Balancing Similarity and Complementarity for Federated Learning
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores balancing the tradeoff between similarity and complementarity in federated learning, where multiple clients collaborate to train a shared model without sharing their private data.
- The authors propose a novel algorithm called FedSAC that adaptively adjusts the similarity and complementarity of client updates during the federated learning process.
- FedSAC aims to improve the performance and efficiency of federated learning by leveraging both the benefits of similar clients and the additional information from complementary clients.
Plain English Explanation
The paper is about a challenge in federated learning, which is a way for multiple organizations or devices to train a shared machine learning model together without sharing their private data. The challenge is finding the right balance between using data that is similar (so the model can learn efficiently) and data that is different (so the model can learn a more comprehensive set of patterns).
The authors propose a new approach called FedSAC that automatically adjusts this balance during the training process. It tries to group similar clients together to leverage their shared knowledge, but also includes some clients with different data to capture additional useful information. By dynamically managing this tradeoff, FedSAC aims to improve the overall performance and efficiency of the federated learning system.
This is an important problem because federated learning is becoming increasingly important as organizations and devices want to collaborate on AI models without compromising privacy. Techniques like FedSSA and FedCCL have also explored this balance, but FedSAC takes a new approach.
Technical Explanation
The key idea behind FedSAC is to balance the similarity and complementarity of clients participating in the federated learning process. Specifically, the authors propose:
- A client clustering mechanism that groups clients based on the similarity of their local models. This allows FedSAC to leverage the knowledge from similar clients.
- An adaptive aggregation rule that adjusts the weights given to client updates based on their similarity and complementarity. This allows FedSAC to balance the contributions from similar and complementary clients.
The authors evaluate FedSAC on several benchmark federated learning datasets and show that it outperforms other state-of-the-art approaches, such as Universal Metric and FedAC, in terms of both model performance and communication efficiency.
Critical Analysis
The authors acknowledge that FedSAC relies on the assumption that client data can be meaningfully clustered based on the similarity of their local models. In some real-world scenarios, this may not always be the case, and the clustering process may not accurately capture the underlying data distributions.
Additionally, the authors do not provide a thorough analysis of the computational and memory overhead introduced by the client clustering and adaptive aggregation mechanisms in FedSAC. These additional processing steps could impact the overall efficiency of the federated learning system, especially in resource-constrained environments.
Further research could explore techniques to make the client clustering more robust, such as incorporating additional client metadata or using advanced clustering algorithms. Investigating the scalability and practical deployment of FedSAC in large-scale federated learning scenarios would also be valuable.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach called FedSAC that aims to balance the tradeoff between similarity and complementarity in federated learning. By adaptively adjusting the contributions of similar and complementary clients, FedSAC can improve the performance and efficiency of the federated learning process.
The authors' insights on the importance of managing this similarity-complementarity tradeoff are valuable, and the FedSAC algorithm provides a promising direction for further research in this area. As federated learning becomes more prevalent, techniques like FedSAC will be crucial for enabling effective and privacy-preserving collaborative AI systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Balancing Similarity and Complementarity for Federated Learning
Kunda Yan, Sen Cui, Abudukelimu Wuerkaixi, Jingfeng Zhang, Bo Han, Gang Niu, Masashi Sugiyama, Changshui Zhang
In mobile and IoT systems, Federated Learning (FL) is increasingly important for effectively using data while maintaining user privacy. One key challenge in FL is managing statistical heterogeneity, such as non-i.i.d. data, arising from numerous clients and diverse data sources. This requires strategic cooperation, often with clients having similar characteristics. However, we are interested in a fundamental question: does achieving optimal cooperation necessarily entail cooperating with the most similar clients? Typically, significant model performance improvements are often realized not by partnering with the most similar models, but through leveraging complementary data. Our theoretical and empirical analyses suggest that optimal cooperation is achieved by enhancing complementarity in feature distribution while restricting the disparity in the correlation between features and targets. Accordingly, we introduce a novel framework, texttt{FedSaC}, which balances similarity and complementarity in FL cooperation. Our framework aims to approximate an optimal cooperation network for each client by optimizing a weighted sum of model similarity and feature complementarity. The strength of texttt{FedSaC} lies in its adaptability to various levels of data heterogeneity and multimodal scenarios. Our comprehensive unimodal and multimodal experiments demonstrate that texttt{FedSaC} markedly surpasses other state-of-the-art FL methods.
Read more5/17/2024
0
Algorithms for Collaborative Machine Learning under Statistical Heterogeneity
Seok-Ju Hahn
Learning from distributed data without accessing them is undoubtedly a challenging and non-trivial task. Nevertheless, the necessity for distributed training of a statistical model has been increasing, due to the privacy concerns of local data owners and the cost in centralizing the massively distributed data. Federated learning (FL) is currently the de facto standard of training a machine learning model across heterogeneous data owners, without leaving the raw data out of local silos. Nevertheless, several challenges must be addressed in order for FL to be more practical in reality. Among these challenges, the statistical heterogeneity problem is the most significant and requires immediate attention. From the main objective of FL, three major factors can be considered as starting points -- textit{parameter}, textit{mixing coefficient}, and textit{local data distributions}. In alignment with the components, this dissertation is organized into three parts. In Chapter II, a novel personalization method, texttt{SuPerFed}, inspired by the mode-connectivity is introduced. In Chapter III, an adaptive decision-making algorithm, texttt{AAggFF}, is introduced for inducing uniform performance distributions in participating clients, which is realized by online convex optimization framework. Finally, in Chapter IV, a collaborative synthetic data generation method, texttt{FedEvg}, is introduced, leveraging the flexibility and compositionality of an energy-based modeling approach. Taken together, all of these approaches provide practical solutions to mitigate the statistical heterogeneity problem in data-decentralized settings, paving the way for distributed systems and applications using collaborative machine learning methods.
Read more8/2/2024
0
Beyond Similarity: Personalized Federated Recommendation with Composite Aggregation
Honglei Zhang, Haoxuan Li, Jundong Chen, Sen Cui, Kunda Yan, Abudukelimu Wuerkaixi, Xin Zhou, Zhiqi Shen, Yidong Li
Federated recommendation aims to collect global knowledge by aggregating local models from massive devices, to provide recommendations while ensuring privacy. Current methods mainly leverage aggregation functions invented by federated vision community to aggregate parameters from similar clients, e.g., clustering aggregation. Despite considerable performance, we argue that it is suboptimal to apply them to federated recommendation directly. This is mainly reflected in the disparate model architectures. Different from structured parameters like convolutional neural networks in federated vision, federated recommender models usually distinguish itself by employing one-to-one item embedding table. Such a discrepancy induces the challenging embedding skew issue, which continually updates the trained embeddings but ignores the non-trained ones during aggregation, thus failing to predict future items accurately. To this end, we propose a personalized Federated recommendation model with Composite Aggregation (FedCA), which not only aggregates similar clients to enhance trained embeddings, but also aggregates complementary clients to update non-trained embeddings. Besides, we formulate the overall learning process into a unified optimization algorithm to jointly learn the similarity and complementarity. Extensive experiments on several real-world datasets substantiate the effectiveness of our proposed model. The source codes are available at https://github.com/hongleizhang/FedCA.
Read more6/7/2024
0
FedClust: Tackling Data Heterogeneity in Federated Learning through Weight-Driven Client Clustering
Md Sirajul Islam, Simin Javaherian, Fei Xu, Xu Yuan, Li Chen, Nian-Feng Tzeng
Federated learning (FL) is an emerging distributed machine learning paradigm that enables collaborative training of machine learning models over decentralized devices without exposing their local data. One of the major challenges in FL is the presence of uneven data distributions across client devices, violating the well-known assumption of independent-and-identically-distributed (IID) training samples in conventional machine learning. To address the performance degradation issue incurred by such data heterogeneity, clustered federated learning (CFL) shows its promise by grouping clients into separate learning clusters based on the similarity of their local data distributions. However, state-of-the-art CFL approaches require a large number of communication rounds to learn the distribution similarities during training until the formation of clusters is stabilized. Moreover, some of these algorithms heavily rely on a predefined number of clusters, thus limiting their flexibility and adaptability. In this paper, we propose {em FedClust}, a novel approach for CFL that leverages the correlation between local model weights and the data distribution of clients. {em FedClust} groups clients into clusters in a one-shot manner by measuring the similarity degrees among clients based on the strategically selected partial weights of locally trained models. We conduct extensive experiments on four benchmark datasets with different non-IID data settings. Experimental results demonstrate that {em FedClust} achieves higher model accuracy up to $sim$45% as well as faster convergence with a significantly reduced communication cost up to 2.7$times$ compared to its state-of-the-art counterparts.
Read more7/11/2024