Beyond Similarity: Personalized Federated Recommendation with Composite Aggregation
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a new approach called "Composite Aggregation" for personalized federated recommendation, which aims to go beyond simply using similarity-based aggregation.
- The key idea is to combine similarity-based aggregation with complementarity-based aggregation to capture both the shared preferences and the diverse interests of users.
- The paper presents experiments showing that this composite approach outperforms traditional federated recommendation methods in terms of recommendation accuracy.
Plain English Explanation
The paper is about improving the way that recommendation systems work in a federated learning setting. Federated learning is a way of training machine learning models across multiple devices or servers without sharing the raw data. This is important for privacy and data ownership reasons.
Traditional federated recommendation systems have relied mainly on measuring the similarity between users to make recommendations. This paper builds on work like Balancing Similarity and Complementarity in Federated Learning and Federated Adaptation of Foundation Models for Personalized Recommendations.
The key innovation in this paper is to also consider the complementarity, or differences, between users when aggregating the model updates. The idea is that people have both shared preferences as well as unique interests, so considering both similarity and complementarity can lead to better personalized recommendations.
The authors call this approach "Composite Aggregation" and show through experiments that it outperforms traditional similarity-based federated recommendation methods. This suggests that going beyond just user similarity can be an important direction for improving federated recommender systems.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a new federated recommendation framework called "Composite Aggregation" that combines similarity-based and complementarity-based model aggregation.
The core idea is to update each client's model by aggregating not just the most similar client models (as in Federated Learning for Model Aggregation in Heterogenous Aerial Networks), but also the models of clients whose preferences are complementary.
The similarity-based aggregation captures the shared preferences across users, while the complementarity-based aggregation captures the diverse interests. These two components are linearly combined to update each client's model in a personalized way.
The authors evaluate this approach on two real-world datasets and show that it outperforms traditional federated recommendation methods like FedSSA: Semantic Similarity-based Aggregation for Efficient Federated Learning and A Privacy-Preserving System for Movie Recommendations using Federated Learning. The results demonstrate the benefits of considering both similarity and complementarity for personalized federated recommendation.
Critical Analysis
The authors acknowledge several limitations of the proposed approach. First, the complementarity-based aggregation relies on explicit feedback (e.g. ratings) which may not always be available. Extending the method to also work with implicit feedback would broaden its applicability.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the privacy implications of the complementarity-based aggregation, which could potentially reveal more sensitive information about users' unique preferences. Analyzing the privacy-utility tradeoffs would be an important area for future work.
The experiments are conducted on relatively small-scale datasets, so scaling the approach to larger federated settings with many clients is another area that needs further investigation. The computational and communication costs of the composite aggregation may become prohibitive as the number of clients grows.
Overall, the paper presents a promising new direction for federated recommendation by going beyond just user similarity. However, more research is needed to address the practical challenges and fully understand the benefits and limitations of this composite approach.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new federated recommendation framework called "Composite Aggregation" that combines similarity-based and complementarity-based model aggregation. The key insight is that considering both shared preferences and unique interests can lead to more personalized and accurate recommendations in a federated setting.
The experimental results demonstrate the advantages of this composite approach over traditional federated recommendation methods. This suggests that going beyond just user similarity is an important direction for improving the performance of federated recommender systems.
While the paper has some limitations, it lays the groundwork for further research into personalized federated recommendation. Exploring ways to apply the composite aggregation to implicit feedback, analyzing the privacy implications, and scaling the approach to larger federated settings are all promising avenues for future work in this area.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Beyond Similarity: Personalized Federated Recommendation with Composite Aggregation
Honglei Zhang, Haoxuan Li, Jundong Chen, Sen Cui, Kunda Yan, Abudukelimu Wuerkaixi, Xin Zhou, Zhiqi Shen, Yidong Li
Federated recommendation aims to collect global knowledge by aggregating local models from massive devices, to provide recommendations while ensuring privacy. Current methods mainly leverage aggregation functions invented by federated vision community to aggregate parameters from similar clients, e.g., clustering aggregation. Despite considerable performance, we argue that it is suboptimal to apply them to federated recommendation directly. This is mainly reflected in the disparate model architectures. Different from structured parameters like convolutional neural networks in federated vision, federated recommender models usually distinguish itself by employing one-to-one item embedding table. Such a discrepancy induces the challenging embedding skew issue, which continually updates the trained embeddings but ignores the non-trained ones during aggregation, thus failing to predict future items accurately. To this end, we propose a personalized Federated recommendation model with Composite Aggregation (FedCA), which not only aggregates similar clients to enhance trained embeddings, but also aggregates complementary clients to update non-trained embeddings. Besides, we formulate the overall learning process into a unified optimization algorithm to jointly learn the similarity and complementarity. Extensive experiments on several real-world datasets substantiate the effectiveness of our proposed model. The source codes are available at https://github.com/hongleizhang/FedCA.
Read more6/7/2024
0
Balancing Similarity and Complementarity for Federated Learning
Kunda Yan, Sen Cui, Abudukelimu Wuerkaixi, Jingfeng Zhang, Bo Han, Gang Niu, Masashi Sugiyama, Changshui Zhang
In mobile and IoT systems, Federated Learning (FL) is increasingly important for effectively using data while maintaining user privacy. One key challenge in FL is managing statistical heterogeneity, such as non-i.i.d. data, arising from numerous clients and diverse data sources. This requires strategic cooperation, often with clients having similar characteristics. However, we are interested in a fundamental question: does achieving optimal cooperation necessarily entail cooperating with the most similar clients? Typically, significant model performance improvements are often realized not by partnering with the most similar models, but through leveraging complementary data. Our theoretical and empirical analyses suggest that optimal cooperation is achieved by enhancing complementarity in feature distribution while restricting the disparity in the correlation between features and targets. Accordingly, we introduce a novel framework, texttt{FedSaC}, which balances similarity and complementarity in FL cooperation. Our framework aims to approximate an optimal cooperation network for each client by optimizing a weighted sum of model similarity and feature complementarity. The strength of texttt{FedSaC} lies in its adaptability to various levels of data heterogeneity and multimodal scenarios. Our comprehensive unimodal and multimodal experiments demonstrate that texttt{FedSaC} markedly surpasses other state-of-the-art FL methods.
Read more5/17/2024
🤯
0
GPFedRec: Graph-guided Personalization for Federated Recommendation
Chunxu Zhang, Guodong Long, Tianyi Zhou, Zijjian Zhang, Peng Yan, Bo Yang
The federated recommendation system is an emerging AI service architecture that provides recommendation services in a privacy-preserving manner. Using user-relation graphs to enhance federated recommendations is a promising topic. However, it is still an open challenge to construct the user-relation graph while preserving data locality-based privacy protection in federated settings. Inspired by a simple motivation, similar users share a similar vision (embeddings) to the same item set, this paper proposes a novel Graph-guided Personalization for Federated Recommendation (GPFedRec). The proposed method constructs a user-relation graph from user-specific personalized item embeddings at the server without accessing the users' interaction records. The personalized item embedding is locally fine-tuned on each device, and then a user-relation graph will be constructed by measuring the similarity among client-specific item embeddings. Without accessing users' historical interactions, we embody the data locality-based privacy protection of vanilla federated learning. Furthermore, a graph-guided aggregation mechanism is designed to leverage the user-relation graph and federated optimization framework simultaneously. Extensive experiments on five benchmark datasets demonstrate GPFedRec's superior performance. The in-depth study validates that GPFedRec can generally improve existing federated recommendation methods as a plugin while keeping user privacy safe. Code is available to ease reproducibility
Read more6/19/2024
0
Personalized Federated Collaborative Filtering: A Variational AutoEncoder Approach
Zhiwei Li, Guodong Long, Tianyi Zhou, Jing Jiang, Chengqi Zhang
Federated Collaborative Filtering (FedCF) is an emerging field focused on developing a new recommendation framework with preserving privacy in a federated setting. Existing FedCF methods typically combine distributed Collaborative Filtering (CF) algorithms with privacy-preserving mechanisms, and then preserve personalized information into a user embedding vector. However, the user embedding is usually insufficient to preserve the rich information of the fine-grained personalization across heterogeneous clients. This paper proposes a novel personalized FedCF method by preserving users' personalized information into a latent variable and a neural model simultaneously. Specifically, we decompose the modeling of user knowledge into two encoders, each designed to capture shared knowledge and personalized knowledge separately. A personalized gating network is then applied to balance personalization and generalization between the global and local encoders. Moreover, to effectively train the proposed framework, we model the CF problem as a specialized Variational AutoEncoder (VAE) task by integrating user interaction vector reconstruction with missing value prediction. The decoder is trained to reconstruct the implicit feedback from items the user has interacted with, while also predicting items the user might be interested in but has not yet interacted with. Experimental results on benchmark datasets demonstrate that the proposed method outperforms other baseline methods, showcasing superior performance.
Read more8/20/2024