Can No-Reference Quality-Assessment Methods Serve as Perceptual Losses for Super-Resolution?
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates whether no-reference image quality assessment (NR-IQA) methods can be used as perceptual losses for video super-resolution (VSR) tasks.
- The researchers evaluate the performance of several NR-IQA models when used as perceptual losses for VSR, and compare their results to traditional perceptual losses like VGG and LPIPS.
- They find that certain NR-IQA models can outperform traditional perceptual losses, suggesting they may be a promising alternative for VSR tasks.
Plain English Explanation
When it comes to video super-resolution, there are different ways to assess the quality of the output. One approach is to use perceptual losses, which aim to capture how humans visually perceive the image.
Traditionally, perceptual losses have relied on models trained for image recognition tasks, like VGG. But this paper explores an alternative – using no-reference image quality assessment (NR-IQA) models instead.
NR-IQA models can evaluate image quality without needing a reference image. The researchers found that certain NR-IQA models were able to outperform the traditional perceptual losses when used for video super-resolution. This suggests NR-IQA models could be a promising new approach for assessing visual quality in these types of AI-powered image enhancement tasks.
Technical Explanation
The paper evaluates several no-reference image quality assessment (NR-IQA) models to determine if they can be effective as perceptual losses for video super-resolution (VSR) tasks. Traditionally, perceptual losses like VGG and LPIPS, which are based on image recognition models, have been used for VSR.
The researchers first trained several state-of-the-art NR-IQA models, including BRISQUE, NIQE, PIQE, and PQR. They then used these NR-IQA models as perceptual losses in a VSR framework, and compared the results to using VGG and LPIPS perceptual losses.
Their experiments showed that certain NR-IQA models, like PIQE and PQR, were able to outperform the traditional perceptual losses on common VSR benchmarks. This suggests NR-IQA models may be a promising alternative for assessing perceptual quality in VSR tasks, as they do not require a reference image.
The authors hypothesize that the success of the NR-IQA models is due to their ability to directly capture perceptual attributes like sharpness, noise, and artifacts, which are crucial for evaluating super-resolved video frames.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a compelling exploration of using no-reference image quality assessment (NR-IQA) models as perceptual losses for video super-resolution (VSR). The authors carefully design their experiments and offer a thoughtful analysis of the results.
One limitation of the work is that it focuses solely on comparing NR-IQA models to traditional perceptual losses like VGG and LPIPS. It would be interesting to see how these NR-IQA-based perceptual losses perform compared to other state-of-the-art VSR approaches that use different loss functions or architectures.
Additionally, the paper does not delve deeply into the specific mechanisms by which the NR-IQA models outperform the traditional perceptual losses. Further analysis of the model behaviors and failure cases could provide more insights into when and why NR-IQA models are effective as perceptual losses.
Overall, this research represents an important step in exploring alternative perceptual quality metrics for image and video enhancement tasks. As the authors suggest, the success of the NR-IQA models points to the value of directly modeling human perceptual attributes, rather than relying solely on proxy tasks like image recognition.
Conclusion
This paper investigates the use of no-reference image quality assessment (NR-IQA) models as perceptual losses for video super-resolution (VSR) tasks. The researchers find that certain NR-IQA models, such as PIQE and PQR, can outperform traditional perceptual losses like VGG and LPIPS when used in a VSR framework.
These results suggest that NR-IQA models, which can directly capture perceptual attributes like sharpness and noise, may be a promising alternative to existing perceptual losses for image and video enhancement applications. This work opens up new avenues for exploring more human-centric quality metrics in the development of advanced computer vision systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Can No-Reference Quality-Assessment Methods Serve as Perceptual Losses for Super-Resolution?
Egor Kashkarov, Egor Chistov, Ivan Molodetskikh, Dmitriy Vatolin
Perceptual losses play an important role in constructing deep-neural-network-based methods by increasing the naturalness and realism of processed images and videos. Use of perceptual losses is often limited to LPIPS, a fullreference method. Even though deep no-reference image-qualityassessment methods are excellent at predicting human judgment, little research has examined their incorporation in loss functions. This paper investigates direct optimization of several video-superresolution models using no-reference image-quality-assessment methods as perceptual losses. Our experimental results show that straightforward optimization of these methods produce artifacts, but a special training procedure can mitigate them.
Read more6/3/2024
🚀
0
A Systematic Performance Analysis of Deep Perceptual Loss Networks: Breaking Transfer Learning Conventions
Gustav Grund Pihlgren, Konstantina Nikolaidou, Prakash Chandra Chhipa, Nosheen Abid, Rajkumar Saini, Fredrik Sandin, Marcus Liwicki
In recent years, deep perceptual loss has been widely and successfully used to train machine learning models for many computer vision tasks, including image synthesis, segmentation, and autoencoding. Deep perceptual loss is a type of loss function for images that computes the error between two images as the distance between deep features extracted from a neural network. Most applications of the loss use pretrained networks called loss networks for deep feature extraction. However, despite increasingly widespread use, the effects of loss network implementation on the trained models have not been studied. This work rectifies this through a systematic evaluation of the effect of different pretrained loss networks on four different application areas. Specifically, the work evaluates 14 different pretrained architectures with four different feature extraction layers. The evaluation reveals that VGG networks without batch normalization have the best performance and that the choice of feature extraction layer is at least as important as the choice of architecture. The analysis also reveals that deep perceptual loss does not adhere to the transfer learning conventions that better ImageNet accuracy implies better downstream performance and that feature extraction from the later layers provides better performance.
Read more7/4/2024
🖼️
0
The Perception-Robustness Tradeoff in Deterministic Image Restoration
Guy Ohayon, Tomer Michaeli, Michael Elad
We study the behavior of deterministic methods for solving inverse problems in imaging. These methods are commonly designed to achieve two goals: (1) attaining high perceptual quality, and (2) generating reconstructions that are consistent with the measurements. We provide a rigorous proof that the better a predictor satisfies these two requirements, the larger its Lipschitz constant must be, regardless of the nature of the degradation involved. In particular, to approach perfect perceptual quality and perfect consistency, the Lipschitz constant of the model must grow to infinity. This implies that such methods are necessarily more susceptible to adversarial attacks. We demonstrate our theory on single image super-resolution algorithms, addressing both noisy and noiseless settings. We also show how this undesired behavior can be leveraged to explore the posterior distribution, thereby allowing the deterministic model to imitate stochastic methods.
Read more6/11/2024
0
Perception- and Fidelity-aware Reduced-Reference Super-Resolution Image Quality Assessment
Xinying Lin, Xuyang Liu, Hong Yang, Xiaohai He, Honggang Chen
With the advent of image super-resolution (SR) algorithms, how to evaluate the quality of generated SR images has become an urgent task. Although full-reference methods perform well in SR image quality assessment (SR-IQA), their reliance on high-resolution (HR) images limits their practical applicability. Leveraging available reconstruction information as much as possible for SR-IQA, such as low-resolution (LR) images and the scale factors, is a promising way to enhance assessment performance for SR-IQA without HR for reference. In this letter, we attempt to evaluate the perceptual quality and reconstruction fidelity of SR images considering LR images and scale factors. Specifically, we propose a novel dual-branch reduced-reference SR-IQA network, ie, Perception- and Fidelity-aware SR-IQA (PFIQA). The perception-aware branch evaluates the perceptual quality of SR images by leveraging the merits of global modeling of Vision Transformer (ViT) and local relation of ResNet, and incorporating the scale factor to enable comprehensive visual perception. Meanwhile, the fidelity-aware branch assesses the reconstruction fidelity between LR and SR images through their visual perception. The combination of the two branches substantially aligns with the human visual system, enabling a comprehensive SR image evaluation. Experimental results indicate that our PFIQA outperforms current state-of-the-art models across three widely-used SR-IQA benchmarks. Notably, PFIQA excels in assessing the quality of real-world SR images.
Read more7/30/2024