Conditional Generative Representation for Black-Box Optimization with Implicit Constraints
0
🛠️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Black-box optimization (BBO) is a powerful technique for tackling complex decision-making problems, including those in public policy domains like police districting.
- However, its broader application has been hindered by the difficulty of defining feasible regions and the high-dimensionality of decisions.
- This paper introduces a novel BBO framework called Conditional And Generative Black-box Optimization (CageBO) that aims to address these challenges.
Plain English Explanation
The paper presents a new approach called CageBO that makes it easier to use black-box optimization for complex public policy problems. Black-box optimization is a technique that can find good solutions without needing to fully understand how the problem works under the hood.
However, real-world policy problems often have a lot of constraints that make it difficult to use black-box optimization effectively. The CageBO method solves this by using a type of neural network called a conditional variational autoencoder to learn the distribution of feasible decisions. This allows the optimization to happen in a simplified, constraint-free "latent space" while still evaluating the objectives in the original, more complex decision space.
The paper demonstrates the CageBO approach on a large-scale police districting problem in Atlanta, Georgia. The results show that CageBO outperforms existing methods in terms of both performance and efficiency.
Technical Explanation
The CageBO framework leverages a conditional variational autoencoder (CVAE) to learn the distribution of feasible decisions in the original high-dimensional decision space. This allows for a two-way mapping between the original decision space and a simplified, constraint-free latent space.
The optimization then occurs in the latent space, where the constraints are effectively handled by the CVAE. The objectives are still evaluated in the original decision space, allowing CageBO to efficiently navigate the implicit constraints often found in public policy applications.
The authors validate their approach through a case study on large-scale police districting problems in Atlanta, Georgia. They compare CageBO to several Bayesian optimization baselines, including methods that explicitly model physical constraints or use latent space representations. The results show that CageBO offers notable improvements in both performance and efficiency.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to addressing the challenges of using black-box optimization for complex public policy problems. The use of a conditional variational autoencoder to learn the distribution of feasible decisions is a clever and well-executed idea.
However, the paper does not address the potential limitations of the CVAE itself, such as the difficulty of training and the potential for bias in the learned latent space representation. Additionally, the case study focuses on a single problem domain (police districting), and it would be valuable to see how well the CageBO framework generalizes to other public policy applications.
Further research could also explore ways to provide formal safety guarantees for the CageBO approach, ensuring that the optimized solutions are truly feasible and desirable from a policy perspective.
Conclusion
The Conditional And Generative Black-box Optimization (CageBO) framework presented in this paper represents a significant advancement in the use of black-box optimization for complex public policy problems. By leveraging a conditional variational autoencoder to learn the distribution of feasible decisions, CageBO can efficiently navigate the implicit constraints often found in these domains.
The promising results on the police districting case study suggest that CageBO has the potential to unlock the power of black-box optimization for a wide range of public policy challenges, ultimately leading to more informed and effective decision-making. As the field of black-box optimization continues to evolve, approaches like CageBO will be essential for bridging the gap between theoretical techniques and real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛠️
0
Conditional Generative Representation for Black-Box Optimization with Implicit Constraints
Wenqian Xing, Jungho Lee, Chong Liu, Shixiang Zhu
Black-box optimization (BBO) has become increasingly relevant for tackling complex decision-making problems, especially in public policy domains such as police redistricting. However, its broader application in public policymaking is hindered by the complexity of defining feasible regions and the high-dimensionality of decisions. This paper introduces a novel BBO framework, termed as the Conditional And Generative Black-box Optimization (CageBO). This approach leverages a conditional variational autoencoder to learn the distribution of feasible decisions, enabling a two-way mapping between the original decision space and a simplified, constraint-free latent space. The CageBO efficiently handles the implicit constraints often found in public policy applications, allowing for optimization in the latent space while evaluating objectives in the original space. We validate our method through a case study on large-scale police redistricting problems in Atlanta, Georgia. Our results reveal that our CageBO offers notable improvements in performance and efficiency compared to the baselines.
Read more8/20/2024
🛠️
0
CAGES: Cost-Aware Gradient Entropy Search for Efficient Local Multi-Fidelity Bayesian Optimization
Wei-Ting Tang, Joel A. Paulson
Bayesian optimization (BO) is a popular approach for optimizing expensive-to-evaluate black-box objective functions. An important challenge in BO is its application to high-dimensional search spaces due in large part to the curse of dimensionality. One way to overcome this challenge is to focus on local BO methods that aim to efficiently learn gradients, which have shown strong empirical performance on a variety of high-dimensional problems including policy search in reinforcement learning (RL). However, current local BO methods assume access to only a single high-fidelity information source whereas, in many engineering and control problems, one has access to multiple cheaper approximations of the objective. We propose a novel algorithm, Cost-Aware Gradient Entropy Search (CAGES), for local BO of multi-fidelity black-box functions. CAGES makes no assumption about the relationship between different information sources, making it more flexible than other multi-fidelity methods. It also employs a new type of information-theoretic acquisition function, which enables systematic identification of samples that maximize the information gain about the unknown gradient per cost of the evaluation. We demonstrate CAGES can achieve significant performance improvements compared to other state-of-the-art methods on a variety of synthetic and benchmark RL problems.
Read more5/14/2024
0
Reinforced In-Context Black-Box Optimization
Lei Song, Chenxiao Gao, Ke Xue, Chenyang Wu, Dong Li, Jianye Hao, Zongzhang Zhang, Chao Qian
Black-Box Optimization (BBO) has found successful applications in many fields of science and engineering. Recently, there has been a growing interest in meta-learning particular components of BBO algorithms to speed up optimization and get rid of tedious hand-crafted heuristics. As an extension, learning the entire algorithm from data requires the least labor from experts and can provide the most flexibility. In this paper, we propose RIBBO, a method to reinforce-learn a BBO algorithm from offline data in an end-to-end fashion. RIBBO employs expressive sequence models to learn the optimization histories produced by multiple behavior algorithms and tasks, leveraging the in-context learning ability of large models to extract task information and make decisions accordingly. Central to our method is to augment the optimization histories with textit{regret-to-go} tokens, which are designed to represent the performance of an algorithm based on cumulative regret over the future part of the histories. The integration of regret-to-go tokens enables RIBBO to automatically generate sequences of query points that satisfy the user-desired regret, which is verified by its universally good empirical performance on diverse problems, including BBO benchmark functions, hyper-parameter optimization and robot control problems.
Read more7/8/2024
0
Automated Computational Energy Minimization of ML Algorithms using Constrained Bayesian Optimization
Pallavi Mitra, Felix Biessmann
Bayesian optimization (BO) is an efficient framework for optimization of black-box objectives when function evaluations are costly and gradient information is not easily accessible. BO has been successfully applied to automate the task of hyperparameter optimization (HPO) in machine learning (ML) models with the primary objective of optimizing predictive performance on held-out data. In recent years, however, with ever-growing model sizes, the energy cost associated with model training has become an important factor for ML applications. Here we evaluate Constrained Bayesian Optimization (CBO) with the primary objective of minimizing energy consumption and subject to the constraint that the generalization performance is above some threshold. We evaluate our approach on regression and classification tasks and demonstrate that CBO achieves lower energy consumption without compromising the predictive performance of ML models.
Read more7/9/2024