CausalDisco: Causal discovery using knowledge graph link prediction

Overview

• Causal discovery is the process of identifying new causal relationships from observational data.
• Traditional causal discovery methods often struggle with missing data.
• This paper presents a novel approach called CausalDisco that formulates causal discovery as a knowledge graph completion problem.
• CausalDisco supports two types of causal discovery: causal explanation and causal prediction.
• The approach is evaluated on a benchmark dataset for causal reasoning, and compared to multiple knowledge graph embedding algorithms.

Plain English Explanation

Causal discovery is about finding new causal relationships – how certain things cause other things to happen – based on observational data. Traditional methods for doing this often have trouble when some of the data is missing.

This paper introduces a new approach called CausalDisco that treats causal discovery as a type of knowledge graph completion. A knowledge graph is a way of representing information as a network of related concepts. CausalDisco uses this framework to discover two types of causal relationships: causal explanation, which describes how things are connected, and causal prediction, which forecasts what will happen.

The researchers evaluated CausalDisco on a dataset of simulated videos designed for testing causal reasoning, and compared it to other knowledge graph algorithms. They found that using weighted causal relationships (where the strength of the connection is measured) improved the accuracy of causal discovery compared to not using weights.

Technical Explanation

The key innovation in this paper is framing causal discovery as a knowledge graph completion problem. Specifically, the authors map the task of discovering causal relations to the problem of predicting missing links in a knowledge graph.

CausalDisco supports two main types of causal discovery:

1. Causal Explanation: Identifying the causal relationships between entities in the knowledge graph and the strength of those relationships.
2. Causal Prediction: Using the causal knowledge graph to forecast future causal events.

The authors evaluate CausalDisco on the CLEVRER-Humans dataset, a benchmark for causal reasoning from video data. They compare the performance of multiple knowledge graph embedding algorithms, using two different data split approaches:

1. Random-based split: The typical way of evaluating link prediction algorithms.
2. Markov-based split: A novel technique that leverages the Markovian property of causal relations.

The results show that incorporating weighted causal relations (where the strength of the causal association is represented) leads to improved causal discovery compared to a baseline without weighted relations.

Critical Analysis

The authors acknowledge some limitations of their approach. First, the CLEVRER-Humans dataset is a synthetic dataset, so the findings may not fully generalize to real-world causal reasoning tasks. Second, the Markov-based data split used in the evaluation is a novel technique, and its advantages over the standard random split may require further investigation.

Additionally, the paper does not deeply explore the potential biases or errors that could arise from mapping causal discovery to a knowledge graph completion task. There may be important causal relationships that are difficult to capture in a knowledge graph representation.

Finally, the authors do not discuss the computational complexity or scalability of the CausalDisco approach compared to other causal discovery methods. As the knowledge graph grows, the link prediction task could become increasingly challenging.

Overall, the paper presents a novel and promising approach to causal discovery, but further research is needed to fully understand its strengths, limitations, and practical applicability.

Conclusion

This paper introduces CausalDisco, a novel approach to causal discovery that formulates the problem as a knowledge graph completion task. By representing causal relationships as weighted links in a knowledge graph, CausalDisco supports both causal explanation and causal prediction.

Evaluation on a benchmark dataset for causal reasoning shows that incorporating weighted causal relations leads to improved performance over a baseline without weights. This suggests that the strength of causal associations is an important factor to consider in causal discovery.

While the paper demonstrates the potential of this approach, further research is needed to address its limitations and fully understand its capabilities. Expanding the evaluation to real-world datasets, exploring the biases inherent in the knowledge graph representation, and analyzing the scalability of the methods are all important next steps.

Overall, this work represents an interesting contribution to the field of causal discovery, with implications for explainable AI, counterfactual reasoning, and causal machine learning.