Can Prompt Modifiers Control Bias? A Comparative Analysis of Text-to-Image Generative Models
2406.05602
0
0
Abstract
It has been shown that many generative models inherit and amplify societal biases. To date, there is no uniform/systematic agreed standard to control/adjust for these biases. This study examines the presence and manipulation of societal biases in leading text-to-image models: Stable Diffusion, DALL-E 3, and Adobe Firefly. Through a comprehensive analysis combining base prompts with modifiers and their sequencing, we uncover the nuanced ways these AI technologies encode biases across gender, race, geography, and region/culture. Our findings reveal the challenges and potential of prompt engineering in controlling biases, highlighting the critical need for ethical AI development promoting diversity and inclusivity. This work advances AI ethics by not only revealing the nuanced dynamics of bias in text-to-image generation models but also by offering a novel framework for future research in controlling bias. Our contributions-panning comparative analyses, the strategic use of prompt modifiers, the exploration of prompt sequencing effects, and the introduction of a bias sensitivity taxonomy-lay the groundwork for the development of common metrics and standard analyses for evaluating whether and how future AI models exhibit and respond to requests to adjust for inherent biases.
Create account to get full access
Related Work
Prompt Modifiers for Bias Mitigation
Previous research has explored the use of prompt modifiers to control bias in text-to-image generative models. These modifiers can be added to the input prompt to steer the model towards generating less biased images. For example, adding a modifier like "in an inclusive and diverse way" could encourage the model to produce images that represent a wider range of people and perspectives.
Bias in Text-to-Image Generation
Researchers have also surveyed the issue of bias in text-to-image generation, identifying factors like dataset composition, model architecture, and training procedures that can lead to biased outputs. Understanding the sources and manifestations of bias is crucial for developing effective mitigation strategies.
Prompt Engineering Frameworks
Frameworks for optimizing prompts have been proposed, which could potentially be leveraged to reduce biased outputs. These approaches aim to systematically refine prompts to elicit the desired model behavior, including by addressing issues of bias.
Latent Debiasing
Another line of research has explored latent debiasing, which seeks to identify and manipulate the latent representations within generative models to remove unwanted biases. This approach may complement prompt-based techniques for controlling bias.
Plain English Explanation
Researchers have been exploring ways to reduce bias in text-to-image generative models, which are AI systems that can create images based on textual descriptions. One approach is using "prompt modifiers" - additional words or phrases added to the input prompt to steer the model towards less biased outputs. For example, adding "in an inclusive and diverse way" could encourage the model to generate images representing a wider range of people and perspectives.
Researchers have also studied the various sources of bias in these models, such as the data they are trained on, their architectural design, and the training process itself. Understanding where bias comes from is key to developing effective strategies to mitigate it.
Additionally, there has been work on frameworks for optimizing prompts, which could potentially be used to reduce biased outputs. These frameworks aim to systematically refine prompts to elicit the desired model behavior, including by addressing bias.
Another technique is "latent debiasing," which looks at manipulating the internal representations within generative models to remove unwanted biases. This could complement prompt-based approaches for controlling bias.
Overall, researchers are actively exploring different ways to make text-to-image AI systems more inclusive and representative, recognizing that bias is a significant challenge in this emerging technology.
Technical Explanation
The related work section covers several approaches for addressing bias in text-to-image generative models:
-
Prompt Modifiers for Bias Mitigation: Prior research has explored using prompt modifiers - additional text added to the input prompt - to steer models towards less biased outputs. For example, adding a modifier like "in an inclusive and diverse way" could encourage the model to generate more representative images.
-
Bias in Text-to-Image Generation: Researchers have surveyed the issue of bias in text-to-image generation, identifying factors like dataset composition, model architecture, and training procedures that can lead to biased outputs. Understanding the sources of bias is crucial for developing effective mitigation strategies.
-
Prompt Engineering Frameworks: Frameworks for optimizing prompts have been proposed, which could potentially be leveraged to reduce biased outputs. These approaches aim to systematically refine prompts to elicit the desired model behavior, including by addressing issues of bias.
-
Latent Debiasing: Another line of research has explored latent debiasing, which seeks to identify and manipulate the latent representations within generative models to remove unwanted biases. This approach may complement prompt-based techniques for controlling bias.
Critical Analysis
The related work highlights the significant progress made in understanding and addressing bias in text-to-image generative models. The use of prompt modifiers, prompt engineering frameworks, and latent debiasing techniques offer promising avenues for bias mitigation. However, the research also suggests that bias is a complex and multifaceted issue, with various sources and manifestations.
One potential limitation of the prompt modifier approach is that it may not fully address the underlying biases in the model and dataset. While prompt modifiers can steer the model's outputs, they may not fundamentally change the model's learned biases. Integrating prompt modifiers with other bias mitigation techniques, such as dataset curation or architectural modifications, could be a valuable avenue for further research.
Additionally, the effectiveness of prompt-based approaches may be influenced by factors like the specific prompt wording, the model's capacity to understand and respond to the prompt, and the target task or domain. Careful evaluation and refinement of these techniques will be necessary to ensure their robustness and generalizability.
The latent debiasing approach is interesting, but it may be challenging to implement in practice, as it requires a deep understanding of the model's internal representations and mechanisms for bias propagation. Further research is needed to develop efficient and scalable techniques for identifying and manipulating the relevant latent dimensions.
Overall, the related work highlights the importance of continued research and innovation in this area, as the development of bias-aware and inclusive text-to-image generative models is crucial for their ethical and responsible deployment in real-world applications.
Conclusion
The related work on bias mitigation in text-to-image generative models demonstrates the significant progress made in this area, as well as the ongoing challenges. Approaches like prompt modifiers, prompt engineering frameworks, and latent debiasing offer promising avenues for reducing bias, but each has its own limitations and areas for further exploration.
Researchers have made strides in understanding the sources and manifestations of bias in these models, which is essential for developing effective mitigation strategies. However, bias remains a complex and multifaceted issue, requiring a multi-pronged approach that combines various techniques and continuous evaluation.
As text-to-image generative models become more prevalent and influential, it is crucial that the research community continues to prioritize the development of inclusive and representative systems. Addressing bias in these models is not only a technical challenge but also a matter of social responsibility, as these systems have the potential to shape our visual understanding of the world and the way we perceive ourselves and others.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Severity Controlled Text-to-Image Generative Model Bias Manipulation
Jordan Vice, Naveed Akhtar, Richard Hartley, Ajmal Mian
0
0
Text-to-image (T2I) generative models are gaining wide popularity, especially in public domains. However, their intrinsic bias and potential malicious manipulations remain under-explored. Charting the susceptibility of T2I models to such manipulation, we first expose the new possibility of a dynamic and computationally efficient exploitation of model bias by targeting the embedded language models. By leveraging mathematical foundations of vector algebra, our technique enables a scalable and convenient control over the severity of output manipulation through model bias. As a by-product, this control also allows a form of precise prompt engineering to generate images which are generally implausible with regular text prompts. We also demonstrate a constructive application of our manipulation for balancing the frequency of generated classes - as in model debiasing. Our technique does not require training and is also framed as a backdoor attack with severity control using semantically-null text triggers in the prompts. With extensive analysis, we present interesting qualitative and quantitative results to expose potential manipulation possibilities for T2I models. Key-words: Text-to-Image Models, Generative Models, Backdoor Attacks, Prompt Engineering, Bias
4/4/2024
Batch-Instructed Gradient for Prompt Evolution:Systematic Prompt Optimization for Enhanced Text-to-Image Synthesis
Xinrui Yang, Zhuohan Wang, Anthony Hu
0
0
Text-to-image models have shown remarkable progress in generating high-quality images from user-provided prompts. Despite this, the quality of these images varies due to the models' sensitivity to human language nuances. With advancements in large language models, there are new opportunities to enhance prompt design for image generation tasks. Existing research primarily focuses on optimizing prompts for direct interaction, while less attention is given to scenarios involving intermediary agents, like the Stable Diffusion model. This study proposes a Multi-Agent framework to optimize input prompts for text-to-image generation models. Central to this framework is a prompt generation mechanism that refines initial queries using dynamic instructions, which evolve through iterative performance feedback. High-quality prompts are then fed into a state-of-the-art text-to-image model. A professional prompts database serves as a benchmark to guide the instruction modifier towards generating high-caliber prompts. A scoring system evaluates the generated images, and an LLM generates new instructions based on calculated gradients. This iterative process is managed by the Upper Confidence Bound (UCB) algorithm and assessed using the Human Preference Score version 2 (HPS v2). Preliminary ablation studies highlight the effectiveness of various system components and suggest areas for future improvements.
6/14/2024
🤯
Survey of Bias In Text-to-Image Generation: Definition, Evaluation, and Mitigation
Yixin Wan, Arjun Subramonian, Anaelia Ovalle, Zongyu Lin, Ashima Suvarna, Christina Chance, Hritik Bansal, Rebecca Pattichis, Kai-Wei Chang
0
0
The recent advancement of large and powerful models with Text-to-Image (T2I) generation abilities -- such as OpenAI's DALLE-3 and Google's Gemini -- enables users to generate high-quality images from textual prompts. However, it has become increasingly evident that even simple prompts could cause T2I models to exhibit conspicuous social bias in generated images. Such bias might lead to both allocational and representational harms in society, further marginalizing minority groups. Noting this problem, a large body of recent works has been dedicated to investigating different dimensions of bias in T2I systems. However, an extensive review of these studies is lacking, hindering a systematic understanding of current progress and research gaps. We present the first extensive survey on bias in T2I generative models. In this survey, we review prior studies on dimensions of bias: Gender, Skintone, and Geo-Culture. Specifically, we discuss how these works define, evaluate, and mitigate different aspects of bias. We found that: (1) while gender and skintone biases are widely studied, geo-cultural bias remains under-explored; (2) most works on gender and skintone bias investigated occupational association, while other aspects are less frequently studied; (3) almost all gender bias works overlook non-binary identities in their studies; (4) evaluation datasets and metrics are scattered, with no unified framework for measuring biases; and (5) current mitigation methods fail to resolve biases comprehensively. Based on current limitations, we point out future research directions that contribute to human-centric definitions, evaluations, and mitigation of biases. We hope to highlight the importance of studying biases in T2I systems, as well as encourage future efforts to holistically understand and tackle biases, building fair and trustworthy T2I technologies for everyone.
5/3/2024
🛸
NeuroPrompts: An Adaptive Framework to Optimize Prompts for Text-to-Image Generation
Shachar Rosenman, Vasudev Lal, Phillip Howard
0
0
Despite impressive recent advances in text-to-image diffusion models, obtaining high-quality images often requires prompt engineering by humans who have developed expertise in using them. In this work, we present NeuroPrompts, an adaptive framework that automatically enhances a user's prompt to improve the quality of generations produced by text-to-image models. Our framework utilizes constrained text decoding with a pre-trained language model that has been adapted to generate prompts similar to those produced by human prompt engineers. This approach enables higher-quality text-to-image generations and provides user control over stylistic features via constraint set specification. We demonstrate the utility of our framework by creating an interactive application for prompt enhancement and image generation using Stable Diffusion. Additionally, we conduct experiments utilizing a large dataset of human-engineered prompts for text-to-image generation and show that our approach automatically produces enhanced prompts that result in superior image quality. We make our code and a screencast video demo of NeuroPrompts publicly available.
4/9/2024