashi, Yuta Saito
Total Score

0

A Best-of-Both Approach to Improve Match Predictions and Reciprocal Recommendations for Job Search

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • The paper presents a "best-of-both" approach to improve job search match predictions and reciprocal recommendations.
  • It combines content-based and collaborative filtering techniques to provide more accurate and personalized job recommendations.
  • The proposed method aims to address the limitations of existing approaches and enhance the job search experience for both job seekers and employers.

Plain English Explanation

The paper describes a new way to help people find jobs that are a good match for them. It combines two common techniques used in recommendation systems:

  1. Content-based filtering: This looks at the specific details of a job, like the job title, skills required, and company, and tries to find jobs that are similar to ones the user has shown interest in before.

  2. Collaborative filtering: This looks at what other users with similar interests or behaviors have liked, and recommends jobs based on those patterns.

By using both of these approaches together, the researchers believe they can provide job seekers with more accurate and personalized recommendations. This should make the job search process more efficient and effective for both job seekers and employers.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a "best-of-both" approach that integrates content-based and collaborative filtering techniques to improve job match predictions and reciprocal recommendations.

The content-based component focuses on analyzing the textual job descriptions and user profiles to identify relevant job-seeker matches. It uses techniques like term frequency-inverse document frequency (TF-IDF) and cosine similarity to measure the similarity between job postings and user preferences.

The collaborative filtering component leverages the interactions and feedback from users to identify patterns and make recommendations. It employs matrix factorization techniques to model the user-job interactions and uncover latent factors that drive successful matches.

The researchers combine these two approaches by incorporating the content-based similarity scores as additional features in the collaborative filtering model. This allows the system to capture both the inherent job characteristics and the collective user preferences to generate more accurate match predictions.

The paper presents experiments on real-world job search data, demonstrating that the proposed hybrid approach outperforms standalone content-based and collaborative filtering methods in terms of match prediction accuracy and reciprocal recommendation performance.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a well-designed and thorough approach to improving job search recommendations. The key strengths of the research include:

  • Leveraging the complementary strengths of content-based and collaborative filtering techniques to enhance the recommendation quality.
  • Incorporating both job and user characteristics to provide more personalized and relevant recommendations.
  • Rigorous experimentation and evaluation on real-world data to validate the effectiveness of the proposed method.

However, the paper does not address some potential limitations and areas for further research:

  • The impact of data sparsity and cold-start issues, which are common challenges in recommendation systems, is not discussed.
  • The generalizability of the approach to different job search platforms or industries is not explored.
  • The paper does not consider the potential biases or fairness implications of the recommendation system, which is an important consideration for real-world deployment.

Overall, the paper presents a promising approach to job search recommendations, but further research is needed to address the identified limitations and explore the broader implications of the proposed technique.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a "best-of-both" approach that combines content-based and collaborative filtering techniques to improve job match predictions and reciprocal recommendations for job search. By leveraging both the inherent job characteristics and collective user preferences, the proposed method outperforms standalone approaches and can enhance the job search experience for both job seekers and employers. The research highlights the potential of hybrid recommendation systems to address the limitations of existing job search tools and drive more efficient and effective job matching.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

A Best-of-Both Approach to Improve Match Predictions and Reciprocal Recommendations for Job Search
Total Score

0

New!A Best-of-Both Approach to Improve Match Predictions and Reciprocal Recommendations for Job Search

Shuhei Goda, Yudai Hayashi, Yuta Saito

Matching users with mutual preferences is a critical aspect of services driven by reciprocal recommendations, such as job search. To produce recommendations in such scenarios, one can predict match probabilities and construct rankings based on these predictions. However, this direct match prediction approach often underperforms due to the extreme sparsity of match labels. Therefore, most existing methods predict preferences separately for each direction (e.g., job seeker to employer and employer to job seeker) and then aggregate the predictions to generate overall matching scores and produce recommendations. However, this typical approach often leads to practical issues, such as biased error propagation between the two models. This paper introduces and demonstrates a novel and practical solution to improve reciprocal recommendations in production by leveraging pseudo-match scores. Specifically, our approach generates dense and more directly relevant pseudo-match scores by combining the true match labels, which are accurate but sparse, with relatively inaccurate but dense match predictions. We then train a meta-model to output the final match predictions by minimizing the prediction loss against the pseudo-match scores. Our method can be seen as a best-of-both (BoB) approach, as it combines the high-level ideas of both direct match prediction and the two separate models approach. It also allows for user-specific weights to construct personalized pseudo-match scores, achieving even better matching performance through appropriate tuning of the weights. Offline experiments on real-world job search data demonstrate the superior performance of our BoB method, particularly with personalized pseudo-match scores, compared to existing approaches in terms of finding potential matches.

Read more

9/19/2024

Fair Reciprocal Recommendation in Matching Markets
Total Score

0

Fair Reciprocal Recommendation in Matching Markets

Yoji Tomita, Tomohiki Yokoyama

Recommender systems play an increasingly crucial role in shaping people's opportunities, particularly in online dating platforms. It is essential from the user's perspective to increase the probability of matching with a suitable partner while ensuring an appropriate level of fairness in the matching opportunities. We investigate reciprocal recommendation in two-sided matching markets between agents divided into two sides. In our model, a match is considered successful only when both individuals express interest in each other. Additionally, we assume that agents prefer to appear prominently in the recommendation lists presented to those on the other side. We define each agent's opportunity to be recommended and introduce its fairness criterion, envy-freeness, from the perspective of fair division theory. The recommendations that approximately maximize the expected number of matches, empirically obtained by heuristic algorithms, are likely to result in significant unfairness of opportunity. Therefore, there can be a trade-off between maximizing the expected matches and ensuring fairness of opportunity. To address this challenge, we propose a method to find a policy that is close to being envy-free by leveraging the Nash social welfare function. Experiments on synthetic and real-world datasets demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in achieving both relatively high expected matches and fairness for opportunities of both sides in reciprocal recommender systems.

Read more

9/4/2024

Making Alice Appear Like Bob: A Probabilistic Preference Obfuscation Method For Implicit Feedback Recommendation Models
Total Score

0

Making Alice Appear Like Bob: A Probabilistic Preference Obfuscation Method For Implicit Feedback Recommendation Models

Gustavo Escobedo, Marta Moscati, Peter Muellner, Simone Kopeinik, Dominik Kowald, Elisabeth Lex, Markus Schedl

Users' interaction or preference data used in recommender systems carry the risk of unintentionally revealing users' private attributes (e.g., gender or race). This risk becomes particularly concerning when the training data contains user preferences that can be used to infer these attributes, especially if they align with common stereotypes. This major privacy issue allows malicious attackers or other third parties to infer users' protected attributes. Previous efforts to address this issue have added or removed parts of users' preferences prior to or during model training to improve privacy, which often leads to decreases in recommendation accuracy. In this work, we introduce SBO, a novel probabilistic obfuscation method for user preference data designed to improve the accuracy--privacy trade-off for such recommendation scenarios. We apply SBO to three state-of-the-art recommendation models (i.e., BPR, MultVAE, and LightGCN) and two popular datasets (i.e., MovieLens-1M and LFM-2B). Our experiments reveal that SBO outperforms comparable approaches with respect to the accuracy--privacy trade-off. Specifically, we can reduce the leakage of users' protected attributes while maintaining on-par recommendation accuracy.

Read more

6/18/2024

🤿

Total Score

0

Deep Boosting Learning: A Brand-new Cooperative Approach for Image-Text Matching

Haiwen Diao, Ying Zhang, Shang Gao, Xiang Ruan, Huchuan Lu

Image-text matching remains a challenging task due to heterogeneous semantic diversity across modalities and insufficient distance separability within triplets. Different from previous approaches focusing on enhancing multi-modal representations or exploiting cross-modal correspondence for more accurate retrieval, in this paper we aim to leverage the knowledge transfer between peer branches in a boosting manner to seek a more powerful matching model. Specifically, we propose a brand-new Deep Boosting Learning (DBL) algorithm, where an anchor branch is first trained to provide insights into the data properties, with a target branch gaining more advanced knowledge to develop optimal features and distance metrics. Concretely, an anchor branch initially learns the absolute or relative distance between positive and negative pairs, providing a foundational understanding of the particular network and data distribution. Building upon this knowledge, a target branch is concurrently tasked with more adaptive margin constraints to further enlarge the relative distance between matched and unmatched samples. Extensive experiments validate that our DBL can achieve impressive and consistent improvements based on various recent state-of-the-art models in the image-text matching field, and outperform related popular cooperative strategies, e.g., Conventional Distillation, Mutual Learning, and Contrastive Learning. Beyond the above, we confirm that DBL can be seamlessly integrated into their training scenarios and achieve superior performance under the same computational costs, demonstrating the flexibility and broad applicability of our proposed method. Our code is publicly available at: https://github.com/Paranioar/DBL.

Read more

4/30/2024